Letter to BCCC - See P41 Update - Page 35

Originally posted by: narangi314

Holy Canoli!

People are paranoid !!! There's no conspiracy, there's no enmity with other shows or with the actors here...I wish people would take the trouble to actually read the letter before making such unwarranted accusations!

Originally posted by: adeeti10

🤣 You crack me up girl! But every word you said... True!

Originally posted by: narangi314

show mein saazish, forum mein saazish...and there are still people who wonder about the impact of TV?! 😆

Originally posted by: adeeti10

Implied something to that effect earlier today in response to one of those posts! 😃

@Rupnzel people don't get influenced either by villen or hero of a hindi tv serial.
it was showing tulsi kills mom in law,son.
it show parvati send her grand son to jail.
it showing kashis marry four times and his 3rd husband,4th husband married her sisters.
it shows manav gets slapped by 10times by mom in law and 3 times by archana when he was not guilty.
i don't see any of those happen reality
people know its not for real and its fiction.

and i wanted to know why the same people don't send bccc for their previous show which gives romantic angle to violance.

seconed thing mother means earth for asad.
a mother who is also his father.
apert from mother and sister who is own for asad.
nobody do you understand how much insecurity he has.
but still i am saying asad does a wrong thing by slapping zoya.
i also mentioned in if posts it could better if they avoid it.
i also make a thread about asad should not taunt zoya about parents.

but you people are too much taking a scene with real life and dragging the issue 8-9 days and saying same thing on 20thread.what is the point of too much repeatation.do you have anything new to say.

its not a normal behaviour.so we found this behaviour is very suspicious.

and yes you people single out asad.
why you people don't say anything about dilshad pain.
how rashid cheated his pregnant wife.
why it don't touch you.
cheating on a pregnant wife is not so important for you than a slap.
and wait are not rashid a positive character.
so why you people don't say anything about rashid.
you fail to answer that ques.

and romancing of lead couple will be revelent till last episode of qh.

but do you want to shouting about slap( which happend in one episode ) till last episode.
how illogical the comparision.

you also can't deny the common link of you people which i mentioned.
which makes the intenion of you people very much suspicious

Originally posted by: mijanur

@Rupnzel people don't get influenced either by villen or hero of a hindi tv serial.
it was showing tulsi kills mom in law,son.
it show parvati send her grand son to jail.
it showing kashis marry four times and his 3rd husband,4th husband married her sisters.
it shows manav gets slapped by 10times by mom in law and 3 times by archana when he was not guilty.
i don't see any of those happen reality
people know its not for real and its fiction.

and i wanted to know why the same people don't send bccc for their previous show which gives romantic angle to violance.

seconed thing mother means earth for asad.
a mother who is also his father.
apert from mother and sister who is own for asad.
nobody do you understand how much insecurity he has.
but still i am saying asad does a wrong thing by slapping zoya.
i also mentioned in if posts it could better if they avoid it.
i also make a thread about asad should not taunt zoya about parents.

but you people are too much taking a scene with real life and dragging the issue 8-9 days and saying same thing on 20thread.what is the point of too much repeatation.do you have anything new to say.

its not a normal behaviour.so we found this behaviour is very suspicious.

and yes you people single out asad.
why you people don't say anything about dilshad pain.
how rashid cheated his pregnant wife.
why it don't touch you.
cheating on a pregnant wife is not so important for you than a slap.
and wait are not rashid a positive character.
so why you people don't say anything about rashid.
you fail to answer that ques.

and romancing of lead couple will be revelent till last episode of qh.

but do you want to shouting about slap( which happend in one episode ) till last episode.
how illogical the comparision.

you also can't deny the common link of you people which i mentioned.
which makes the intenion of you people very much suspicious

Originally posted by: madmaxine

Hi!

I really liked the letter you wrote. I think it's a step in the right direction. So, I haven't read all 30 pages of this discussion, but I skimmed a few pages here and there. I didn't see any mention of this, so I thought I'd link you. The BCCC is having a session to sensitize creative teams on TV channels on the depiction of women on TV.

http://articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2013-02-07/india/36971051_1_bccc-sources-women

It's pretty sad that creative teams need to be sensitized. After all, aren't artistes supposed to be the most sensitive to upheavals in society? This is a good time to have this debate, when the country has finally woken up to the way women are mistreated/abused in India. The point in the article about the shows pretending to create awareness in society through their depiction of violence against women is particularly well taken. It's almost like they pick an issue, say they'll make a show out of it, and then proceed to depict women undergoing numerous sufferings before she finally gets things right in her life. What's worse, things going well for her usually mean she's finally hitched to a good guy.

For those who say people's behaviors are not influenced by what comes on TV, I say your argument is not just flawed, it is outright wrong. Of course they are. See this article from a year ago.

http://www.filmitown.com/2012/01/10/bccc-objects-on-showing-violence-on-small-screen/

That's just the tip of the iceberg. I could probably find you 100 more if I had the time and the inclination. 😊

Finally, this is not about Qubool Hai. It really isn't. QH was just the vehicle. Its about every show that showcases this kind of behavior.

Kudos on writing the letter!

okaaay, so finally read through the 45 pages...and my brain hurts!! 😆

Originally posted by: narangi314

okaaay, so finally read through the 45 pages...and my brain hurts!! 😆

We clearly have a problem with logic here.

Let's look at an analogy shall we?

An analogy, acc to wikipedia is: is a cognitive process of transferring information or meaning from a particular subject (the analogue or source) to another particular subject (the target), and a linguistic expression corresponding to such a process. In a narrower sense, analogy is an inference or an argument from one particular to another particular.

So, to the analogy:

What if when Indians began to agitate for independence, the British told us "Why didn't you object to us when we first arrived in the 1600s? Why didn't you object about the Dutch? Why didn't you object about the Portugese? Why don't you object to the colonization of Africa? Why didn't you object the viking invasion of england?.. ...See? See? You didn't right? So shut up and stop agitating now"

Do you see how spurious this logic is?????

How does NOT objecting to a previous incident of violence/aggression on this show or indeed any other show negate/undermine the need to object NOW. Surely it makes it only all the more important.

I'd also like to ask you once more to refer to the definition of an analogy...I am NOT equating the objection to the slap with the objection to colonialism...Just in case anyone has any doubts on that score.

Hope that helps!

Cheers!

couldn't have explained it better Mira...I cannot comprehend the fact that ppl cannot seem to understand the fact that everyone has the right to voice their opinion...but, I still have to read all 45 pages😆...in between work.

Originally posted by: Rupunzale

couldn't have explained it better Mira...I cannot comprehend the fact that ppl cannot seem to understand the fact that everyone has the right to voice their opinion...but, I still have to read all 45 pages😆...in between work.

I might take some painkillers before I start...I have not had a chance...if I start I won't get work done and I am up against a deadline (so some members must be really happy not to see me here. 😆)...will start later tonight responding to some posts...and members.