Does a particular actor/actress deserves credit for trp success alone? - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

32

Views

4.9k

Users

24

Likes

113

Frequent Posters

typhoon thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#21
good post yaari😳
actors ofcourse do make a difference but its also story director audiance needs good story plus drama and roamnce 😳

qh sj owns in the sense she played zoya sanam seher and of course its good characterisation and sj acting which made it possible 😳😳


qh 1 stoey truned crapped so they need to take leap kabhi😳 were epic now sanam seher rocks see revenge is getting trp so its about story telling😳


no actor alone can bring trp😆

_Lavender_ thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#22

Very Nice post yaari⭐️

Well the opinion regarding this differs from person to person😆...For an online watcher its about there favourite stars n all..so for them the credit goes to that particular actor in general😆...But One thing which is above all TRPs and TVT's that actors and CV's bring is the dedication towards a show called Qubool Hai...If a tv show don't possess brilliant actors a show cant run and to be honest if actors really bring TRP's then Surbhi deserves the whole credit she is with Qh from day 1 till now...n Trp audience too get attached with actors n characters and since she is performing and they r watching her since 2012 in QH...So like most of us Qubool hai is about Zoya Sanam n Seher...So credit should be given to her...But to me Its a Team work in which direction plays a vital role so yeah credit should be given to the whole crew...Only Good Drama brings Trp!
Thnx for Pm🤗
NainaAlex thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#23
Nice post Yaari, thx for the PM...

The success of a show belongs to the entire team, the director plays a very important part ..

A star male/female lead can bring in the fans initially but its the script and characters that will give a loyal audience for the show.
Meself thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#24
Gone are the days when an actor or an actress ruled the roost! These days the story sell and nothing else! Mostly because the viewers are youngsters who can connect more to the story and less to the couple or the lead. Of course leads are important but a sloppy story cannot save the ass.


For instance Madhubla. That series had Vivian and Dhrashti as leads yet it was axed; so I believe its the story! For the better on your platter the more you'll flock to it!
halima_zaka thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: KhatamKahani


😆 You have your dates and weeks mixed up. That was the week of the wedding. I mean not the actual marriage, but the wedding was happening that whole week.

😆
aman1605 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#26
I think Yaari it's not just only an actor but the whole team becoz they all work hard not only actors
minnie2308 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#27
I am by no means a TRP 'gyani', but will take a shot. And I have no facts and figures because I do not follow/understand TRP.😆
Generally there are serials of various cadres/types - mostly drama, some suspense and handful are love stories. Again, there are audiences for each type of of story. And then there are makers for each type of story. This is not to say that makers must not venture into other cadres, but if they do it will be good to do that with caution. Also its not as if the audience for 1 type of story will not want to watch some of the other masala in their current viewing, but again not too much.
Now coming to your question- In its most generic terms, yes every single episode is a product of various different people's hardwork.
But you have posted this on QH forum and I am going to rightly assume its about QH storyline, QH actors, etc...
You spoke about the story! Can you say the current story is going good? Mind you the story is about the characters and their environment and the situations they face and the way they deal with it. How well is the current story of QH progressing? is the plot tight? You will have your opinion, I have mine, No the plot is not tight. The story is not progressing. I haven't watched for more than 2 weeks and still when I catch glimpses on the SBB/SBS(I watch them as they are interspresed with news and also to know which serial I might want to watch), it's pretty much still the same.
At present they are thriving on the short term merriment of surprise factor. Every episode will have something new to torture Sanam with. In general people are not so Sadist. they watch torture in the HOPE that it ends. When it keeps piling with no end in sight, they move on. Because at the end everyone wants the tortured character to get its due.
Most makers who excel in drama, do the torturing for a fixed duration and bring some good times for the leads before a new set of torture/turmoil begin. QH has failed in this department. This in my opinion is a single biggest turn-off for many. Sanam continues to remain tortured and with a sauten around, there seems no end to her plight.
Hence with the current sad state of plot/story, it is not wrong to assume that a certain actor who brings in good looks, acting talent can be a reason for TRP. but mind you this TRP will not be sustained. If the story remains poor, no star power, lead, direction, etc can save it.
Read with a pinch of salt and ignore if you want:: For most serials based on a love story it is extremely important for leads to look good.😆 For a drama based serial it may not be very important and this can be seen from some really flourishing saas bahu sagas (I won't name them😉 but they have extremely average looking actor/actresses in lead roles) How ever for QH2's initial story line it was utmost improtant that the men and women look good, which they did😆. To add to it, our leads can act too. So they've done and offered what they can. Now its all on the story .. if they write a good story, they can go beyond those where acting talent, looks are average. So if you ask me, QH2 is actually thriving on the good looks and acting talent of its lead😉 because the story sucks😛
Edited by minnie2308 - 10 years ago
ssrdj thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#28
Thanks yaari for pm

To be honest, I have never understood the strategy of trp audience, but it is definitely not star factor...may be a star can attract audience foe initial episodes.

Second comes the story..I had earlier thought may be story contributes but nowadays I feel even story is not contributing towards trps...


Nowadays I feel it is just drama that boost trps.Trp audience are looking towards drama...be it logical or illogical...

And the drama effect is definitely a team work..
_shadesnature_ thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#29
...Thank you so much for creating this debate over this topic ."...
Well the question of does superstar or popular actors boost the show or film
It's fifty fifty answer
Sometime yes it does
Sometime don't
But I will go for yes superstar boost the content of show or film ...think practically guys
Take the example of this show
When Karan leave the show it faces upside down tremendously
Raqesh was second option ...asad and Zoya marriage was about to happen but the duscussion was on the Karan ...
I know people were attached to him ..but still ...,...I am sorry if the people didn't agree to my words ...
Now take the example of Bollywood ..nowadays if film is going to release ok let's refer the film of "KHAN BRIGADE " hardly people go for story content but go for the name of "Khan" ...this is the policy but gladly thier films are disappointing but main popular credit always go for them
In Indian television there were show whose story content was much better to the comparison of other show but the TRPS go for popular aCtor to and shows ...
But the second phase is also here some Newly arrived shows of Pakistan like zindagi Gulzar hai ,humsafar ...the main base of popularity was story content and credit goes to everyone who related with the show ...
FILM LIKE BHAG MILKHA BHAG ,MARRY KOM ...KAHANI IT WAS NOT PARTICULAR ACTOR CENTRIC FILM ..
THE MAIN THING IS THAT INDIAN VIEWRS ARE CONFUSED OVER THE BLANCE OF "POPULAR ACTOR ...AND STORY CONTENT ...AND PEOPLE WHO ARE RELATED TO THAT PROJECT ...

BUT I THINK THE THERE SHOULD BE A TRANSFORMATION ON VIEWS OF PEOPLE SO THAT THEY DO NOT MAKE THEM SELVE "ACTOR CENTRIC"
Edited by NATURESHIVANI - 10 years ago
JShukla thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#30
I dont know about the rest, but if they guarantee that they will show KVB for atleast half the program length every day with some good dialogs, some good romance and some good stunts, I shall come back to watch😃 He he...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".