My Observations : Please feel free to ignore

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

gossipgirlxoxo

@gossipgirlxoxo

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

#41

Originally posted by: GitaIyer
Amber your posts are too good to be ignored.🤗
Fully agree with you, if we cannot say good about something, then not saying anything is the next best option.

Criticism should be constructive, not destructive. Most of the posts are nowadays bordering on the line of hatred.

What is Qh - after all a show on the idiot box. Treat it as such. Anyone visting QH IF would think ASYA separation and Zoyaan are a national, rather international issue and Gul is the next Hitler.

WORD !

Quote

gossipgirlxoxo

@gossipgirlxoxo

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

#42

Originally posted by: Meaningful
Wow! Your thought process is amazing! So are your writing skills! 👏
I cannot believe you are so young - I read your age in one of your posts

Age is just a number my dear !

And Thank You !

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

gossipgirlxoxo

@gossipgirlxoxo

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

#43

Originally posted by: mamta-s
@ gossipgirlxoxo,
First ...may I also address you as Amber please ...as I see others do so .

I am in sync with your reasoning . Also I realise it is the idiot box and I guess what you are suggesting is to not to take it seriously . But this idiot box is a very powerful medium and what is broadcast should be taken a tad more seriously ..its range of influence is increasing at a rapid pace here in this country .

While we are trying very hard to eradicate age old customs that are regressive ,popular shows telecasting such rituals is indeed a very negative approach . Society and individuals must be made aware of such things ..as you said life is not a bed of roses and each one has to bear the consequences of their actions ..as is being shown in QH right now !

The problem is not in the theme but in the execution . The Zoyaan track may have planned from the start ..as Ayaan had said @ the start itself ...Bhaijan aapke aur mere beech koi ladki hi aayegi ...so it was expected that this would come ...but the manner in which it has been envisaged is immature and unacceptable :(

For my part the comments have always been towards constructive criticism . There is a very fine line between the ludicrous and the sublime when narrating a sequence on screen . GK has to ensure that those she hands over the reigns to must keep that in mind .

It is understandable that Zoya is now confused ..her inner self is in turmoil already ...should she go back to Mr Khan or maintain her vows / She is being given the opportunity to return but she herself is now prolonging her stay ...and that is required for the story .

But may we please be shown this in a sleeker , more mature manner? That is all that we are asking ! Why do we have to be subjected to Haseena's gross antics ...her face smeared with halwa !!!!

Yes you may call me Amber :).

I feel that the original synopsis was in itself messed up, in the sense that Zoya did not land in Ayaan's house and the mixing of names and other stuff , so I prefer to believe that since starting Gul Planned this like this only that is broadly speaking . They change details along the way but I don't think that she changed her story in a major way. I am one of those people who watch it just once and sometimes even skip episodes. What I feel is that, the original synopsis was done totally wrong , otherwise why would Gul take 11 months to build up AsYa. The reason it is not being done in a sleeker and mature way is that , it preserves AsYa. She does not want to touch AsYa and these trivial ways are making sure that AsYa remains untouched. You are I think one of the most senior person here, you know it that tough situations don't last , tough people do ! Also this show is for Indian audience , and the masses appreciate Haseena on their screen ... We all like characters we can relate to... Also my parents and grandparents are from Bhopal, this still happens ... Not only in Bhopal but many places in India.

I just want to see how this plays out :)

Edited by gossipgirlxoxo - 11 years ago

Quote

gossipgirlxoxo

@gossipgirlxoxo

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

#44

Originally posted by: starsinmyeyes

That in bold is exactly my problem Amber...when you read the original synopsis you will realize it is different from what she is showing even now..this dishonesty bothers me

..chalo...I will tell u I have no issues if ZoYaan finds it's purpose...Humeira ko insecure karke kya milega? It was Ayaan who wasn't in love with her and he realized that when Vikram entered her life...10th september ko yeh track shuru hua tha..last epi aired on 25th october...and that was the first real important showdown Razia and Zoe had...one and a half month almost...😲

I agree with u also that this was the only way she could have entered SM without any reveal...but my question is..are the ZoYaan eyelocks and hugs necessary at this stage of the show...I agree they are all innocent and friendly and there to make Humz jealous? But this execution instead of making Humz jealous is corroborating this in my mind that Gul is fully capable of a romantic ZoYaan...the way every character was butchered to make Zoe look good..she will be too..and that is unfair...

If this track ends the way u see it...then I have already said, I will watch each and every episode I missed...but...making a mockery out of marriage does not sit well with me...and honestly..the drama becomes repetitive too...itna Ramadan track mein emphasis diya only to have Tanveer return again...the horrendous miscommunication between Asad and Zoya...the glaring loopholes in the script...if 4 lions are as seamless as u say they are...as I said...for my sake I would love to see them pull this off...honestly

And Amber..aap forum mein negativity se bothered ho...just think audience show ki never ending negativity se kitni bothered hogi...since May..Tanveer is winning...5 months Amber...we are all exhausted..but the reason we are around is that we hope it will return to some normalcy...and trust me as each day passes, hopelessness is clouding the hope

Shruti , that original synopsis was kind of like Nikah movie, but right from Day one it did not happen that way, she fell in love with Asad not Ayaan... And if if we fix the names , the storyline right from the start totally different.

Zoya set up relationship with KV people that too three of them months, she should be given enough time to form her equation with SM people.

It's not only about Humeira being jealous Shruti ... It's not about ZoYaan , it's about ZoHu, their relationship will start on a bad note, Razia will poison Humeira, Zoya saves Humeira, Humeira will be responsible for the ultimate downfall of Razia, because there is only one person whom Razia loves in her own way that is Humeira... QH is not only AsYa and ZoYaan and AyRa ... It's so much more, they have to bring warring families together, all these things will have a purpose ...a person like AAK changed... Zoya had a big part to play but without Tanu as a catalyst was it possible...?

The point is she is not making a mockery of the marriage.

Audience knows that it is not a valid Nikah and the 4 players involved do not believe in paper marriage, they were tricked and coerced into it by destiny and community. Shruti my personal opinion here is totally different but I understand what GK is doing here. Like AAK said it's a Haadsa not aVaada

Quote

gossipgirlxoxo

@gossipgirlxoxo

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

#45

Originally posted by: mamta-s
One more thing,
As you said ..and I have also said this elsewhere ...the Asya story has to move to the next stage ...some maturity in their relationship has to come about . It is wonderful the way their story progressed so far and the viewers can not be blamed for being suddenly jerked down to reality. And this rude shock is unacceptable because of another strong factor in any telecast ..the pull of the actors !!!

There is no doubt that KSG has the skills to become every young girl's fancy ...he drips romance on screen like no other young actor and has captured the hearts of the majority of youngsters on this forum .SJ, though the main protagonist in GK's narrative gets her sheen from him . You remove KSg from the scene and the his fans will no doubt will be inconsolable ! It a double blow ...Asya split apart and no kSG on screen :(

It will need a masterstroke to get all viewers back to QH ! Some maturity is required in the execution .We will be there as we know that love matures with the pain of separation ! KSG is again marvellous for this too ..its SJ who is lagging behind unfortunately ..she is a different actress without him ! Director's please note !

KSG as every young girls fantasy ? I have no opinion on that. I am very neutral . His life and personality is none of my business. Yes KSG as an actor ! I think He is good. Asad as every young girls fantasy that I can understand. I am very positive about the future of QH. It still has a lot of potential.

Quote

mamta swaika

@-ajna-

Sparkler

Posted: 11 years ago

#46

@ Amber :)

I am neutral too ..and do not know much about any actor's personal life . But as a career educationist I do recognise excellence ..and my personal view is that KSG is a marvellous performer and that he is a team player ..he adds lustre to all his co-actors performances too !

Yes I am probably the oldest here ..in years but not in the duration of my stay here :) Am still groping and struggling to acclimatize...so please excuse the lapses and bloopers I may make .

I have to share that I do not subscribe to the common view that the execution has to suit the masses ..we may endeavour to raise the bar for them all too ! I am aware that ' such things ' happen all around us ...some have happened in my life too ..but we can bring some finesse to the show .

But that is entirely my personal opinion as an educationist my life's purpose was to raise standards wherever and however possible :)

I hope I am within forum decorum to share my views .