Reason for Jagya's promptness in refusal

642126 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#1
Jagya broke up relationship with Sanchi without talking to anyone else and without waiting much.

He kept silent all these months despite his dislike for her, difference in their ways of thinking and lifestyle and his dislike for her perverted overtures towards him.

But he showed promptness only now in refusing her after hearing her conversation with friends and learning from Anandi how she'd bribed the pandit twice.

It's being alleged that he did so because of his love for Ganga. Broke off from Sanchi the moment he got something against her.

What do you think, why he broke the engagement like this? Because of concern for family but knowing their inability to refuse and to avoid further problems in their lives? Or because of his newly realised love for Ganga?

But then didn't he dislike Sanchi from day one? Even before he developed feelings for Ganga. Hasn't he been avoiding to refuse for sake of his family? And refused now when he felt even family couldn't be happy?

What's your take?

Created

Last reply

Replies

26

Views

4.4k

Users

21

Likes

220

Frequent Posters

redapple1 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
I feel he broke off the engagement with Sanchi because he is concerned for his family not because he loves Ganga. He tried to work it out, but hearing Sanchi making fun of his heritage and the way she said she would take Jagya away from Jaitser was the triggering point.

Edited by redapple1 - 12 years ago
642126 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
However tempted I may feel to buy that idea (of his love for Ganga being the trigger), I still think it's got less to do with Ganga. Jagya disliked her from day one. He disliked her behaviour with Anandi and his family.
He was never comfortable with the attention she later started giving to him. No interest in her calls or gifts. He had at once said he had never considered Sanchi that way when proposal was put to him. He found it odd and wanted to talk to Anandi first. But he was forced to say YES by his family who got him to agree by warning him not to do anything that threatened Anandi's happiness in her sasra. Not to give her any more dukh. So he agreed. All the time his disinterest and helplessness were evident. So how is Ganga responsible for break up of this engagement by Jagya?
I think he was hasty to break this because he felt it was already too late and there shouldn't be more delay - because Anandi would take forever to talk to Sanchi or anyone else or won't be able to intervene much. And if this alliance happened then he'd remain unhappy which was a given, but even his family would have to suffer more - which he did not want them to. He probably thought just as they agreed for this alliance and tolerated Sanchi due to Anandi, similarly they'd have to tolerate tamasha at home after marriage because Sanchi was Anandi's SIL. They'd be in limbo then. He was about to tell truth of Sanchi to his own family but did not tell Shekhars because he did not want to speak against their daughter and it was obvious they wouldn't believe him either.

So he made dialogues on incompatibility and felt it was easier to break an engagement than later break a marriage or break up his home for sake of keeping the marriage together.

From what I know of Jagya as a character, he has been very clear about his dislikes. He has never given importance to what he disliked at first sight. Anandi or Gauri - he'd had a liking for them. That was never there for Sanchi. So how could anyone expect him to work around that relationship or wait more to talk to Sanchi about what he had overheard?

Jagya did not think of Ganga at restaurant or outside it or while going to temple or Shekhars' house. He thought only of Sanchi and her plans which he had heard. So how can we say Ganga's love was main reason for his action?
He had not intended to visit or call Ganga after breaking his engagement. It's a coincidence that he got a call from Mangalore about Ganga's arrest.

Wasn't he ready to sacrifice for family? Which is why he offered Ganga to go to Jaipur instead of inviting her to Jaitser? He never contacted her again after she told him she would manage there by herself and did not need a job in Jaipur. He even felt she'd changed and moved on after living in Mangalore.

Therefore I still think his main reason for breaking this engagement was his family who he did not want to see suffer again. He'd seen his family's and Anandi's hesitation so he decided to stop dilly dallying and end it there even if he was perceived as a bad guy.
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
Jagya never ever liked Sanchi and he forced himslef to put up with her for the sake of his family happiness and since he believed that she was Anandi's choice for him.These are the only two reasons for him to get engaged in the first place.
Every time he wanted to break away from this these two factors made him to hang on.

But after the coffee shop convo where he overheard Sanchi and the conversation he had with Anandi cleared his way for him.

These were the only two obstacles in his path his parents' happiness and Anandi's opinion -when they were removed he just went ahead and called off the marriage.

I think even if there had been no Ganga he would have called off the wedding.

But the way he did was not really the way.He should have talked to Sanchi irst and tell her to be there at her home and he is coming there and he should have broken with Sanchi in full view of his family and told her why he was breaking it off and then should have walked away from there.
Then Shekhar family would have rushed to find the truth about what he said instead of jumping on his throat.That way it would have been much better.

koolsadhu1000 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
I don't think it had anything to do with Ganga .

He has learnt to keep his personal emotions well in check and take decisions with the brain .

It was his life experience that taught him that .

Neither does he dislike Saanchi . He is indifferent to her . He did not even try to get back at her after all that he overheard when he broke off .

He said yes for the family and broke off for the family .

When she almost accused him of being low in character and having an affair he swallowed it and did not even think of breaking off .

When she constantly phoned him and like some control freak constantly dictated to him what he should wear to the hospital he was mildly disturbed but he brushed it off .

When he witnessed her vile temper he swallowed that too .

Anything personal he adjusted but when it came to family he acted .
Her contempt for his family shocked him . And he acted promptly . The farce must not go on for a minute longer . Anandi's saasra , buying time and thinking over it , talking with her etc was a waste of time . The thing must be cut at its roots , so she could find what worked for her and he could for himself .

For past 6 MONTHS he stayed true to the promise he made to his mother ...after 16th i will do as u say .

He did not keep a lot of contact with Ganga

only cursory contact

and even arranged for her job elsewhere .

Jagya has learnt to control emotions well .

He never said no to Saanchi for Ganga , he would have married her if he had not heard that conversation .

But he heard it and there was ridicule for his family in it .

Whereas he was never gonna leave it now .

So he broke off .
Missesha thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#6
In my POV, its a mix of all the reasons
- He didn't like Sa, but he accepted since it was going to make his family happy
- He thought he will change himself for Sa, to keep their couple happy, and he tried as well, but Sa was way too different for him
- He had started feeling suffocated already but wasn't sure what to do, so he continued with Sa with very less feelings for her.
- Then he realised he loves G, but he decided to sacrifice his love. He even tried to move away from her thoughts and didn't call her back to jaister.
- All this was already paining him, when final stroke was made at Sa's revelation. This gave him the much needed reason to break off.

Good decision. No point sacrificing so much, when even the main reason for which he was getting married would not be addressed - i.e. family's happiness.

His main reason for break up is incompatibility, concern for family and his newly realised love for G. In that order. But all reasons are interlinked in a way.
Edited by Missesha - 12 years ago
BeyondTheSky thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#7
jagya accepted sanchi's proposal for his family's happiness & because of anandi, he thought it had her approval, the moment he realized absence of both the reasons, he didnt waste any time on it...
i think he felt very free & relieved to do that 😆.
we can debate on what was the right way to do it...but sanchi being sanchi no amount of talking to her would have helped ! this was to be done asap...may be taking his father & dadisa into confidence before going ahead should have been the right thing to do.
Edited by BeyondTheSky - 12 years ago
JuhiR thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#8
In my opinion, Jagiya agreed to marry Sanchi for the sake of his family's happiness. He had no interest in Sanchi. He tried to adjust but was suffocating in this relationship. But when he found out Sanchi's true colors and how she is going to treat his family, he made his decision. He did not want a rerun of his previous experience and saved his family from the upcoming misfortune.
He loves Ganga but was willing to sacrifice his love for the sake of his family. That is why he agreed to marry sanchi. But he could not bear to see his family go through suffering and pain due to his wife again. That is the reason for his breakup IMHO.
Sunna_Deewani thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#9
I think Jagya thought his family will be happy with sanchi as their Bahu and only for this reason he was being patient. Now after overhearing the sanchi's restaurant convo, its clear that sanchi has no intention to blend with his family and that will surely cause unhappiness only for his family. So the main reason of making his family will not be fulfilled. Also sanchi was not really Anandi's choice like he had thought earlier. Two main reasons why he agreed are no more valid.

Promptness with he did it - i guess maybe he was just too angry on jhooti, sarphiri Sanchi😆 and wanted to let out soon. Otherwise he could have told his family of sanchi's double face. Then his family would have faced shekar's anger instead of jagya alone😕. He would not want them to get curses from Ira and co. This could also be a reason.

I guess its a combo of many things. Its never a one thing that make you take certain steps.
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#10
I think if he had not over heard that conversation and had a talk with A he would have gone ahead and married her despite loving Ganga and would have made everyone his,his family's and Sanchi's lives miserable if he had not overheard what Sanchi said.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".