Where QH 2 meets QH1. - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

63

Views

6.2k

Users

21

Likes

260

Frequent Posters

GitaIyer thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#31
res
Unres

Saajan .. reminds me of one of the dumbest way to end a movie. 🤢
QH1, I think the names ayan and asad were interchanged in the synopsis coz right from day 1, it was meant to be asya else zoya would've landed at SM, with shireen being her phoophi instead of Dilshad. Had VM been the first choice to play Ayaan, I'm sure Gul would've gone ahead with the original synopsis. But that's spilled milk, which has been licked by the cat and wiped clean.

Fitting in QH1 into QH2, two brothers, both in love with each other and also the same girl. So. you think halala will be tried this time. Except for the anguish and angst for all the 3 concerned, the equations will remain as they will end up tonight - saahil married.
Rehaan, the question of giving up his love doesn't arise coz Sanam doesn't love him, not yet.
Ahil. the question of taking up his bro's love doesn't arise coz Sanam agreed to nikaah of her own will, well not exactly.

Now, what we will get to see is raw emotions, which Gul is so good at capturing. Hope Rehaan can deliver whatever shade has been decided for him. SJ and KVB, we have seen, are aces when it comes to emotional and angsty scenes.

Lovely post, though, I don't agree QH2 meets QH1 at this point.
And honestly I feel QH2 is focussing more on story and leads ever since IPL ended, than QH1 ever did in its 18 months journey. IN QH1 the story stood at the same place for more than a year and within a week, all the plots were closed.
Back then Asya were madly in love, here its one-sided love all the way, be it Ahil's or Rehaan's.
The OTTs are fixed, and married too, now waiting for them to fall in love.

Edited by GitaIyer - 11 years ago
subhkisonu thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#32

Originally posted by: chicksoup


AyRa did not have Tanveer because it had Haider...so in essence, there is a triangle...most definitely something would have turned up like Tanveer if Vikrant had not left...since he did, Haider turned up.😊

And Dulhan swapping...what I meant is, there was no dulhan swapping in QH!...what was there was what some people crudely called wife swapping...and that is definitely not happening in QH 2!


I actually don't get why Kabhi fans are upset at all...KSG wanted out for health reasons...Zee played dirty..Asad was replaced...

Asad died for the writer the day KSG left the show...so in effect they killed off AsYa...(whereas the initial plan was to end Asad once KSG left in four months..)...and started a fresh story with a new couple. KSG was iconic...Raqesh got the raw deal...but he played his part well...

And KVB gets to give the show a new life...

The PH needs money..The crew and cast needs work...life has to go on...the show must go on...and all fans should move on...

I am saying this because what Kabhi AsYa fans are feeling is nothing compare to the insults Geet fans heaped on IPKKND...to this day, they continue the same.

I will not say QH2 is better than QH1...because QH1 was written leisurely OVER A PERIOD OF MONTHS...It must have been painful for the maker to let go of those characters to accommodate the egos of some people...

QH2 was written while QH 1 was still being shot...so the focus was that much more less..given that, the show is extremely good and definitely a fresh take. I hate to compare it to other shows that have taken leaps...because none have done well like QH2. It may never reach 2nd position...but the fact that it climbed back into top ten is applause worthy.

There are many QH lovers who feel it fell short of IPKKND...so what U feel about QH2 is only natural...😳


And I am not sure what inside sources U R talking about...the fact is there was never any Zoyaan...since AsYa and AyRa were well and truly established by then..😊



Word!!!!👏
gossipgirlxoxo thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#33
Soupji 🤗
kya khoob likhti hain aap. ⭐️
Sanam to bani hi Aahil ke liye hai.
Sari qaynaat unko milaane ki koshish kar rahi hai.
The problem in QH1 was that they tried ZoYaan very late in the game.
AsYa was established.
Here Sanam's feelings are still ambiguous.
Rather she has feelings for Rehan as a friend and Aahil as the go to person in case of any crisis.
In her unconscious state, when she sees death in the face all she can think about is Aahil.
So aag to dono taraf lag chuki hai...
Shaadi ke baad bhadak bhi jayegi.


subhkisonu thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#34
A beautiful analysis Soup as usual!😊I have no words to say.
You know how much I love your posts😳
But today after reading your replies I am falling in love all over again with you😳
You are such a cool person. 😳
Love you😳
Avie thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#35
Great post..
That scene was more than perfect.. Aahil's emotions were portrayed brilliantly by KVB..
BeIndependent thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#36

He can only truly ever be hers...

She can never be his...

i love these lines...😳

Awesome post as always...👏...yes the story fits perfectly here...and is being told nicely...hope they maintain this...QH is getting interesting again..😳😃...No gujaria Gul..plz stay with more with QH..😆😆

surbhisha thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#37
wow so a nice post i just love it lot ...
_Ridz_ thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#38

Originally posted by: chicksoup


AyRa did not have Tanveer because it had Haider...so in essence, there is a triangle...most definitely something would have turned up like Tanveer if Vikrant had not left...since he did, Haider turned up.😊

And Dulhan swapping...what I meant is, there was no dulhan swapping in QH!...what was there was what some people crudely called wife swapping...and that is definitely not happening in QH 2!


I actually don't get why Kabhi fans are upset at all...KSG wanted out for health reasons...Zee played dirty..Asad was replaced...

Asad died for the writer the day KSG left the show...so in effect they killed off AsYa...(whereas the initial plan was to end Asad once KSG left in four months..)...and started a fresh story with a new couple. KSG was iconic...Raqesh got the raw deal...but he played his part well...

And KVB gets to give the show a new life...

The PH needs money..The crew and cast needs work...life has to go on...the show must go on...and all fans should move on...

I am saying this because what Kabhi AsYa fans are feeling is nothing compare to the insults Geet fans heaped on IPKKND...to this day, they continue the same.

I will not say QH2 is better than QH1...because QH1 was written leisurely OVER A PERIOD OF MONTHS...It must have been painful for the maker to let go of those characters to accommodate the egos of some people...

QH2 was written while QH 1 was still being shot...so the focus was that much more less..given that, the show is extremely good and definitely a fresh take. I hate to compare it to other shows that have taken leaps...because none have done well like QH2. It may never reach 2nd position...but the fact that it climbed back into top ten is applause worthy.

There are many QH lovers who feel it fell short of IPKKND...so what U feel about QH2 is only natural...😳


And I am not sure what inside sources U R talking about...the fact is there was never any Zoyaan...since AsYa and AyRa were well and truly established by then..😊




are u comparing Haider with Tanveer??? God save you from Mohit fans... thats quite an insult to Haider... 😕

Coming to why KaBhi fans are upset you will never get that because some people just watch the show but never get attached... if tomorrow Sj is replaced then they will start shipping Bohra and the new replaced girl...sad but thats the hard truth 😉

and about ZoYaan... yes you never know what is going on behind the curtains 😆😆 ...
Edited by _Ridz_ - 11 years ago
vm17 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#39

Originally posted by: chicksoup


I know this is not the first time the original synopsis of QH1 has been invoked on QH2...a few thoughts from my side...😳

Back in October 2012 when I heard about 4 Lions making a new show named Qubool Hai , I was deeply engrossed in another show of theirs by the name Iss Pyar Ko kya Naam doon?'😆


I heard about the synopsis of the show- It was supposedly about two brothers falling for the same girl. I thought I'd never watch the show, because it was a stale concept for me. I had no issues about the right' and wrong' about it...frankly speaking, Saajan' must be the only movie I watched patiently on this...there, if I remember rightly, Sanjay Dutt was the adopted brother of Salman Khan...and other than the general plot, all I remember of the film is the fantastic songs...suffice to say, I thought it was the most boring plot ever!

But Gul gave me a pleasant surprise when I started watching QH carefully after IPK closed down. There was no shadow of two brothers falling for Zoya. (Especially since I caught up with the first episode only months down the line...😉)

By the time the infamous Zoyaan track came, I was quite sure that Asya will never be separated other than a small physical separation. Amidst hues and cries of the immorality of the track, I wondered what it would have been like if Gul had actually stuck to the initial synopsis...

It was to have been about Zoya marrying Ayan first (a marriage of convenience) and him divorcing her immediately( I suppose that can be easily presumed to be of Raziya's doing...) Later Ayan actually falls for Zoya, and seeks Asad's help in winning her over...one of the major hurdles for Ayan would be that he cannot marry Zoya unless she is married and divorced again...that would where Asad would have to step in...and he ends up falling for his Brother's love...This is what I understood the story was supposed to have been like...

An actor like KSG bringing to life an Asad Ahmed Khan who had to fight this overpowering feeling he starts developing for a girl who is out of bounds' for him...and Surbhi as the naive Zoya who does not realise that she has fallen in love with the man who is diametrically opposite to her in every way...When I caught a glimpse of Asad's jealousy and possessiveness in Zoyaan track, I understood why the original plot had been strong and also why it had been modified. A woman being a wife to two brothers...does not sound nice at all...so the writer tried to portray the hero's anguish in a different way.

When I watched the Thursday episode, the twist simply left me in awe. Karanvir Bohra giving life to an AAhil Razaa Ibrahim... a man of no tameez or tehzeeb...when he has to give up his love to a more deserving man, who happens to be his adopted brother...a boy who tails him like a shadow..worships him like a god...

He is the epitome of jealousy when he catches Rehaan whose kahaani has found him...unfortunately, the very kahaani that refused to favour him...yet he has the grace and goodwill to wish his brother the very best...giving up the woman he gave his heart to...

...And very soon he would be called up to be the keeper of his brother's love... Sanam would be his, legally...but morally he would have to fight his feelings with every ounce of will power because he knows exactly where Sanam stands in his life...and his brother's life...

If Rehaan had not confessed to him, Sanam would have been destiny's perfect gift...now she is simply someone loaned to him...

He can only truly ever be hers...

She can never be his...

Even though we have been seeing it for a while, that one Aahil- Rehaan scene...it was perfect...and KVB was more than perfect! The transition from a disappointed lover to a resigned, well wishing brother...it definitely is one of the epic scenes of this season👏...kudos to the writer, director and actor for bringing the concept alive!👏


Amazing post Soup.You have explained the original synopsis very nicely and with KSG playing AAK he would have delivered it perfectly.ALso,VM was good.I think they did'nt want to show halala bcoz they were showing a muslim story for the first time and wanted to play safe.
Most of the people hated the zoyan track but i think it helped to establish some things.Asad learnt that for the sake of Nikhat he had no right to sacrifice Zoya.Secondly he realized the extent to which he loved her,He went to SM when ayan was ill and hugged zoya.Asya were very good during the zoyan track Asad felt jealous and when tanu blackmailed him he didd'nt go for the sacrificial mode and instead unmasked tanveer.HE went to Sm and claimed her replying to all the questions posed by maulvis,Gaffur etc.Zoya who was all for nikah and its sanctity realized that Love is more important than rituals and customs and societal rules.So zoyan served a purpose.
Coming to QH 2 Ahil realized the day he found rehan and Sanam talking and laughing after the "why can't you understand "incident when she filled his glass with ice that Sanam is more comfortable with Rehan.He himself made matters difficult by scolding Sanam after the washing machine incident,Sanam is no Zoya who forgives easily.Sanam is like her dad remembers and she is also judgemental.Ahil was jealous when Rehan showed the ring and was about to walk off when rehan asked him to congratulate and rehan hugged him.Ahil will think of a way to unite Sanam and Rehan.
But billi might be having her own plans and would do something to make Rehan like her.REhan in his nice character is no use for billi.Let's hope Rehan does'nt become negative nad they don't show halala.
nautanki_anu thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#40
Very good post soup 😃.

I think in all this 'one brother sacrificing his love for another' game one thing that will stand out is what does Sanam want. This is exactly what was highlighted in the climax of the movies Saajan and Nikaah. I know it will look jaded if shown in QH2 yet again but it's important for Sanam to spell out what she wants even though there are no marks for guessing that. Finally in this 'bhai woh aapki hain' and the other saying 'nahin bhai woh teri hain' scenario, Sanam is gonna scream and say "Koi mujhse bhi poochhega ke main kya chahti hoon?" 😆.

Of course either ways, no matter what happens and what decision is taken one thing is for sure. Tanveer will go on playing games till the day she kicks the bucket if at all she does 😆.
Edited by nautanki_anu - 11 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".