Sharing a true story - Mother versus Wife

...MonaCo... thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#1
Going by the current bash Dilshad theories, I want to share a true story of one of my friends. She is way in her forties. So, its not about someone who is just an angry, rebellious teenager. She has made very well for herself - career wise and family wise, and shared a decent bond with her mother until recently - when she picked an argument with her (like always) over something silly. Now it has been three years since they spoke. However, she despises her father, so much so that she was not allowed (leave alone being invited) to her wedding. Why? Because he was an alchoholic abuser.
This woman, though has a good life is full of psychological issues, that run very deep. She has trust issues, has allienated everyone that has ever loved her, is insecure, etc. etc I dont even want to get started.

Her father used to hit her, and her mother when she was young. As soon as she turned 15-16 she moved out and began making a life of her own. Today she herself is borderline self abusive (though she is away from substance abuse). She has very strong ideas (no matter how irrational they are ) and will fight tooth and nail for them. So no one can talk to her about her dad.

Her mother is now remarried and has found true love, but as a part of her own healing (Which we can totally understand) reconciled with her ex husband (my friends father) and invited him to her wedding. This is many years later - like about 20 years later since she divorced him. She says she only did it for peace. Her own peace of mind.

I dont know why but she once let me in the wall she has built around her heart at a moment when she was a bit high. So I asked her do you hate your father? You know her answer?

I hate him. More than I hate anyone else. But you know who I hate more? My mom. After whatever I went through in life for her, with her, due to that man... She betrayed me and chose to find some stupid shit called peace. She never for once, thought how I felt... and she broke down.

A woman everyone hates for being strong, brutal, ambitious, broke down.

May I even say why I share this poignant story? I rest my case on what I think Dilshad should have done.

I promised myself not to make a post but I could not stop myself.

Rashid - a man who chose his own freedom over his duties as a father, two timed her, and left her along with his ammi for suffering with two kids... gets chosen over her son who has been inflicted the worst possible psychological issues due to him. Dilshad, I understand your pain as a woman and wife... but I can never believe this is the choice of a mother. I would never ever do this to my son.

Created

Last reply

Replies

52

Views

4.2k

Users

26

Likes

200

Frequent Posters

RandomSquared thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
im just sooo disappointed in dilshad in every way
mochhug thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
I don't mean to bash Dilshad, and while I understand her as a woman and wife, I still can't as a mother. And not only as a mother. But as a woman, even if he left her because of blackmail THE SECOND TIME. He left her THE FIRST TIME out of his own free will. He cheated on her. And she would still go live with him? Leaving her son behind? What about Zoya? I mean she considers her her daughter, no only because Asad loves her, but because they have a strong mother/daughter bond.
I just can't. This totally ruined Dilshad's character for me, and I just can't keep watching this show. I tolerated Gul butchering Asad's character for the sake of a love story and the promise of a brother's clash. And I know it'll happen now with this, but I can't stand her butchering Dilshad's character after elevating her so much over the last year and takin so much effort to show her as a strong independent, yet caring mother.
WaqtZaya thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
Isn't qh so realistic? :))
The biggest reason y I love it :))
vinita459 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
How can dilshad even think about moving with him? What ever it is but he does have another wife living in SM. Raashid and Dilshad are being too selfish and not thinking about the consequences.

How come now they are not thinking about their daughters who got married in Haseena's house. Now haseena will not make their lives miserable by taunting them. What if she sends both of them back to their home.

What about Asad, he did so much for his mom. How come dilshad is not thinking about asad and his feelings.

I will be very disappointed with her character if she really did leave Asad for Raashid.
starsinmyeyes thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#6
I can understand where Dilshaad is coming from...there is no one wrong or right here...but it's about fair and unfair...it's about the strong facade that gave in now...yes all this is unfair to Asad but Dilshaad's character became more believable...she is a woman who was abandoned but still loved her hubby...and knows that he was innocent when she heard that recording in the doll before it was changed...there had to be some repercussions and damage she sustained post her separation...the same way Asad did...now the chinks in her armor are coming into view...
Great post...TFS
RandomSquared thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#7
i still dont get why this wud result in a clash, asad wud never support dilshad in this matter
Zanutix thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#8
The story of that friend of yours has moved me, really.

I don't know whom I support, everything's very vague.

I do understand that Dilshaad has been craving for a husband's love... she has been selfless for too long.
Now, when her kids have found their love and are all set to start a family of their own, shouldn't she too be free to pursue her love?

But she should also consider the fact that there are potential dangers to her life and dignity at SM.

Her decision is more or less impulsive and very abrupt.

She has the right to live her life the way she wants, but what about Asad?
They had been each other's pillar of strength through thick and thin,

Dilshaad has been Asad's life.
The old, akdu Asad lived only for his Ammi and Najma.
How would he feel when his most respected person will ditch him for the one he despises?

And Rashid, you already have your hands and pockets full with more than necesarry things.

Dono haathon mei laddoo much?

And where is that Rashid Ahmed Khan who wanted to make amends with his most loved and elder son?
He has gathered guts, finally, but has misdirected them.

You just don't barge into someone's house and shout at them, and challenge to snatch away what rightfully isn't even yours,

Go Home, Rashid.

Your Daughter, Daughter-in-law, Son, Ammi, Wife, Bhaijaan, Bhabhijaan and Biryaani are waiting for you.

-khaleesi- thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#9
I completely agree with you.
Since a woman has a child she's a mother first before anything else. Dilshad's love for Rashid maybe above everything else but it should not be above her son's happiness. Esp. when the son has completely shared her burden growing up to the point of giving up his childhood to support her.
annanyaksgian thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#10
agree how could she leave her son ,asad who is always there when her spineless love left her with two child for another women

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".