Laut kar Budhoo Ghar ko aaye..LATHER.RINSE.REPEAT. AND...we are back to square one!
Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde have come out to play again. Plus it seems the "bad cop" was not so dearly missed so I am shamelessly planting my butt here, with a little dose of reality 😆
(the hangout goes:
"lo aa gaye phir apnay gyan aur stupid theories ka pitara lay kar, Anjali kahin ki").. kiya karoon, I guess... yeh meri aadat hai.😉
It is well understood by now that the train destined for Shantivan, carrying Shyam Manohar Jha, was driven on the tracks of ASR's trust with Khushi as the driver, who had a self-pointed gun to her head called Di. The train has crashed into Shantivan, the tracks are damaged and the driver, badly wounded. What's done is done. There is no reasonable explanation for why Khushi had to be the one to do the dishonors. If the idea was to put a crack in ASR's trust, there are at least four different ways the makers could have accomplished it without directly tarnishing Khushi. Even if there is a big game plan for future which is founded on Khushi's decision, I failed to see it because from where I sit, this is nothing but satyanaash in the making. I am not that dense (I think) but maybe, the show is indeed way above my IQ level. If the idea was to get the jealous lover out of ASR, than other than that one minute of mumbling and pretended asphyxiation of Shyam, the makers missed the mark. If you need tips on writing a jealous lover, ask any girl or PM me, Pro Bono is my middle name. How many people actually got the idea that ASR reacted to Khushi because of Shyam being the one who came between them? Probably a very few. Majority saw the scene as ASR being hurt because Khushi betrayed him, Bas. If the actual reasoning was that important and was missed, what was the point? Bread crumbs, glimmer of hope, damage control, more oxygen for a show on life support, etc. Take your pick.
The sad reality is every character will take a fall if that's what keeps ASR intact. This should make the majority happy because the fandom is biased towards ASR and doesn't really give a hoot about anyone else. But for hopeless rationalists like me, who care for the story, and know ASR is nothing without Khushi, I think our days of enjoying the show are numbered.
Now that we have beaten a dead horse over Khushi's action, Mr. Hyde would like to take a stab at justifying both ASR and Khushi (*ducks chappals and tamatars*)
The only way I can justify their behavior is to essentially ignore the character growth that they had shown for both post kidnapping. We seem to have hit a reset on the characters.
Khushi is back to being herself, making decisions without thinking about the consequences and doing things for other people to justify her existence, her soul, her purpose in life. She is Khushi, she makes others happy, even if that means making the cat in RM happy which in turn makes ASR happy. She did this for Di because if Di isn't happy, how can ASR be? During kidnapping, her conversation with DM, she had said that she didn't care what ASR thought of her, she only wanted him back in the house. She had realized her love for him but for all she knew, the man could throw her out the minute he is back. Her nature, the core of her being, the selfless act of making that one man happy at any cost. She hid Shyam's truth from everyone because she didn't want to hurt anyone. She is doing the same now, not telling the complete truth about Shyam because she doesn't want to hurt ASR on Di's account. She is willing to bear his wrath but she can't see the man hurt should he ever find out his mother like Di has been betraying him all along. This is Khushi. The same Khushi we have seen from day 1 (minus post kidnapping) who sacrifices herself for others because that's how she breathes. So, one begs the question, if she is so hell bent on making ASR happy, why does it have the opposite effect? Because ASR has always told her it is his Di who matters the most! Khushi needs to know that today she hurt the husband in ASR more than the brother but how would she know that? Until something or someone makes her realize this, Khushi will always be DKL because in her mind, that is the ONLY way to make ASR happy.
ASR - the insecure, paranoid and tarnished man who finally found one person he thought he could trust, the one person in front of whom, he can lay his wounds bare and just be himself, his true self. It took him a long while (11/28/40/45 days to be exact) to get here but he is here now, at least he seems to think so. How could Khushi, the only one who knows how damaged ASR is, can do this? How can she betray his trust and make him question his decision? He put blind faith in her by kicking the man out of his Di's life, no questions asked. How can she bring the same man back in and question his judgement? How can she bruise his insecurities even more that somewhere maybe, just maybe he made a wrong decision? He is hurt because
faraq padta hai, he has come a long way but yet he is still too far. He is madly in love with Khushi, but does he truly understand Khushi? Does he not see this girl has proven time after time that she lives and breathes for other people? She openly asked him, if Di isn't happy, how can you be so? Does ASR not know, she married him to save her sister's wedding? Does ASR not know that behind the selfless acts of this girl lie a deeper issue of no self-worth? Does ASR not know that this girl doesn't exist for herself? Does ASR not know that she is in love with him madly but the only way she knows to make him happy is through hi Di? Does ASR not remember that he has always told Khushi it is his Di who matters the most! No, ASR doesn't. He is still learning. Until something or someone makes him realize this, Khushi will always be DKL and ASR will repeatedly get hurt.
(From an execution standpoint, I think there was a missed opportunity here. If the idea was to bring out the jealous lover, a line to the affect of "Khushi tum kaisay bhool sakti ho us nay humaray saath kiya kia, tumharay saath kiya kia" would have clarified the stance a lot better. I think the deeper reasoning for his reaction could've made an impact here, he felt betrayed and hated Shyam but why? because of his ego, Di or Khushi? this was important.)
Now that Mr. Hyde had some fun with his delusions, time for Dr. Jekyll to bring everyone back to reality:
I look at things holistically so it is almost impossible for me to ignore the character growth that they had shown for these two, perhaps that is where I part ways with a daily soap. Khushi knows what Shyam is capable of, she has first hand witnessed it. She knows how her impulsive and emotional decisions in the past have taken a turn for the worse. She lives and breathes for other people, how can she let a man in who nearly killed her husband and betrayed her husband's most treasured Di? What happened to her promise to ASR, "I'll always be there when you need me"? She is not justified in her actions.
ASR knows his anger gets the best of him, even after her realized his love for Khushi, his harsh words almost drove her out of his life. Time and time again, he has witnessed how his words hurt Khushi. Did he not apologize for every single time? Did he not realize she left for his Di before the contract was over? He did. So how could he use the same tone with her and ask her to get out regardless of what she did? If he understands her well, why would he completely shut her out? He has every right to be angry, no doubt, but to compare her with everyone else who has betrayed him is just wrong. To demean her by putting her in queue with every other person in his life is unfathomable. This girl almost gave up her life for him. He is not justified in his actions.
The saving grace here was the night scene where they both realized that they have yet to learn so much about the other person. The impact of ASR's own words "Just Go" on him, thinking what if she goes away and the jilted disappointment in Khushi about being misunderstood once again - both have put them back to square one: "What The.." for him and "jalebi making" for her. DM hi jaanay how long this 360 will last but this might be the only hope for the show now. Both of them have their own set of beliefs and they both think they are right. To us audience, they both are right and wrong but that doesn't matter. What matters is for these two characters to stand their ground and fight for what they believe in and in the process learn the other's point of view. It is not a question of what is morally right here, but a matter of self-preservation and confidence in their own decision.
The less I talk about Anjali, the better. I am all in favor of resilience and moving on because that is one of life's harsh realities but I am not at all in favor of insensitivity especially when it is portrayed at such an exponential level. The character of Anjali is a cascading effect of satyanaash! from conception to execution, input to output, the character is one of the worst portrayals of a woman and of all the roles a woman goes through in her life. Nothing more should be said about it.
Edited by joenet1234 - 12 years ago
850