AsYa: Please? - Page 5

Originally posted by: sujataraje

did i interpret his PLEASE wrong???????😕 i just said what i felt...i know i am pretty bad at analysing all this stuff😆

I truly feel that the Asad and Zoya confrontation scene was very subtely executed(though I believe that they could've ditched 'Tum hi ho' in that situation) but the dialogue and the way they were rendered was very subtle. I could actually relate to Zoya!
Even the desert song sequence worked for me(which to be honest only left me bemused in all other shows it was used in) Maybe some of our fellow members were expecting some high voltage melodrama.
P.S: The background tune in the scene when Asad-Zoya enter the Dargah was just so...well what should I say...filled with that essence of Divinity!

Originally posted by: -ARLover-

I agree with you. I also did not find anything bad in the episode. I really liked it, alot.

And yes, that one 'please' held so much of desperation, so much of love and need. It depicted so much. It was beautiful the way he said it.

Great analysis 👍🏼

Originally posted by: MoronsKiMallika

Thank you.😃...The confession and the pleading was to get Zoe back in his life. But Zoe rejected Asad and this is not going to make a very happy picture. Ek 'naa' bahot kucch bigaad saktee hai.

Originally posted by: delena90

Frankly from a narrative pov the confession was just not needed...at least not yet. The entire episode felt rushed and i have to question the PH's decision to go to Ajmer.

Karan and Surbhi are great actors, there is no set in the world that would have made their angst or chemistry less palpable. What are they doing in Ajmer if everything but two scenes have already been shown to us?

While I understand the song was used to describe Asad's emotion it was entirely too long and frankly I am more interested in seeing the story move. I know Asad is in pain. I know Asad doesn't deserve this. I know Zoya is in pain. I know Zoe doesn't deserve this. I don't need a song to tell me that they are devastated. The writers over the last week did well in showing us how shattered these two are.

Maybe today is a set up but still if all that happens in Ajmer is a couple of confrontations, a short reunion and a fall from a cliff I don't know what I am supposed to make of it.

On points of AsYa today - they were great as usual. The please killed me too.

Good post Vic.

Originally posted by: Madame_Noddy

Vicky madam, just curious, are you a writer? if you are, im not surprised one bit, and if ur not, you should seriously consider taking it up professionally. Seriously. What beautiful analysis! Itna achha agar koi mujhe likhne ko bolega to mujhe mahino lag jayenge, sachi!

Coming to the episode, i loved it. I dont know what others were expecting from the desert scene, but this is exactly what i had expected. just perfect. And the most beautiful scene in the epi for me was Asad's expression when he saw Zoe in the ajmer palace...aansu aagaye aaankh mein😭

Beautiful episode!

Very nice post..

Originally posted by: starsinmyeyes

Episode jaisa bhi ho Vicky Ma'am...aapki analysis hamesha ek naya perspective deti hai...it is always spot on...for me, like u, the entire epi summed up into that one 'Please?'...Zoya's effort to not breakdown, unable to look into his eyes lest her resolve fails...was heart rending...sach maano toh aaj pehli baar Zoya ke chehre pe darr dekha maine...she was scared that if she looks into his eyes she will melt like butter...and so she left...

Asad's honest, not asking for anything in return confession took my breath away..nothin OTT...just two people madly in love saying to each other what they felt with complete honesty...this transparency in emotions defines AsYa for me...

Baaki episode mere dil ko itna nahi chhoo paaya...but then i really did not care as long as i got that beautiful confession...i only felt bad for Karan and Surbhi because the sequences they shot did not do justice to their hardwork...strictly my opinion😊

Oh..the "please" was disheartening to say the least and he said it after saying that he will love her till his last breath and that the truth for him will not change even if Zoya disbelieves him and doesn't forgive him. For some reason, I'have always considered words like these coming from the usual the tv hero's mouth cheesy ...but they actually made sense for me in Asad's case. I loved his simple and truthful confession. It was touching that he just wanted to let her know what he felt about her...without expecting anything from her. Though when his I love you kept echoing 😆...I lowered my expectation a little 😆...but when he said mohabbat karta hoon...I liked it.

Originally posted by: SANYAGAUTAM13

Lovely post as usual. But what I liked most was what I wanted to say but u put it across beautifully.

I wish Zoya would have melted a little bit for him , and almost tried to forgive him and accept him with all his faults, after all that is true love all about.

Her realizing nothing happened between him and TAnveer and then going back to him, make her a little judgemental, but I guess trust was always a big issue for them , she had put him on a pedestal always, so the downfall was too much of a betrayal.

Do u think it is Tanu on the other line, looks like it, will Tanveer " s face will be. Revealed toAsad or he will go back broken and say yes to TAnveer.

I think that to be a more likely scenario