Urgent..pls open this!

Page

Next Last

DMKJ_VB

@DMKJ_VB

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 14 years ago

Sorry!😉 I had to have everyone;s attention.

another reason of mentioning urgent...i will be online for only a while, so wanted to read as many replies as possible!

So, now coming to the post- I came across a post on gurmeet's acting. I hv no problem with the topic maker and i respect her point of view.but i wanted to post my opinion on the matter, so i thought why not create a new post...forum will also become more active😉

Now, some ppl feel that gurmeet is acting like Maan !

I disagree.

First, we need to understand one basic thing- Yash is a person who has lost the most loved person of his life...he is brooding, a loner, has chosen to stay aloof from family matters- so tell me ppl, do u expect him to smile and be cool?😲

He is the same guy who played MSK, so when yash becomes angry or he stays aloof...some of the expressions r bound to be similar! For God's sake, even Dilip Kumar nand Amitabh Bachchan wouldn't hv been able to do otherwise becoz it ain't humanly possible!

But those who r complaining- what about the scene with his wifee's photo? There was no MSK there at all!What about his instant change from anger to sadness when he begged his mother and bhabhi to not leave his daughters with a servant...i don't recall MSK folding hands ever!Gurmeet's expressions in that scene were completely out of the world...Fantastic! It was Yash and only Yash.

I could point out 100s of other minor differences, .his expressions during the Dargah scene, when he opened his eyes after praying- the pain, the sadness- sorry, but i never saw that in MSK...this was Yash...as MSK his eyes portrayed a different pain in sad scenes, and here i saw a guy who had lost his most treasured possession and was struggling to survive!

So, for me guru is brilliant as Yash! What do u all think? please share ur views.

Quote

Frequent Posters

Jacob

@Jacob

Beginner

Posted: 14 years ago

Completly agree...

But maybe it is big time we should ignore the fact yash is like msk...

Opening post like this will create more problem...

You saying not to compare but you maybe the 2nd person to point out,... And if you do point out this brings question in peoples mind.

Maybe we should stop here opening a new post exactly like people have before only brings the whole msk though in this forum.

Maybe dont answer and it will disapear.

You can only create a mess by replying.

Therefore can we please not talk about msk in this forum at all... People who do talk about it , soon as the story line of PV settle it will disappear...

Opening post after post saying msk is not like yash will only keep the topic wake and this will linger in peoples mind.

Edited by Jacob - 14 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

DMKJ_VB

@DMKJ_VB

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: Jacob
Completly agree...
But maybe it is big time we should ignore the fact yash is like msk...

Opening post like this will create more problem...

You saying not to compare but you maybe the 2nd person to point out,... And if you do point out this brings question in peoples mind.

Maybe we should stop here opening a new post exactly like people have before only brings the whole msk though in this forum.

Maybe dont answer and it will disapear.

You can only create a mess by replying.

Therefore can we please not talk about msk in this forum at all... People who do talk about it , soon as the story line of PV settle it will disappear...

Opening post after post saying msk is not like yash will only keep the topic wake and this will linger in peoples mind.

u hv a point there..but this post is about Gurmeet's versatality, and not MSK..i pointed out MSK becoz that whom yash was being compared to.or else believe me, i am the last person who wants to bring MSK here😛

Quote

veena

@VEENAGOPAL

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 14 years ago

Amazing Post..I wonder why ppl compare..GURU is entirely different for me here as YASH. For one second also i am not feeling he was MSK..Any ways some ppl will not get satisfied whatever they get..GURU rocks all over as YASH

Quote

LuvStrk-001

@LuvStrk-001

Dazzler

Posted: 14 years ago

Completely agree with ur post!!!!Its high time lest stop comparing YASH and MSK!!!!Lets respect and appreciated the hard work the actor is putting in the character YASH!!!!I really dnt know much abt MSK as i hve watched the show in bits parts oly!!!There i guess so he played as a lover boy and here is a mature person with the two kids and lost the biggest gift tat is luv of his life tat is her wife!!Clearly u cn notice the pain in his eyes!!so lets stop commenting on tat post it ll nt matter much!!!!!😊

Quote

Sonia KN

@Sonia.KN

Sparkler

+ 5

Posted: 14 years ago

Rite u r saying what I second.Dear I know he is yash not MSK link is GC...People should think about this if some one talk about GC MSK or Yash kahi to kahi three of these persons r different yet one.their every shade gonna reflect other.So I sincerely request some attention seekers(not u ) plz try to avoid bash if some one talk about two shades of 1 person jst to get attention This is sudden transformation that it ll take time to b used of 😳

Quote

Manali

@I_LoveYou_Kanha

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

Absolutely Right & awesome post dear!!!
100% agree with you...HE is doing an awesome job as Yash, & the most important thing Yash is playing by the same person who played MSK so it's obeous that his face can't be change..😆...am laughing on those people who thinks that GC is copying MSK...🤣, GC was MSK & GC is Yash too, Both the Characters are of one person...that Is Gurmeet Choudhary...Copy ka to matlab hi nahi banta, an wo apni shakl to change nahi kar sakta!!!
GC rockss as Yash!!!

Edited by Iluvkanha_GCian - 14 years ago

Quote

Janaki

@RamKiSeeta

Achiever

+ 6

Posted: 14 years ago

What about his instant change from anger to sadness when he begged his mother and bhabhi to not leave his daughters with a servant...i don't recall MSK folding hands ever![/QUOTE] Yes, he seemed more like Ram than MSK to me in that scene, because many of Gurmeet's expressions during Uttarkand of Ramayana, after Sita's exile when he's mourning her loss, are similar to Yash mourning his dead wife. The way he hugged his small daughters is similar to the way he hugged Luv and Kush after Sita returned to Dharti Ma. In both scenes he had tears and pain in his eyes.

So more than MSK, I see similarities between Ram and Yash, BUT the similarities are bound to happen because Ram, MSK, and Yash are all played by the same actor. His expressions are his own and when it is required for Yash to become angry or displeased, he will seem similar to MSK, and when he is supposed to portray pain and tears, he will seem similar to Uttarkand Ram.

Because Yash is played by Gurmeet after both Ram and Maan, I think we will continue to see many similarities, but the fact remains that Yash is Yash, and he is neither 100% like Ram or Maan, so let's appreciate him for his own character and not constantly compare.

If it came to that, I could say Aarti's attitude is simialr to that of Rani Laxmibai's, but there's no point in comparing because she is not Laxmibai and Aarti is her own unique character. Similar, Yash is also.

Edited by JanakiRaghunath - 14 years ago

Quote

BatameezDil

@BatameezDil

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 14 years ago

completely agree with you ria
as yash, GC's expressions and his body language is different from MSk

someone said that his voice was like MSK in scene where he was shouting at servant ...lol
he can't change his voice modulations yar...obviously ab voice changer to laga nahi sakta GC 😆
some of posts just doesn't make any sense to me...voice same hai,eyes same hai...😆

sorry but i found such posts lame and funny ... criticize krne ke liye aur kuch na ho to hairstyle,stubble aur voice ke peche pad jana😆