Who sang better? Aneek or Sonu Nigam?

This is the original song by the master of masters Mohammed Rafi Saahab:

[YOUTUBE]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CrHKWJi1dOQ[/YOUTUBE]

This is Aneek's Version: CLICK HERE

This is Sonu's Version : CLICK HERE


Sonu's voice has more body and sweetness here, but Aneek does the expressions better IMO.

Which do you think is better between the two?

PS:
I didn't consider breath control as one is a live version and one is recorded.

Sonu by far.....Actually no comparison between Sonu & Aneek.....Not fair to either...

Aneek sang well but his voice does not have the weight Rafi saab has.....Sonu did very good job....

yeah... body seemed more.... then again it was still live.. so

How can you even compare Aneek with Sonu??? 😈 I am waiting for Shezu to come and rip you apart!!! 😆

Originally posted by: akanna

How can you even compare Aneek with Sonu??? 😈 I am waiting for Shezu to come and rip you apart!!! 😆

naaah she wont

we have an agreement 😛

Originally posted by: gengarjetty2

naaah she wont
we have an agreement 😛

Hmm... looks like some MIDs logged in one after another to vote for Aneek in this thread!! I wonder who would be so keen on making Aneek look better than Sonu?? 😛 😆

Shezu, where are you yaar?? 😃

^^

no, swear on rafi saahab's soul no mid's

Originally posted by: gengarjetty2

^^ no, swear on rafi saahab's soul no mid's

arrey, dont do that yaar!!! Never swear on someone's soul like that - it's not right... I believe ya, but make sure you dont use MIDs to vote! 😉 😃

WOW, two more posts and I am Rockerz!!! 😳

Originally posted by: akanna

arrey, dont do that yaar!!! Never swear on someone's soul like that - it's not right... I believe ya, but make sure you dont use MIDs to vote! 😉 😃

WOW, two more posts and I am Rockerz!!! 😳

oh yeah?

Wonder abt 3 who voted for Aneek? Again i respect their opinion..