Sid Mahek Rajgaddi task

Just saw yesterday's episode.

Why was what Sid-Mahek did unfair? THey played completely as per the rules of BB. The only thing perhaps which Sid did wrong was not show them the letter but there was no rule to say they couldnt keep switching places. In fact Im sure Juhi and Sky would have done the same once they would have gotten on. The thing was they just tried to act very cool about it and got kicked in the process. Sky in fact did run to go get the throne but seeing other people not paying much attention I guess he thought it would look stupid if he got on and so didnt take the throne right away. Sid Mahek did the task excellently as per the rules, there was no rule to say janta had to be happy so dont know why BB brought that in later and said they failed becoz of it. Me thinks BB's purpose of picking the correct winner for this game didnt happen and so they decided to just forfeit the game. I wonder who BB team wanted to win and for what reason.

And Sid was brilliant in the task especially his sorry burp and even his one liners😆😆 in response to Sky's sore loser ranting. SKy was atrocious crying MOMMY again becoz somebody answered him back and mentioned a bad word "bum" . And that pebble throwing - wth was that???? What a stupid and petty childish thing to do !

Today goes to Sid for making me laugh so much with his well timed burp !!!😆
😆

sid ko leetter nhe chupana tha baqi sab theek tha !!!

Sid created whole confusion by hiding the letter. When it comes to task rules, both groups were not on the same page. We can not say if sid-mehak played task per rules unless they share it with all housemates and convince them as well. And why would someone hide letter if they think they are following rules of the task ? Clearly there was a catch in the rule that they did not want to share with other group 😉

Sorry burp was funny 😆 Sometimes I enjoy this "tu tu main main" of Sky n sid 😆

agree, sid ko letter chupana nahi chahiye tha

Yeah okay I guess not showing the letter was a big thing. Though really I dont get why they didnt show it - when they read it aloud so many times nothing the letter said would have given any advantage to anyone. In fact Sid's and Mahek's position would have been strengthened becoz the letter didnt say anything about switching only between two people was not allowed. Wish they would have shown the letter and won the task completely fair and square. But I am also betting the impending wrath of Juhi also made BB take the decision of declaring the task not properly done. 😊

Sky gang had already read the letter many times so it was ok to keep the letter...it wasn't hiding actually and they did not break any rules.we loved the task.sky Juhi and amar were fools they could not see the opportunity to sit on that throne...even Mahek did not think about it...until sid made her realise ...only sid had the brilliant idea of sitting on the rajgaddi and switching with mahek ...in my opinion they did the task wholeheartedly even at midnight when mahek went to washroom they took the task seriously and Sid sat in her place ...which was good thing as sky beep cycle was waiting for her to get up...enjoyed every moment...Sid is really good...

Originally posted by: shellily

Just saw yesterday's episode.

Why was what Sid-Mahek did unfair? THey played completely as per the rules of BB. The only thing perhaps which Sid did wrong was not show them the letter but there was no rule to say they couldnt keep switching places. In fact Im sure Juhi and Sky would have done the same once they would have gotten on. The thing was they just tried to act very cool about it and got kicked in the process. Sky in fact did run to go get the throne but seeing other people not paying much attention I guess he thought it would look stupid if he got on and so didnt take the throne right away. Sid Mahek did the task excellently as per the rules, there was no rule to say janta had to be happy so dont know why BB brought that in later and said they failed becoz of it. Me thinks BB's purpose of picking the correct winner for this game didnt happen and so they decided to just forfeit the game. I wonder who BB team wanted to win and for what reason.

And Sid was brilliant in the task especially his sorry burp and even his one liners😆😆 in response to Sky's sore loser ranting. SKy was atrocious crying MOMMY again becoz somebody answered him back and mentioned a bad word "bum" . And that pebble throwing - wth was that???? What a stupid and petty childish thing to do !

Today goes to Sid for making me laugh so much with his well timed burp !!!😆
😆

They played completely as per the rules of BB>>>>>>>>>>..ya you are right...it is BB rule that hide the rule book from other contestants...don't allow them to read...isn't it ...if Sid and Mahek were so confident about their strategy then why didn't they allowed others to read...By not allowing itself show that are unfair...


Why was what Sid-Mahek did unfair?>>>>>>>>>>>Sid's reason I have written above...Mahek's reason for not giving enough household work to SID...I remember once she mention that it is very tough for any captain to get SID working...Here it was mahek's chance but she choose not to give work to SID but give more work to SKY...why ? also again if I am not wrong when Shraddha sharma was made princess she ordered some work to SID and he opposed to do any work...

Originally posted by: praval

Sky gang had already read the letter many times so it was ok to keep the letter...it wasn't hiding actually and they did not break any rules.we loved the task.sky Juhi and amar were fools they could not see the opportunity to sit on that throne...even Mahek did not think about it...until sid made her realise ...only sid had the brilliant idea of sitting on the rajgaddi and switching with mahek ...in my opinion they did the task wholeheartedly even at midnight when mahek went to washroom they took the task seriously and Sid sat in her place ...which was good thing as sky beep cycle was waiting for her to get up...enjoyed every moment...Sid is really good...

If sky gang had brains they would have done same thing

Yeah do agree to it that it was not as if the content of the letter was any secret - everyone knew about it...but I think it is a BB rule to let anyone see the rules of a particular task as many times as they want for the duration of the task. It wouldnt have changed the outcome of the task if they had shown the letter so that was perhaps one tiny mistake which Sid and Mahek made. But both of them did the task very well and bahut hard work kiya uske liye -- I wish they would have won something for it. Sky gang brains grew out later on when they realized that acting smart mein woh log gadhi kho baithe and then they resorted to stupid nonsense of throwing stones as sleeping girls. 😕

Originally posted by: chirag2205

They played completely as per the rules of BB>>>>>>>>>>..ya you are right...it is BB rule that hide the rule book from other contestants...don't allow them to read...isn't it ...if Sid and Mahek were so confident about their strategy then why didn't they allowed others to read...By not allowing itself show that are unfair...


Why was what Sid-Mahek did unfair?>>>>>>>>>>>Sid's reason I have written above...Mahek's reason for not giving enough household work to SID...I remember once she mention that it is very tough for any captain to get SID working...Here it was mahek's chance but she choose not to give work to SID but give more work to SKY...why ? also again if I am not wrong when Shraddha sharma was made princess she ordered some work to SID and he opposed to do any work...

Yeah did accept hiding the rules was a bit silly. But I was talking about being fair according to the rules of the game - which in every other case both were completely playing within the rules. Unfairness in other things around the house everyone has done to everyone -- but that is not the focus of the discussion here. I was talking only strictly pertaining to the task. 😊

Originally posted by: shellily

Yeah did accept hiding the rules was a bit silly. But I was talking about being fair according to the rules of the game - which in every other case both were completely playing within the rules. Unfairness in other things around the house everyone has done to everyone -- but that is not the focus of the discussion here. I was talking only strictly pertaining to the task. 😊

task main ek dafa bethna hain yeh to kahin nhe likha tha i think ya aisa kuch tha sab fair khela but leteer chupane aur apne kingdom main sid sahab larai karrahe hian gali galoch karrahe hain 😛