Who do u think is better...???? - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

44

Views

1.5k

Users

17

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

Posted: 18 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: aditivats

Lolz dear I understand this but we dont know much abt somi na. Sagars hv just shown him as PRC's father n ajmer's king n nothing more than that. How do we know that he didn't commited any mistake wen he was young😆

N now coming to ur point that wen PRC refused to go wid his frnz then i completely support his decision there. Come on yaar, he is a king, he cant go every where. If he has to do everything by himself then wat use r others for. Wat r they doing. I just dont understand this concept of Sagars that PRC is a king but he still goes everywhere on his own. No guards nothing. Are all ppl working under him useless.Cant he get some time for his personal life too🤢

so true aditi..without prc no matter can get resolved..cumon he is king he can't be after all these small fights & problems🤢

i even hate the way his frnds r potrayed these days they r completely clueless of wht is happening in PRC's life...come together & go together...they seem to behave as if none of them was aware of PRC love for sanyo.

Cumon ..arjun was the one who said...we will drop by maya mai's place before heading to ajmer....they saw PRC & sanyo together..they shud be able to understand the emoional stress he is going thru.....

aditivats thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#32

Originally posted by: Kai_Hiwatari

so true aditi..without prc no matter can get resolved..cumon he is king he can't be after all these small fights & problems🤢

i even hate the way his frnds r potrayed these days they r completely clueless of wht is happening in PRC's life...come together & go together...they seem to behave as if none of them was aware of PRC love for sanyo.

Cumon ..arjun was the one who said...we will drop by maya mai's place before heading to ajmer....they saw PRC & sanyo together..they shud be able to understand the emoional stress he is going thru.....

Exactly nd ispite of supporting him at this time they made a plan wid his nanaji n that fortuneteller n sent him for alligator n ninja fights🤢

crazy_kiran thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#33

Originally posted by: aditivats

Exactly nd ispite of supporting him at this time they made a plan wid his nanaji n that fortuneteller n sent him for alligator n ninja fights🤢

yup ur right the frnds could hv tried to solve the misunderstanding by going to sanyo and explaining her everything as they were also there when jai attacked them in the jungle, or could have met vaishali and told her the truth and involved her in trying to prove pri innocence to sanyo by serching for the ring or something.

jatt1234 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#34
woww such an interesting discussion and i didnt c!!

okay well i didnt read it all so forgive me for repeated points

but i think that they were equally as good.

prithvi might be well known but that was because of his love story, and the fact that his defeat led to him beign the last hindi king.

i think its just circumstances and fate that made their actions slightly different, but at the end of the day they both made the same mistake. forgiving.

someshwar forgave bhimdev, and prithvi forgave ghori.

So both were kinda similar.

In the sagars though, i think prithvi is shown to be more of an emotion udnerstanding character. well i dont know how to put it. but someshwar put his kingdom before anything else.

Like when sanyogita came to the mahel and anangpal offered delhi. someshwar wanted prithvi to accept, prithvi couldnt because he cared too much of his family, he brought up the faces of his mum and how upset she was.

But we do know that prithvi accepts in the end, so i think prithvi learns from his dad. i think it would be wrong to say he was a shadow of his dad, and went by what his dad did or said. but he went with what he thought was right.

It would also be easier for us to say prithvi was better because we know more about him, whereas much less is known about Someshwar. We can easily say "prithvi is better" and that is because we know that he killed Bhimdev Solanki a well established king of the time, at the mere age of 13. We dont have anything to compare that to though? We do not know what Someshwar was able to accomplish at the age of 13.

you could say that we dont know what Someshwar accomplished because he wasnt as good as king, prithvi's stories spread far and wide because he was a good king.

To be honest, i think that Prithvi's stories were just spread because of the Love Story and because he was the last Hindu ruler.

So my opinion is they are equal and i think it would be wrong to compare as with Prithvi we know a lot about him, where as Someshwar we know next to nothing 😕


mayuragulati thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#35
As of now, we have only seen Prithvi as a good human being, gr8 warrior, intelligent, smart etc. but we r yet to see prithvi as a king. killing bheemdev was also kind of a personal vendetta...how many decisions has he taken as a king..for ajmer or for delhi? he's too busy with his personal life right now but that's only sagar's way of streching the story. may be they r laying foundations for his new role... prithvi - the king of delhi and ajmer..how he realizes tht his duties n responsibilities towards his kingdom hold much importance than his private life. thats what someshwar kept on advicing him..till now, someshwar is a better king than prithvi but obviously later prithvi came out to be much stronger, wiser and popular than his father..
chaitra86 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: kirantarani2007

yup ur right the frnds could hv tried to solve the misunderstanding by going to sanyo and explaining her everything as they were also there when jai attacked them in the jungle, or could have met vaishali and told her the truth and involved her in trying to prove pri innocence to sanyo by serching for the ring or something.



actually i dont think his friends could have done anything better..i agree that dragging prithvi into everything is ridiculous but convincing sanyogita is almost next to impossible....that girl literally closes her ears when someone tries to tell her something...she only has to learn the truth by herself somehow......so i think
it was easier for prithvi's friends to remind him about his responsibilities than convince prithvi's junglee billi😆
navya2007 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#37
i think prc was a good king better than somi. he had more teritories undeer him and

it was wise to letr that ghori go other wise his pll would wage war against whole of india and keep comin 2 this place just like wat happend afterr ghori died.

the rajputs werent united so it would hav been big problem to face them. and ppl were alwayz scared of war it invites destruction..........

prc tried to avoid by marrying gals. and he did try his best to keep peace talks 2.
ppiyu thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#38
If we seperate sanyo from pri's life than i think Prithvi is better...... Otherwise I think Someshwar is Perfect.
215629 thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#39
hmmmm....I like this tpoic and I don't like the way Sagars are protraying Prithvi...

but still I wld like to debate accd to what sagars are showing...I don't like Prithvi's decisions...they are not at all wise...he is always worrying about Sanyogita...why become a king if are so much interested in your personal life??is she greater than his father?doesn't he remember his father saying 'ek raja ko sabse pehle apne rajya aur praja ke baare mein sochna chahiye'

Why shd he have got more interest in her rather than concentrating on his throne...just because of his little infatuation so much loss was incurred ...

So in my opinion Someshwar was greater than Prithvi ... Someshwar was a true soldier ... he didn't even hesitate to send his son when there was a problem...but this Prithvi sees sanyo everywhere...ungh!!
merry911 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#40

Originally posted by: Kashimani

thats so true Aditi😆

...abt my opinion, I'll say ...lolz I don't know...and true, I don't know the actual History....but, as per the serial I'll say PRC was better in some ways & Someshwar was better in some other ways!....hmmm sounds quite diplomatic, right?

OK, I think PRC was a better king than Someshwar, as many times Prithvi seemed to be thinking in right direction than Someshwar, despite of Prithvi's young age & Someshwar's experience!....Well I think Prithvi was a better king, good warrior inspite of his age. He was ruling most part of North India. It's not easy to rule over that big empire.

.....but, Someshwar was well mature & experienced which had made him better than Prithvi in many cases....particularly in making decission as a king over as a person. I think, Prithvi being young & having lost his father, his strongest source of encouragement & wisdom.......has done few wrong choices as a king - sure age and experience makes you better. I'm sure if Prithvi had lived longer he had been even better.

one is elopement, for which I personally don't blame him as GOD also wants that two persons in love should meet in life & thus, may be that was destined and that elopement incident led to prithvi's death finally .....and I am not sure how Someshwar could have advised Prithvi in such situation! here I don't agree with you dear. You think if Prithvi hadn't eloped with Sanyo that would have made Jaichand his friend? or even hating Prithvi less? I don't think so. He hated Prithviraj chauhan, and I think he would have helped Ghori against Prithvi anyway. Now also he have tried to Prithvi to get Delhi's throne.

Second wrong thing PRC did was forgiving Ghori....at least he should have taken lesson from waht BD did to his father....and I think if Someshwar was alive, he would have surely advised Prithvi not to forgive Ghori. Yes this was Prithvi fault. I think the only reason for his losing the 2nd Battle of Tarain. I think Prithvi should have learned the lesson from his father's past experience. Remember Someshwar forgave BD and spared his life and what did BD did in return- he killed Someshwar. Same as Prithvi spared Ghori's life and Ghori.....


So, these are the two important incidents happened in PRC's life that made Prithvi to die so horribly.....BUT, I think that may be it was destined so....I believe in GOD & destiny!

...thanks for your patience & thanks for the interesting topic Kai.....it made me think what I never analyzed😳

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".