Shame on Gul for turning this into a religious issue

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Mohini19

@Mohini19

Voyager

Posted: 11 years ago

#11

Originally posted by: Hodda
We should all know by now that when it comes to Gul, common sense makes to sense.
I don't hate the woman. I just think she discounts the intelligence of her viewers greatly.

She keeps on mentioning TRPs & aunties that watch the show...
I wonder if she actually thinks that those women are so stupid to a point that they'll buy the crap going on in the current track. So demeaning, in my opinion.

Love & Peace to All!

No question about the fact that she thinks that viewers are brainless.

But, isn't that true for those so called viewers who contribute to the TRPs? I wonder what percentage of Indian viewers (not those on IF here) question such dumb tracks?

The truth is that the writers and producers continue to come up with crap because they know that crap sells amongst Indian audience who constitute TRPs.

Quote

Baby

@shami9

Beginner

Posted: 11 years ago

#12

no not at all this nika is not valid.i am amuslim.in islam bride aor groom ki marzi ke bina nika jaez nahi he.yeh islami taleem ke khilaf he aor yeh sahi nahi.yeh to sirf aor sirf mazhab ki badnami he.please stop it.we are very much hurt about this trace.kissi bhi mazhab mei zabbarasi nahi ki ja sakti.please respect the religions ruls.pehle mazhab ke bare mei malumaat le karr kahani likhei .

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

sanamkhan23

@sanamkhan23

Inactive

Posted: 11 years ago

#13

yeh its abig shame as muslim im feeling so bad iwant who rliving in india should issue fatwa against makers they r showing crap 1 culprtis gul then mufties and then others who rforcing girl to accepted invalid nikaah i want to clear it was not any kind of nikaah kya ayaan zoya mufti ka pass gaye jmy nikaah karna kya unhone kaha nhi then if mufti wasknows ayaan alredy kya zoya ne muft ko apni detail di nhiii aur jaisy nikaah dikhaya woh aik joke se kum nhi then 2 they r calling her his wife it s shame and asking her accept this nikaah girl is running she dont want this nikaah so mufti cant force and also others its invalid too its very serious matter gulg did big mistake by showing this incae if some films were shown on islaam some people r forcing girls for nikaah there was amasg in the end they showd in khuda k liye pakistani film girl was forced she didnot accepted it was clear masg it was forced but what gulis trying tosay icant understand nikaahis stiilll invalid according ruls so how they will live in 1 room how they will falll how they will touch how they willl show something else need totake action against gul and iwillbe not surprised if show going off sooon resaon is gulkhan

Quote

call me- East

@eastmeetswest

Voyager

Posted: 11 years ago

#14

Originally posted by: A.Hajnal
I thing I HATED the most is that she is missusing this whole "Nikaah is Islamic way" things...I have always thought that in Islam, these forced and it-just-happened Nikaah doesn't existe...and while watching Indian serials where a sindoor or something like that would make a girl someone's wife, even if she didn't wanted it...I used to stand tall and Thank God that this all didn't happen in Islam...And now she is showing that This all RUBBISH is an Islamic way to get married to someone...?? 😲
She have some stupid kind of understanding of her OWN religion...

besides this the lines that she is using is also tantamount to blasphemous..gul u better catch urself..

Quote

Javeria

@Surbhiholic55

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

#15

Originally posted by: A.Hajnal
<font face="Comic Sans MS, Times, serif" size="2">I thing I HATED the most is that she is missusing this whole "Nikaah is Islamic way" things...I have always thought that in Islam, these forced and it-just-happened Nikaah doesn't existe...and while watching Indian serials where a sindoor or something like that would make a girl someone's wife, even if she didn't wanted it...I used to stand tall and Thank God that this all didn't happen in Islam...And now she is showing that This all RUBBISH is an Islamic way to get married to someone...??😲</font>
<font face="Comic Sans MS, Times, serif" size="2">She have some stupid kind of understanding of her OWN religion...</font>

Well said

Quote

call me- East

@eastmeetswest

Voyager

Posted: 11 years ago

#16

apparently this gul dont have a clue as to the seriousness of religion in islam.. it is not play and amusement as stated in Allah's holy words.. and she is making entertainment out of it.. i hope she knows that she is playing with fire and those who are protraying it also... there are somethings u just cant and dont joke about.. and she better aslo quit this Allah miya line.. Take not the name of God in vain..gul go and get some knowledge from the authentic teachings not fabricated.. and i dont care who doesnt see the seriousness of this..

Quote

Jazlyn Lodhi

@Nutella.

Rocker

Posted: 11 years ago

#17

I have a problem with certain religious aspects depicted in the show from a logical standpoint. Things aren't coming full circle with the story line and the only way out is to make stuff more convoluted by developing new traditions and rites of passages.

However, Qubool Hai never promised to serve as a blueprint for the proper depiction of Islam. It's a fictional show and for that reason, I am willing to roll my eyes and look past this. People have better means of acquainting themselves with the workings of Islam. All of which are better than a TV show.

I doubt other shows on TV portray Hindu practices correctly. I don't see people harping this string with other religions. Bits and pieces of the religion are taken to move the storyline forward. That is all.

And I say all this as a Muslim. Since I am willing to watch this story line pan out with batting an eye, does that mean shame on me too? I would hope not.

Edited by -Jazzy- - 11 years ago

Quote

soni raj singh

@SONIRAJ1

Dazzler

+ 3

Posted: 11 years ago

#18

Originally posted by: Mohini19
Religion is such a touchy and sensitive issue. But, apparently, it is a joke in Indian telly shows where the writers would go to any extent to degrade a religion, a certain section of society or community.

Sensitivity and being considerate for all sections of society and religion has no meaning in our shows.

The unfortunate part is that there could be at least 10 different good ways to move QH's story forward. But, no. the writers had to come up with the most ridiculous and most controversial way of moving the story forward.

I know that people like me (and many others on IF) who live in the US do not constitute the so called TRPs. But, I just read the WUs. They are enough to make my blood boil. Awesome job, writers and gul (😡😡😡).

PS: It is just amusing (read foolish, dumb, and brainless) to see Haseena Bi moving the story forward. Everything that happens in the life of our leads is highly driven by Haseena.

Well done n Gr8 post 👏👏

Quote

sanamkhan23

@sanamkhan23

Inactive

Posted: 11 years ago

#19

all w can do is she should give some masg at the end itis invalid but idont think she willl

Quote

soni raj singh

@SONIRAJ1

Dazzler

+ 3

Posted: 11 years ago

#20

Originally posted by: -Jazzy-
I have a problem with certain religious aspects depicted in the show from a logical standpoint. Things aren't coming full circle with the story line and the only way out is to make stuff more convoluted by developing new traditions and rites of passages.

However, Qubool Hai never promised to serve as a blueprint for the proper depiction of Islam. It's a fictional show and for that reason, I am willing to roll my eyes and look past this. People have better means of acquainting themselves with the workings of Islam. All of which are better than a TV show.

I doubt other shows on TV portray Hindu practices correctly. I don't see people harping this string with other religions. Bits and pieces of the religion are taken to move the storyline forward. That is all.

And I say all this as a Muslim. Since I am willing to watch this story line pan out with batting an eye, does that mean shame on me too? I would hope not.

kind u info Most Hindu background shows r not making fun with religion , All shows r follows with all rules .. !