Why is DUM gharana at the rock bottom?

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Adi

@enigma6

Navigator

Posted: 19 years ago

#11

[

i completely agree w/you Rohan...i feel its not fair that JL kick up a fuss when their contestants get voted off, when Himeshji lost like Aishwarya, Dilshad & Nannu & has still kept quiet & not said anything, & still gives fair comments to all other contestants.😳

Quote

Ricky

@kangaroo

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#12

After watching the episode on HR's compositions, I am convinced that all 4 of the mentors are BIG HYPOCRITES. They are so fixated and critical on the "Rooh", "Dil", "Sur" and what not when the contestants sing.

But every single of them blatantly applaued the Horrendous singing, even the cows would sing better, from HR in the opening session of the episode.

The same song was sung by Sharib beautifully later on. I think AS came close to insinuating that HR performed really well whereas Sharib sang it well.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Ricky

@kangaroo

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#13

Originally posted by: sindoorfan
[
i completely agree w/you Rohan...i feel its not fair that JL kick up a fuss when their contestants get voted off, when Himeshji lost like Aishwarya, Dilshad & Nannu & has still kept quiet & not said anything, & still gives fair comments to all other contestants.😳

Sorry I would disagree here. Himmeshji constantly cribs about Aishwarya. But thats understandable since the poor guy is just left with one contestant. Only I don't see ID cribbing about anyone much. Then again I may be wrong.

Guys,
HR chose the worst contestants, probably didn't train them well either, eventually all his contestants fell out of the race. The other gharanas started with a stronger set of contestants.

It is not unfortunate that HR is left with only Vineet , who is one of the strongest contenders to the throne. His destiny has been a fallout of his poor selection than anything else, so please sympathize with reason.