One of the finest ever - Page 11

Hello SAm..

Originally posted by: nisha2010

of corse if krishna says d same doubts that were voiced by ss or amma...............then something will surely snap in her....................shatter her...................

Nisha,

But Krishna will say that ...he cud not bear her having male friends...and he knows Angad very well and the kind of person he is and also that he is a male ...would he believe that a female beat the blues out of a strong man [I mean physical strength ] or a low life like Angad kept her in a room the whole night and without touching her ....

even her own grand mother refused to believe Pratigya when she returned the next day ...in fact the family mamber's themselves did not believe her instantly...it was slowly they accepted that Nothing did happen .....but to expect Krishna to accept immediately is not logical....he too will need time to understand and accept the fact ....

Tanthya dear....never my mind...dear!!

Originally posted by: HamiSky

Hello SAm..

Am a woman...married!! :-) i dont mind :-)

Krishna going to doubt Pratigya's integrity is not news to her..she knows he gonna doubt her n may hurt her too....

she as well knows that she will left kindly by her in-laws..the extent to whihc they humiliated might be a shocker ..but she knows she has to fight this out....

she is shattered yes..by her in-laws..but still was determined to prove her innocence...

and with Krishna acknowleding their relationship will help her battle it out...first with Krishna....then with the outside world..

her priority is Krishna now...that she had asserted very well ...first wen she told her parents and then wen she painfully engulfed the abuses hurled at her....she was determined to win her Krishna back...she showed the grit no doubt...

but howshe gonna do it...will be intersting to watch!!

yup she was prepared ,......................she told her dad..........she has to face this all alone................

Originally posted by: tanthya

Sam,

I would disagree with u in ur estimation of Pratigya ....what u have portrayed is a picture of a weak willed girl who stumbled at the first hurdle .....but I expect more from Pratigya...

let us cast our mind back , shall we ...she went to her beloved maika to know what her darling Papa was hiding from her ...and her darling Papa after hurling some harshest words at her throws her out in the middle of the night...she suffers a total breakdown then ...her Papa was her world ...and his disownment cuts her to the quick ...she is broken and is saddened and is not the same...but after 2 days she begins to think and decides to search for answers....in other words , her soul repaired and she was resilient enough to seek the truth....

And in the case of Thakur's ...their reaction's were foretold and expected ..by the saxena's family...they even thought that that Pratigya will be Killed or the marriage annulled ....in other words there were some mental preparations beforehand....so we do not find her breaking down that easily...and she did not break down yest, if u noticed ...she knows the consequences and she was prepared for it...such kind of preparedness will not kill a person ...yes she may have been shocked and grieved...but one always recovers from shock and grief ....


if that girl had to die..then she would have died during honeymoon ....if that girl had to die , then she would have died when her father threw her out .....and now this storm will not kill her ...it will only strengthen her !!

We can go back and we can debate what happened in the past was right or wrong. Yes response to the para in red , she died that many times. And this blackening of her and her fathers face was never anticipated. She wouldn't have come to that hell had she knew the kind of allegations, verdict and punishment will she receive without explaining.

So If this happens to someone in reality she will start loving the guy how is part and parcel of that household. Will that love could ever come from the bottom of ones heart. I doubt.

Any ways she is no more the same Pratigya he tried to conquer. She is just a body and will succumbed to her fate where it takes her. But if she rises from this humiliation I will give her the biggest meddle of honor.

Binny ,

the scenes were such that all of us were carried away !!😊....

regarding Krishna's penchant for violence seems to be decreasing quite a lot....are the CV's lulling us.....well if he wants to get physical ...let him..let him get physical and break the mediaplayer ,sofa,chairs and cupboard ..but let him not touch Pratigya ...Pratigya shud be scared out of her wits by this actions ....but she shud not be terrorized ....she shud have enough courage to reach out to him ....and he shud be exhausted enough to listen to her !!


As you said , Binny..it is entirely dependent on POV's ...from Prats POV ...Father was Important ..From SS POV ...his respect and prestige in the society was important ..it might seem fake for us but for him it is very real ....

No need for Krish involvement ...she could have gone directly to SS ...SS being an astute politician and a pragmatist would have known how to deal it with it ...this we saw in the way he handled the laborer's case !!

SS is not trustworthy ..but his precious election is going on ..and he will not do anything to rock the boat !!
Tanthya

I doubt prats needs Krishna to be violent in order to fear his reaction when they are alone, in fact she has already been insulted to the extremes by her in laws, she is in a state of shock, they have stripped her of her confidence, have instilled a sense of fear in side of her and she has completely broken down for the time being. I know this will not last because she is not the type to completely break down, she has the strength to face her problems but she will need some time before she can find her strength again in order to fight against this injustice done to her.

Prats is already scared, shocked,and has been hurt by her in laws actions though it was something she expected but I'm sure they went even past her own imagination. Now she is also expecting a negative reaction from Krishna and after what she and her father have just been through I personally don't feel Krishna breaking things out of anger is going to have much of an affect on her state of mind. I don;t mind though if he takes his anger out on different things as long as he never touches prats that is unacceptable. I don't think prats will be scared or shocked by Krishna's anger it is something she has expected especially after that incident where Krishna told the man to kill his wife. Prats will still be in a state of shock from her in laws behavior towards her not so much their words but their actions.

Krishna though will not be humiliating her in public his reaction will be tolerable for her because it will be in private as long as he does not abuse her of course, and I'm sure she is capable of understanding his pain, and will try to make him understand once he calms down because in anger Krishna hears nothing and listens to no one. So as much as prats making an effort is important Krishna must be willing to listen to her.


Tanthya I was referring to SS not fulfilling his promise of releasing her father once the elections were over, If guruma told him keeping the professor in jail was to their benefit do you really think he would object

Originally posted by: SAM2U

We can go back and we can debate what happened in the past was right or wrong. Yes response to the para in red , she died that many times. And this blackening of her and her fathers face was never anticipated. She wouldn't have come to that hell had she knew the kind of allegations, verdict and punishment will she receive without explaining.

So If this happens to someone in reality she will start loving the guy how is part and parcel of that household. Will that love could ever come from the bottom of ones heart. I doubt.

Any ways she is no more the same Pratigya he tried to conquer. She is just a body and will succumbed to her fate where it takes her. But if she rises from this humiliation I will give her the biggest meddle of honor.

Sam,

She knew she is entering a war zone when she said to her father that this FIGHT IS HERS ALONE ... so she already knew that there will be fight and was ready for that ...she knew such an accusation would be hurled against her hence her calmness and quietness when it actually was happening .....


Did that guy instigate his household members to apply coal ? did that guy throw her out ? did that
justify his family's behavior ? Did that support his family's behavior .? NO !!

That guy held her from falling !! That guy took her in , That guy announced to te shocked family that she was his wife ...and any decisions will be taken by them , no butting in thank you ...
A reaction completely unexpected judging from Pratigya's and her papa's expression !!

A human being is always growing up... pleasure,pain,experience will shape and change our perceptions... to expect Pratigya or for that matter anybody to be same ..is unrealistic...

But if she rises from this humiliation I will give her the biggest meddle of honor.

Thanxx for finally accepting that she does MEDDLE.....😊

Originally posted by: HamiSky

Hello SAm..

Am a woman...married!! :-) i dont mind :-)

Krishna going to doubt Pratigya's integrity is not news to her..she knows he gonna doubt her n may hurt her too....

she as well knows that she will left kindly by her in-laws..the extent to whihc they humiliated might be a shocker ..but she knows she has to fight this out....

she is shattered yes..by her in-laws..but still was determined to prove her innocence...

and with Krishna acknowleding their relationship will help her battle it out...first with Krishna....then with the outside world..

her priority is Krishna now...that she had asserted very well ...first wen she told her parents and then wen she painfully engulfed the abuses hurled at her....she was determined to win her Krishna back...she showed the grit no doubt...

but how she gonna do it...will be intersting to watch!!

Thanks for replying and i hope you didn't mind asking about your gender to understand your POV better, as this is done so many times in the forum.

Well surely it will be interesting to watch purely from a fictional point of view as her staying strong and still trying to prove her innocence to krishna seems far from reality. So by proving her innocence she is saving her marriage or is she just fighting to get her honor restored. I will never agree to the this that Krishna loves her if he doesn't trust her. Will he except if she explains, how could she convince just her words, will he demand evidence, witnesses, Does she needs to explain ?. Even if she is successful in convincing and erasing the doubts will his mind set change. His mentality and possessiveness and his mere thought of suspecting a wife if she will ever be seen with an outsider for any simple reason can not prove the authenticity of his tall love claim.

"His mentality and possessiveness and his mere thought of suspecting a wife if she will ever be seen with an outsider for any simple reason can not prove the authenticity of his tall love claim.
"