This year none is as all rounded as Aneek - Page 5

Originally posted by: April2007

Aneek being Begali got overwhelming Bengali votes. If Bengali factor didn't come in play, he worldn't even have made to top three. We should have had Poonam as one of the top three contestants. Amanat and Poonam are way better than Aneek. Even Shekher (judge) said in his interview that Amanat was most deserving of the three final contestants.

Originally posted by: b4begin

We all know Pandit JYashraj's comment and everyone is saying that amanat rocked in ghazal/classical songs. But versatility is a differnt thing.

I have heard much better rendition of Tujhse Naraj.... it is one of the most overhyped songs of amanat. Cant forget his mitwa performance though. Way better than the original.

your welcome.
lol
no hard feelings..
but if amanat was fat,balding and pimply you wouldn't have found koi mil gaya nice.. he sang out of tune..😃
and how am i being biased if his diction was low class? he didn't sound sophisticated.. like javed akhtar said, it is imprtant that u sing udit/rafi/kishore songs in a refined way..
dont get me wrong, i think amanat is awesome in his own way, i even voted for him because of that ghazal round.. but as far as filmy genre is concerned.. he isn't good.

Originally posted by: bellevue

Yes I agree with you that bengalis just love him to death and some did not care for his singing either, so does people from Rajasthan love Raja they had booths set up for him for voting, and Pakistanis and a lot of Indians voted for Amanat only and that is how it works in India. That is how it works with all the contestants in India. Amazingly it has been more than a year since Aneek became the champ but still certain people wont stop bad mouthing the poor guy. How do you know that it was only bengalis who voted for him and not others, do you have some kind of proof? Any way, he is the champ and that too a well deserving one, and nothing can change that.

Originally posted by: Summer3

Personally I love all three and they are great friends and have great respect for each other. Both Raja and Aneek recognise that Amanat was the most learned in music.

Each of them has given some most unforgettable performances. It does not matter to me who is better than who. I always have enough space in my heart for all.

Originally posted by: LuckyJade

@ Summerji,

🤗

I need to tell you something.. My dear friend Bellevue and i were chatting about IF a few days ago and we both mentioned that you have never put anyone, either another IF member or reality show contestant, down. You always have praises for everyone. In fact, i have noticed that in some forums, your posts seem to liven up a "tense" situation. ;) So hats off to you for your positivity!

Originally posted by: LuckyJade

@ Summerji,

🤗

I need to tell you something.. My dear friend Bellevue and i were chatting about IF a few days ago and we both mentioned that you have never put anyone, either another IF member or reality show contestant, down. You always have praises for everyone. In fact, i have noticed that in some forums, your posts seem to liven up a "tense" situation. ;) So hats off to you for your positivity!

Originally posted by: bellevue

Well to each his or her own. Not everyone knows Aneek as well as you do but he is a genius and has a very high mental absorption rate. He not only sings but also has the ability to add in various modifications and adjustments to a song.

But as to personal taste it is quite natural for all to have their own favourites. I would be worried if everyone liked the same singer.😆

Originally posted by: Summer3

You couldn't have said better. I agree totally about respecting individual's rights in appreciating, respecting, and supporting their favorites, but at the same time expect people to respect other's feelings too. Thanks!😊

Edited by bellevue - 16 years ago