I am one of those who feel that the rape charge doesn't go with humeira character. My thoughts
1. even during rajani track she was uncomfortable to sleep with her so called husband and slept in razia's room.
2. Suicidal humy - she took revenge by hurting herself but did not hurt others.
3. Zoyaan - even though everyone was sympathising with her, I found her selfish in that track. She knew that nikhat's life was in danger, yet she was only thinking about her pain.
4. Current track - right from day one she has been taking her anger on zoya, though this time it is justified. But she has not harmed zoya even though she saw zoya insulting her parents and derooming them.
5. Lastly she has been brought up with lot of tameez and tehzeeb. A rape charge is very serious. In dil, Madhuri's character was a bold modern girl. Here humeira is a traditional girl.
Just my POV.
It's a direct lift-off from one of my favorite movies and a scene done to death. The only saving grace was the acting and the pace at which it is being executed.
Mine too. Both aamir and Madhuri just killed the scene. I can still remember that scene. To be fair, ketki and mohit were good. Both are actors to watch out for.
Edited by GitaIyer - 11 years ago