Was Gunial right in slapping Kumud?

Poll

Gunial's action

Login To Vote

Marybarton

@Marybarton

Rocker

26

+ 8

Posted: 12 years ago

#1

What is this, slap the heroine day? I am so annoyed at Gunial. Slapping a grown up daughter. In public too, because she was worried and upset by Guman's words! Really showed her to be a weak character today.

If you are angry, take it out on Guman, not your daughter who "you trust so much." Daughters are not disposable. If you consider her the honor of the family, honor her dignity by NOT slapping her in front of Saras and others to make an example of her.

I have been supportive of her throughout but this action was uncalled for. Why this abuse of an innocent girl? This was clearly for TRP. What is this TRP audience that enjoys seeing a young girl getting slapped?

Post your view.

Edited by Marybarton - 12 years ago

18

Reply

Quote

Ashwini

@LekhSha

Navigator

10

Posted: 12 years ago

#2

you are wrong,a caring mother dont like any body talking non sence about her dear daughter.

just in anger she slapped.

It wont be for TRP,the culprit of TRP is its slot timing.

3

Reply

Quote

Marybarton

@Marybarton

Rocker

26

+ 8

Posted: 12 years ago

#3

Originally posted by: ashwini.bhr
you are wrong,a caring mother dont like any body talking non sence about her dear daughter.
just in anger she slapped.

It wont be for TRP,the culprit of TRP is its slot timing.

That's wrong anger placement then. Someone else is talking nonsense about her daughter. I can see where she is coming from, doesn't mean what she did was right. Kumud did nothing wrong and she sent Kumud to save the day as always. Just because she is angry doesn't mean she can't respect her adult daughter's dignity.

5

Reply

Quote

Om

@bugsbunny12

Rocker

27

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#4

I don't think kumud deserved to be slapped...

of course, gunial was worried, but instead of being thankful that kumud arrived home despite the storm and chaos...she slapped her daughter?!!!!

i was so angry...she could have asked kumud a 100 questions of why she was late, but why slap her and hurt her feelings???

6

Reply

Quote

Ujjval

@Ujjval

Beginner

0

Posted: 12 years ago

#5

I have always felt hitting/slapping others when we are angry or provoked shows how weak we are. Sorry for bringing this... There is a serial of an PH(that must not be named here) where the hero slaps the heroine thinking she was responsible for his mother's condition. I was shocked to see forum members(some) supporting him and making posts to prove their point(or their hero's point lol)!!! Audience may or may not enjoy such scenes but some of them still support it. Sad but true! :(

3

Reply

Quote

smrth

@smrth

Voyager

19

Posted: 12 years ago

#6

Originally posted by: Marybarton
What is this, slap the heroine day? I am so annoyed at Gunial. Slapping a grown up daughter. In public because she was worried and upset by Guman's words. Really showed her to be a weak character today. If you are angry, take it out on Guman, not your daughter who "you trust so much." Daughters are not disposable. If you consider her the honor of the family, honor her dignity by NOT slapping her in front of Saras and others to make an example of her.

I have been supportive of her throughout but this action was uncalled for. Why this abuse of an innocent girl? This was clearly for TRP. What is this TRP audience that enjoys seeing a young girl getting slapped?

Post your view.

I agree. This was just for a dramatic. In this instance, it was jarring, unnecessary and contrary to the character and her stand as given. There was no head or tail before it came. Moreover it fails in its aim too- 'no impact' whatsoever on audience. An immensely avoidable aberrance...🥱

1

Reply

Quote

Bewakoof

@Bewakoof

Rocker

25

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

#7

I think she was wrong...

Ye zaalim paapi duniya can say anything about your daughter but you should not get affected with it...

Ghumaan was obviously adding oil in fire!

I think Guniyal was wrong!

4

Reply

Quote

emeraldeye

@emeraldeye

Voyager

16

Posted: 12 years ago

#8

Even I felt it was wrong on her part to do this.😡

Earlier I used to like Guniyal - her broad minded and supportive ways! 😊

But yesterday her act was an immature one. I guess she was so grieved and saddened by khoti kaki's and Guman's words that she wanted to strike back and respond to them. But rather than back answering them, she choose to slap Kumud and quieted those two foul mouths!

But still whatever maybe the situation, slapping can never be justified. As a mother she knew her daughter so well. Then how could she??? 😲

2

Reply

Quote

SHANA

@ShanUlas

Sparkler

34

+ 10

Posted: 12 years ago

#9

hope all trp aunties r happy who like slapping there daughters just to ward off there angst .

i voted no it was a weak attempt of guniyal to pecify guman and that specky kamini budhiya in the house

i hate such oldies who just want to put house on fire in name of sada hua tradition but always spare there own child

I hate Guman and that specky khoti baat and i know it will be these two monsters who will poison saras kumud life :(

3

Reply

Quote

SUN_ROCKZZ

@SUN_ROCKZZ

Navigator

11

Posted: 12 years ago

#10

it was really wrong Gunial did wrong by slapping her especially infront of guman all thanks goes to Kumud's father that he backed answered to Guman if he had not done this then evryday Kumud would get slap from her mother what Gunial did was actually wrong

Edited by SID_ROCKZZ - 12 years ago

1

Reply

Quote

Was Gunial right in slapping Kumud?

Poll

Related Topics

Explore Topics