Islam 101 and QH. Maybe or Maybe Not - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

106

Views

9.7k

Users

37

Likes

453

Frequent Posters

Lavanya.K thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#31
Love the post. I haven't been active on any forum or internet site before this but I keenly read a lot silently and I've observed that the easiest way to bash QH has been to pick on the fact that it is a show based on Muslims. First of all it is so unethical and wrong to point how a religion can be shown in a wrong light through entertainment. Because any religion is so big in itself that it cannot be challenged by one show. QH is piece of fiction just telling a story not showcasing the religion in anyway. There are many shows with Hindu characters showing practices that never happen in that religion too but when it comes to fiction you have to have more freedom and not be bound. Because no matter what the religion be it is way too big and beyond a show. And in all cases things shown on any form of entertainment are creative liberty..
_Seera_ thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#32
res
unres

Before mods decide to even shut this down I would like to voice out my opinion as well...

yesterday I res 1st position on Gitey's post "Analysing Humaira" and was about to unres it when I got the same PM.

reading it I was super annoyed and super irritated... Like rivs even i got Trending Details everyday and i ignored them as daily routine cos i find it total waste of my and the person who PMed me's time.

I did do some research on Islam after I got the PM.. I am a non muslim but I do believe that all religion at the end of the day give us same moral values... and i also dont believe any religion be it "Hinduism" or "Islam" should be used as backdrop to accomplish your ulterior motives.

Amber... i am happy you made this post.. and agree completely that people who want to learn teachings of Islam should even watch it...

Some pointers -

1. Nikhat - She was always dusky... When KSG was Asad and when RV is Asad!.. So dont bring the skin colour issue now... Entire world is racial... No one can change it... If we were not their wouldn't have been movements against it.. So stop talking about it...

2. Zoyaan - It was stupid but hey thats daily soap... they are meant to be stupid.. It's a invalid Nikaah that's all... But happened right?? They filed for divorce also! So even Adas, Zoya moved on with it... Why don't you do it??? Move on! They hv forgotten it even happened!

3. Nikah is solemnized at a Mausoleum - I couldn't find anything about it on internet... But my thoughts.. It was used as backdrop and the nikah didn't happen inside the TAJ so I guess they did not do anything wrong! And TAJ is symbol of love... If they wanted to go their for their Nikah thats their wish!

4. Alcohole consumption - Did they show it?? Rivs comment about KHAN's was right! Sue them first and then talk about QH

5. Invalid Nikah at Taj because of Wali - Well as far as this is concerned I have two points -

A divorcee can marry without a wali in Insal (I am considering Zoya as Divorcee)

By indian Law if a muslim women wants to marry she doesn't need to have a wali. There are other countries also who make this possible like Turkey, Bangladesh

I still believe explaination above is not needed as its just a fictional show. We have tolerated even worst scenarios than that... So lets leave QH's fate to those who wants to watch it...

As far as the "CAUSE" is concerned if your really want to fight for something fight for those who can not fight for themselves... Not for those who don't even respond to your request!

Edited by _Seera_ - 11 years ago
subhkisonu thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#33
A much needed post👏Even I am seeing so many posts regarding these things, and I was thinking that do people take a daily soap so seriously? In so many Indian soaps they show that the leads are getting married innumerable times does it happen in real life?😆And whenever they are showing some Hindu festival is celebrated in QH people complains a lot, but I can say from my personal experience that I have lots of Muslim friends since my childhood who celebrated Durga puja, Diwali and Holi very enthusiastically with us and we celebrated Eid with them. Now I am staying in abroad and there is one Muslim guy in my hubby's office who celebrates all the festivals with us. If they are showing something which is against Islam then trust me they are showing many things against Hinduism as well😊. We shouldn't take a daily soap so seriously,those are just for the entertainment purpose😊



Edited by subhkisonu - 11 years ago
AyRa_Rocks thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#34
All I could say is I'm totally in love with this post.
soniasharmin89 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#35
even i m muslim too.i just want to say its just a show and people should treat it like this.

llovely post.
Shayshay92 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#36
This was a great post!! I loved it too much! Being Muslim myself I like the way the show has gone but people shouldn't take it to heart! I love the mashallahs and the inshallahs and even the "Allah mia what's wrong with you Mr. Khan!" QH is different for having Muslim characters and it's not Islam 101 but does she's some light like praying which is great! I think there's nothing wrong with how QH represents Islam because believe it or not some Muslims are exactly like this, the killing and all!
Edited by QHGeetLova - 11 years ago
livelytanu thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#37
Wow I love this post.
I don't have time for an elaborate reply since I have an exam in March but yeah I loved the replies here too.
delena90 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#38

Originally posted by: GitaIyer

Amber for your🤗

and
👏for your post.

Res
Finaly got time to unres,

When twitters and hate mails and boycotting of the serial couldnt do the trick, finally religion was dragged in to help their cause.

And the cause - Closing down a serial
And the reason for the cause - An actor was replaced

Cant even say - grow up, move on. Bcoz these words are not to be uttered.
I hope all these so-called QH haters at least read your post and remember it next time before bringing religion into entertainment. But they will only see what they want to see.



There's a reason I love Bernard Shaw.

As for the who the post is intended for - I am sure it has flown over their collective heads. Oh well.
...MonaCo... thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#39

Originally posted by: gossipgirlxoxo

Last time , I checked QH is not ISLAM 101.
Believe me If I wanted to learn more about Islam, the last place would be daily soap with Romance and Drama as the backdrop.
Watching of any kind of Television is prohibited in Islam.
So people who say that QH is showing Islam in bad light should realize that perfect Muslim(If such a thing exists ) should not be watching any TV with singing, dancing or Non Mahrams acting, touching each other.
So let us for the sake of sanity declare that these are the lessons learnt
1. That if you happen to be in a situation like Zoya and have lost your parents in a fire of Doll Factory conspiracy please do not name your would be Husband's Mom as wali. It will be an invalid Nikah. Thank god most of us are not orphans and have atleast one male relative/friend to act as a wali.
I was really hoping Haider would be far more interested in watching the NIKAH of his chutki than bedding Humeira. So I was pretty disappointed that the cvs have totally ignored the haider-chutki relationship since quite a few episodes now. It is also sad that Aapi Jiju can not come. COME ON, WHY ???

2.Please do not abuse technology irresponsibly. Like No talking while driving , there should be law that clearly states no Talking while in Ghoonghat or Sehra ! Because in a soap called QH the leads were accidentally married in a community Nikah. Most likely we will not end in such a situation, but If unfortunately we do please remember that your Nikah is Invalid so no worries there.
I better not even open my mouth, here right? I mean, what was the point of showing the invalid nikaah if they were never going to broach that topic again? May be in the future?

3. Nikah can be solemnized in front of a Masoleum so there, I can't help you . You will be deemed married, best don't visit Agra because I can't find a flaw in this one :(
4. And I agree that Alcohol consumption is not allowed in Islam. You are no longer a perfect Muslim if you consume alcolhol. But sadly many muslims are imperfect muslims.
5. Multiple marriages are allowed in Islam under very strict rules, but in India , In Bhopal hardly anybody follows any kind of rule to a T.
To add to those points.
1. Tanveer should certainly not sleep around.
2. Farhan should not do stuff to Nikhat
3.Haider should not sleep with Humeira.
4. Razia should not have murdered Zainab.
5. Ghazia should not have trapped Rashid.
6.Rashid shouldn't have left Dilshad in pregnancy.
7. Ghaffur shouldn't have cheated.
8. Zoya shouldn't have stayed in Asad's house.
6. Blah Blah Blah.
Looks like going back in time QH should not have even aired.
Because the whole premise is non Islamic.
It is said in Islam that if you say ill about others , gossip, backbite it's like you are eating your brother's flesh.
Please bookmark this post as just in case people mistakenly learn Islamic principles from QH, their doubts can be cleared.
I wanted to reply to Riv's post Yesterday but it was closed before I could.
Here is the link to that post.


Great Post Amber, as always. Thanks for this 101. As such even when our soaps show :Hindu: traditions they are always messing up... I have learnt to take these illogical things with a pinch of salt (or haven't I?) and not let them hurt my religious sentiments... And, I am glad you can do so too.
BabajiKaThullu thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#40
Awesome Post gossipgirl 👍🏼

I am Gujju and I know there are many shows based on Gujju culture and religions and they showed lots of stuff but its entertainment channel .

where is religion and all in this? 😳

I sometimes really wonder Log bolne se pehle Kya KHAATE honge ?

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".