Drifting away

Hello,

I 'm an ardant fan of Sa re ga ma pa and has been watching this show for more than 3 years. I enjoy singing and hence never miss any of the episodes.

However of late this musical show is leaning towards being a reality show. I live in the US and have watched a lot of these shows.

I watch sa re ga ma pa for its musical quality and not for anything else.

Any comments ??

Sreehu

Originally posted by: taikoo

Agree that the show is slowly drifting away...

One of the reasons that I am slowly losing interest is the decision in not awarding green card to Debojit when he sang really better than his competitors.

If every judge starts using their own yard sticks as mentioned by Shaan, then this is not a talent show...

A besura singer like Vineet gets a green card and a perfect singer like Debu gets a blue card??? what nonsense!

very well said ...absolutly true

Originally posted by: taikoo

A besura singer like Vineet gets a green card and a perfect singer like Debu gets a blue card??? what nonsense!

Originally posted by: Vedang

Vineet is not great in my opinion but he is certainly not besura. Did you mean Rajeev here as he fits the bill and is the one who got green card over Debojeet?

Vedang, Perhaps I should give you little background about this Vineet guy for you to understand why I am calling him besura.

In an earlier competition before this Challenge 2005, Vineet started a song and went so pathetic in the middle that he himself stopped and in the self comments he said, he did go besura. He said his 'gala baith gaya'.

Again in SRGMP Challenge 2005, too he sang similarly and gave the same reason that his 'gala baith gaya'. Are spectators fools???

I don't know if you watched earlier episodes, where mentors and judges did have minor arguments regarding his 'gala baithna'.

Himesh (cry-baby) creates this hype for all his sishyas. This hype only has carried Vineet so far. I don't think he is even a semi-final candidate. That's my view.

Originally posted by: taikoo

Vedang, Perhaps I should give you little background about this guy for you to understand why I am calling him besura.

In an earlier competition before this Challenge 2005, he started a song and went so pathetic in the middle that he himself stopped and in the self comments he said, he did go besura. He said his 'gala baith gaya'.

Again in SRGMP Challenge 2005, too he sang similarly and gave the same reason that his 'gala baith gaya'. Are spectators fools???

I don't know if you watched earlier episodes, where mentors and judges did have minor arguments regarding his 'gala baithna'.

Himesh (cry-baby) creates this hype for all his sishyas. This hype only has carried him so far. I don't think he is even a semi-final candidate. That's my view.

Originally posted by: Vedang

Exactly, that is my point. Debojit was handed a great injustice last round when he was not given a green card compared to singers like Rajeev and Abhijit. Though I have no particular impression about Rajeev, in my opinion the deserving candidates in that round were -

Debu - Green Card

Abhijit - Blue Card

Now again, we have this Kumar Sanu guy judging Debu against Sharib and Irfan. If you ask me Debu is definitely many notches ahead of S&I. But Kumar Sanu may say Debojit 'Kishore Kumar ke jaise nahi lachka...'

What nonsense?

On one hand you say the singers should develop individuality, on other hand you have a judge (is he jealous???) who wants a talented new comer to show all lachaks and nachaks and mataks, while singing???

Why are they confusing the competitors????

Edited by taikoo - 19 years ago