My take on Tumhari Disha dated Aug 30 '05

swathi thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#1

My take on Tumhari Disha dated Aug 30 '05

First things first. I did not see yesterday's episode completely. Started watching it from Dish and Suhas's scene. But somehow thought of writing my views on the character changes (maybe assasinations !!).

While watching the episode yesterday I could not help thinking abt Suhas's flip flop. Initially she was not close with Dish. Then once she knew that coz of Dish Inder and house is getting lost she became angry with her. Then she once again became close with her. After Dish ran away from her mandap Suhas was once again angry with her whihc was fuelled by Inder's death. Now she is back to feeling good abt Dish. I mean Suhas must be the only character who has done so many about turns. Among TD cast I think that its only Azuba who has been the same throughout. Always supportive of Dish and truth. (i mean closer to reality).

About DK the less said the better. DK being so intelligent how can he even think that Dish tried to kill him. I guess this topic has been discussed to death. After being so much in love with Dish how can he suddenly hate her so badly. Should he not be concerned as to what really happened. If she had to kill him she had so many opprtunities. Let me repeat the cinema dialogue. Khane mein tho zeher mila hi sakthi thi. (Translation: She could have mixed poison in food). Maybe from DK's perspective he wanted to get away from his world and when he saw his bro Ved and Dish against him he lost all his brains and hence now is not able to think properly.

Dish needs to stand uo for herself. Being good does not necessarily mean that u have to be a door mat for others. She has always worried abt others and ended up creating problems for herself. If only she is getting affected no harm. As after all its her life. But in the process she is making life hell for others as well. What right did she have to kill Inder's dreams when she agreed to Suhas's demand for Rano and also married DK. Then why did she agree to marry Ved and even though the poor chap kept on asking her abt her feelings she lied and finally ran away from the mandap ?.

In fact looking at things deeply, Gargi and Ved are justified in what they are doing. Gargi always had to share her husband with Sum and also digest the thought that Dhruv was in love with Sum. Any married woman would find it difficult. (Let me not think abt Gargi's own ecapades if there were any. Am sure they wud bring that angle later on and justify Dhruv and Sum. My comment is based on presently whatever is known). Similarly Ved was jilted at the wedding altar by Dish. So guess both their negativity was in a way fuelled by their failures in marriage life.

and how can I forget Maheka ? If her husband ran away does it mean that she will consider whoever comes her way as her husband. and I guess they are not yet married (no sindoor etc etc). I though DK had understood the significance of Sindoor (did he not cliam the same while with Dish). Then how could he do this with Maheka. Can't he understand that he should make Maheka understand the truth. Whatever he is doing is currently on the rebound and the day he comes to know of the truth (if that happens ever) then he is on way to shatter three lives. His own, Maheka and Dish. Of course Dish mite decide to become devi and sacrifice for Maheka and Aaroh (as he needs a father figure) or Maheka can die. I guess we can discuss this aspect when it happens at a later stage.

My questions or topic for debate to you all. Do you think that Suhas is justified in her flip-flop character. I would request that rather than looking at her as a mother please look at her as a woman and then post your views. Also let me know if Ved is justified being negative. What should DK do when he comes to know that Dish was not guilty. Should he be Ram and be with Dish or be Krishna (Bama-Rukmini).

For the unititated in Hinduism we have many gods. Lord Ram was famed for his 'Ek-patni' vrat (one wife only) while Lord Krishna had numerous wives prominent among them being Satyabhama and Rukmini. Both Lord Ram and Lord krishna were the avatars of Lord Vishnu. (Avatars is being born on earth and following worldly ways of life). Rrcently we celebrated the birthday of Lord Krishna as Janmashtami (or Gokulashtami as it is also known. Gokul being another name for Lord Krishna and Ashtami - eighth day on which he was born).

In my next part (and i dunno when I will pen that one) I will try to dissect the characters of Rano, Inder and Suki kaki's family.

I could not help noticing that yesterday that the old DK charm was back. The way he spoke with Gargi and hugged Dish I could not help remembering the good old days. and Dish when will you change your sari ? Am tired of watching the pale yellow sari with the not so matching blue blouse and those chandelier earrings. and surprise Gargi has taken over Dish's dress designer. Well for the preview Gargi was wearing a black sari which was and the material looked the same type as Dish used to wear (semi transparent !!!!) šŸ˜†šŸ˜†šŸ˜†

Last but not the least, thanks twinkle for the wonderful update for yesterday. Keep them coming.

Note to Samy/Sree/Jingle: While i was penning my take these thoughts came into my mind and i thought that we should have a discussion on this as well Let me know if I need to move out these questions to some other suitable post.

Swathi

Created

Last reply

Replies

8

Views

1.2k

Users

8

Frequent Posters

jingle thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#2
swathi thanks for ur take
yaar many days back itself i told here that they have given disha's wardrobe to gargi !
questions gets pop out of our mind by this serial just like pokorn can't help it
samy74 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 20 years ago
#3
Hey

Swathi is is very nice to see your take and I think good idea for discussion I will speak to sree, jingle and Priya and maybe we can come up with the discussion topic leave it with me.

Now your take I always look forward to your brilliant takes and now like TD is back maybe your takes will begin to show on adhoc basis I hope as I think they are fantastic.

What a analysis of Suhas i must say I think she has been a very undecisive woman and in case of Disha she has needed Disha because others have turned their back on her. She has always gone to Disha whenever she has been alone I think if she was Disha's real mother she wouldn't be doing this I think vijendra was the one who loved Disha regardless as a mothers love for a child is selfless. Suhas has loved Rano only as even toill today after she has said so much abotu Suhas she is stil supportin Rano and she is still with her. I think as a mother Suhas has been strong when it comes to Rano but with Disha she has changed like the weather.

Gargi and Ved I think have had misfortunes in their lifes but that doesn't mean u turn so evil that you go on killing sprees and plus Gargi has always been a money orientiated woman and Ved I think was positive lekin withthe situations he has turned negative but I think his character is a bit far fetched how can u turn so negative that you can kill your own brother in sucha short time span. I think again these are miracles of Guhaland.

This new triangle with Mahika, Disha and DK without saying much this reminds me of Piya ka ghar as ther writer is the same so I can see Mahika going all obessive and turning negative and maybe tyring to kill Disha..But ultimately the essence of TD is Disha will always remain DK's Disha and I hope these pagal Guhas show this as I think before it was DK running after Disha and now it is Disha running after DK...Hoping in the end they will run in each others directions and live happily ever after.

Thanks for the brillliant take again swathi I will put this idea for discussion of different characters forward and will get back to you.

Samy
Mamta_ thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#4
tx swathi!!!
as usual lots of insight to ur take...........
as 4 ur Q's..........

i have never approved or liked suhas "flip flop" character as u put it.........i mean she always only looks at her point of view & when it comes to Rano she just goes blind.........i mean even with inder all she thought of was that idiot Rano...........never mind that she was destroying 2 other lives in dish & inder who were in luv (ofcourse i had my own agenda in not wanting those 2 to end up 2gether šŸ˜‰ )........then 1ce she thought Rano was happy then D became her daughter again........i mean that is so insulting & our Dish madam too puts up with all this crap bcos she has no1 else.........i think it is high time some1 highlights suhas's faults to her cos bottom line it is just plain old hypocracy...........

as for D u r right, being nice does not mean u have to b every1's door mat.........bottom line she destroyed banders life by forcing him in2 a marriage with rano(ofcourse this does not justify his behaviour closer to his death).........she also played a huge hand in ved becoming so negative...........he asked her time & time again whether she wanted to marry him & she as silly as she is could only think of her "aai"........the same Aai who to date has never appreciated any of her sacrifices so why continue???

i think 1 can understand ved's 180 turn around but not to the extent of killing dk........i know many of u enjoyed the fact that dish ran away from the mandap but i for 1 thought that was wrong of her........she had plenty of opportunity to voice her opinion & stop the wedding but she didn't........Dish humiliated him so why then turn against dk & that too killing him..........murder is never justified.......i think he should've just went after dish but i suppose he was successful in making dk hate dish at the end of it all.........

as for dk, well if & when he finds out that dish was not involved in his shooting i hope he feels guilty as hell for jumping to conclusions............ok i know after u physically c some1 shooting u, u would probably hate that person............but then why not investigate & try & find out what actually happend.........i mean isn't he confused by dish being so luving & caring 4 him now..........surely if she really shot him she would be surprised/nervous/guilty at him being alive rather than happy.........so dk saigal do some investigating & come to the truth.........u urself would be shocked........oh & i definitely feel he should be "Ram".........

Mamta
chillyflakes thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#5
Great Take Swathi and its really nice to see you after such a long time!

Me thinks that Tumhari Disha should be viewed more or less as a Sitcom rather than a Drama.....because overall, it has its store of funny moments much more than dramatic and emotional ones! šŸ˜†

I never liked Suhas's character from the beginning, she was always a mean and selfish creature...and yes, superbly wishy-washy!

I think it was only DK who was a formidable character, even he has become rather clownish now, but still he manages to put up a decent show as compared with the others!

Do keep giving your takes regularly!

Cheers,

Chilly
PS: Will answer your PM in a while, let me quickly finish my lunch, I am dying out of hunger right now!
soni28 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#6
wonderful take swathi.....suhas's mind flips from one end to another so fast ur head spins......i guess gargi and ved have enough reason to hate DK and I do feel sorry for ved but to murder him so cruelly?!?........as for mahika, she seems like a foolish woman to me wanting to hang on to DK......and once DK finds out that Dish is not guilty he should beg her forgiveness 😊 and then be like Ram that is her's alone
twinecool thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#7
swathi nice to see ur opinion 😊
TD is a CHOW CHOW Bath of all hindi serials kuch waha sai kuch yeha sai šŸ˜•
why do u bring gods here , leave gods where they r poor things they will cry if they see their names draged in to td , somehow they r overprayed in tv serials
bunmaska thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#8

šŸ‘fab Swathi. to read ur take, better than watching TD actually. The less said about TD the better. But you know I don't want TD to end ever. You know why, just so that I can be with my IF-TD family forever and for that sake we need to thank Guhas

QUOTE=twine]swathi nice to see ur opinion 😊
šŸ˜•
why do u bring gods here

šŸ˜†šŸ˜† yup twinks, Swathi was just giving an example. But Swathi ( I know you were just explaining things) , GOD forgive us I don't even want to compare DK to Lord Ram or Lord Krishna. 😳

Other than acting arrogant and staring with wide eyes, DK is a complete loser 😔 who is dancing to the tunes of all the women in the serial to begin with Sanya, than Disha, Sumitra ma, Gargi and now Mahika 🤢

bunmaska thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#9
and Twinks forgot to add hats off to you, Jingle, Vidyadi and all šŸ‘ for having the patience to update šŸ‘

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".