Tum Aisi Kyun Ho Navya? - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

18

Views

2.6k

Users

10

Likes

51

Frequent Posters

laddoo598 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#11

Hello there! Nice post.😊I was going to make a post myself but you've pointed out some of the things going on in my mind so I thought I'll reply to you here. ^^

The first scene of today's episode was so bittersweet..I am so glad Anant did not misunderstand Navya's viewpoint.. He did not question her on her nonchalance about the whole issue, did not ask her why she wasn't trying to understand his plight, did not blame her for not being there for him when he needed her the most.. I didn't think I'd like today's episode even one bit especially with the comments going around about Navya and her constant rona dhona which will get extended for a long time. But I did like it, somewhat. Okay, honestly, I only liked the first scene. You're right about it being bittersweet but...I think Anant didn't misunderstand Navya because she wasn't nonchalant. It's quite the opposite. The girl is clearly heartbroken. She was breaking down and crying everywhere but now she has put herself together and in yesterday's episode, she had made it clear that she's making a sacrifice for others. Even if they haven't said the L word to each other, she loves him but she feels that she owes this much to her parents who love her and trust her so much.

When I say she is being nonchalant I am referring to her actions in the last 2-3 episodes. .The show took a leap of about 4 days and during that time we saw how Navya avoided Anant..I feel in a way she should have been there to listen to what he has to say..As Anant himself said yestererday he feels suffocated everywhere he goes and the only one who could understand his situation is shutting him out..I totally understand Navya's decision to end things with him but that does not mean she has to avoid him all the time..Especially when he has come to her, asking for some comfort, some answers from time to time..

He understood her..He could see how much it was hurting her to do all these..Loved when he said "Why can't you think about yourself for once? Why can't we think about ourselves?". Beautiful way of putting it.😊 I was left with a lump in my throat at the end of this moment. I feel for Anant, mostly. At least Navya is living in a place where she gets love, is understood. On the other hand, Anant is living with people who don't even want to know how he feels. His own people are only concerned about their own agendas. Even though I'm a female, I can really relate to Anant. I think the moment struck a chord with me because I know what he's feeling. He doesn't have anywhere to go, confusion is eating up his mind. I really feel sorry for him.& I think, this isn't running away. He just doesn't have any SHELTER, where he can find some solace or peace of mind.
I was angry with the CVs earlier this week for the recent character progress in Anant but they have once again shown that there is a bigger picture. BUT I'm still angry with the so-called traditional Bajpayees and the Banarasians. They will never make sense to me.

Lovely way of putting Anant's state of mind in words, couldn't agree more..Navya has a loving family..Appy and Ritz are there to listen to her..But poor Anant has to deal with his mess all alone..O

I feel somewhere her admission of her plight would have provided a little bit of comfort to Anant's troubled mind..😊Laddoo598, this would be a great comfort to both Anant and those watching his suffering. But I feel that this would have made things worse for him. If Navya has really made up her mind that she's not going to do anything about this, then telling him about how much she's hurting, how much she loves him, I think that would be putting a burden on him. What I want is for her to go speak to her dad, who is the person she probably feels the closest to, and ask him the rights and wrongs of this. This would be a huge risk, yes, but it's time they realised that they need some mature advice. I feel that Navya's dad would try to think objectively about this and let her have her say even if the rest of the family is scandalised. I want her to realise that this sacrifice is not needed. Anant is a great guy and they haven't done anything wrong, so to speak, so there's no reason why this charade has to go on any longer.

Hmm I see where you are coming from..Navya does not need to proclaim her love but at the same time she should not shut him out too..She should sympathize with him and comfort him as a friend at least..When he told her that feels like running away from all this, he feels suffocated at home and all, her reaction to his confession seemed dull to me..Wahi same old 'Hum e yeh sab bhul na hoga Anant, family ko dukh nahin pohochana chahiye" He knows all this already. Remember, he was the one who backed out first, he was the one who thought about the reaction of the families first..What he needed at that point of time was some comfort, some sympathy..She should have told him that she understands him..Just a simple "Main samajh sakti hu Anant" would have gone a long way..I thought if Anant knew that all this was just as hard for Navya as it is for him then he would feel a bit of comfort..Again thats just my point of view..


Lets see if Navya actually manages to find Anant or someone else gets to him before she does..I am still skeptic about Navya's mom finding out about her and Anant so soon..There is already enough drama going on, we don't need another twist.. Maybe Navya's mum finding out is the right thing to happen here. In my opinion, too much screen space is given to the wrong type of drama, Navya crying and feeling helpless, calls going back and forth about where Anant could possibly be, the Bajpayee house circus, etc etc. It's time to close the generation gap and show us that 2 young people who love each other don't have to elope or resort to other drastic measures to be with each other.
I feel its too early to get the parents involved already..Anant and Navya are still not aware about the extent of their emotions for each other..If they were they would not go for the break up option without even trying to save the relationship first..If they themselves are not ready to fight for the relationship then whats the point of letting the parents know? I feel both of them need time to think things through, to talk between themselves and decide if they are going to go to separation or stay together..The spotlight needs to be taken away from them..Once this engagement horror drama ends the CVs can start Renu's track..After seeing Renu's marriage in trouble Navya's parents will be a little more liberal towards her relationship with Anant, seeing how arranged marriage at a young age did not work too well for their other daughter..And the shoft of focus to Renu's track will also give AnYa enough time to realize that there relationship is worth fighting for..

Thanks for the thought provoking reply Aimin..Will look forward to your posts in the forum..😛
.Juhi. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#12
woah...ossam post dear...i agree wid each & evry wrd of urs...luvly post
barbie2011 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#13
I LOVED THE ORIGINAL POST BUT I LOVED MORE THE NEXT REVISED VERSION THT WAS POSTED WITH THE REACTION. 👏
You have added so much details to this that i have nothing else to say...😆
Wow, nice way to look at it. I basically liked the Renu's point the best. That would be a good way and it would be a good breather to everybody especially ANYA.
1 thing that I am concerned is , I read that the engagement gets called off, but wht will happen so that the engagement gets cancelled. I hope they just dont postpone it. Something has to happen that make the Bajpais understand the Banraswali is not what anant wants and at least for once they think abt his happiness...
Nice post once again...Keep it up
chucklebuddy thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#14
wonderful post... 👏 v well written... 👍🏼
aimin thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: laddoo598


When I say she is being nonchalant I am referring to her actions in the last 2-3 episodes. .The show took a leap of about 4 days and during that time we saw how Navya avoided Anant..I feel in a way she should have been there to listen to what he has to say..As Anant himself said yestererday he feels suffocated everywhere he goes and the only one who could understand his situation is shutting him out..I totally understand Navya's decision to end things with him but that does not mean she has to avoid him all the time..Especially when he has come to her, asking for some comfort, some answers from time to time..
Lol, we could talk our opposing sides all week and possibly the whole month even. She did get into his car, she did listen to him na? No matter what, they both are suffering equally. Navya is just trying to be brave (& failing miserably) with the strength she gets from her loved ones.

Hmm I see where you are coming from..Navya does not need to proclaim her love but at the same time she should not shut him out too..She should sympathize with him and comfort him as a friend at least..When he told her that feels like running away from all this, he feels suffocated at home and all, her reaction to his confession seemed dull to me..Wahi same old 'Hum e yeh sab bhul na hoga Anant, family ko dukh nahin pohochana chahiye" He knows all this already. Remember, he was the one who backed out first, he was the one who thought about the reaction of the families first..What he needed at that point of time was some comfort, some sympathy..She should have told him that she understands him..Just a simple "Main samajh sakti hu Anant" would have gone a long way..I thought if Anant knew that all this was just as hard for Navya as it is for him then he would feel a bit of comfort..Again thats just my point of view..
I totally agree with you on the bold parts. But again, I still think miserable as he was, as dull as her response to him was, he understood her. Only we the viewers are unsatisfied because of all the unspoken, possible dialogues. I watched the episode again and what Anant said to her which brought out a whole barrage of subtleties that I had missed before. His rhetorical question of why she's like that, why they're like that, selfless and sacrificing. He understands her and perhaps that's one of the things that draws her to him. Outwardly she may seem a coward but is an incredibly thoughtful person, her heart rooted in tradition. Though I don't like Navya's approach towards this (& her monotony), looks like Anant is more understanding to her plight and decision. (Well, he's the one in love with her, anyway, not us >_>)

I feel its too early to get the parents involved already..Anant and Navya are still not aware about the extent of their emotions for each other..If they were they would not go for the break up option without even trying to save the relationship first..If they themselves are not ready to fight for the relationship then whats the point of letting the parents know? I feel both of them need time to think things through, to talk between themselves and decide if they are going to go to separation or stay together..The spotlight needs to be taken away from them..Once this engagement horror drama ends the CVs can start Renu's track..After seeing Renu's marriage in trouble Navya's parents will be a little more liberal towards her relationship with Anant, seeing how arranged marriage at a young age did not work too well for their other daughter..And the shoft of focus to Renu's track will also give AnYa enough time to realize that there relationship is worth fighting for..
Ah, common ground! After what you said, it made me think that perhaps you're right. I want to get the parents involved, but maybe not now... I'm still very confused as to how the engagement is going to be called off, though. Wasn't it mentioned somewhere that Anant will get engaged to Sagun? I just don't want Anant to get in trouble. Poor bloke is suffering for no reason already. A guy who commented on a post of mine wrote that he would rather remain celibate than getting married to someone like Sagun, lol. Bechara Anant.
About the Renu track, I want her to be in focus as well. She is one of my favourite characters in Navya, mostly because she's so believable. She practically symbolises the majority of problems the average woman would go through and possibly even more. But I think she would have to have borne loads in her sasural to come scooting back to her home.

Thanks for the thought provoking reply Aimin..Will look forward to your posts in the forum..😛
Likewise, likewise!


& it was really nice, exchanging thoughts with you.😊
laddoo598 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: barbie2011

I LOVED THE ORIGINAL POST BUT I LOVED MORE THE NEXT REVISED VERSION THT WAS POSTED WITH THE REACTION. 👏

You have added so much details to this that i have nothing else to say...😆
Wow, nice way to look at it. I basically liked the Renu's point the best. That would be a good way and it would be a good breather to everybody especially ANYA.
1 thing that I am concerned is , I read that the engagement gets called off, but wht will happen so that the engagement gets cancelled. I hope they just dont postpone it. Something has to happen that make the Bajpais understand the Banraswali is not what anant wants and at least for once they think abt his happiness...
Nice post once again...Keep it up



First of all, thanks so much for such lovely and encouraging comments..😛
As far as the engagement is concerned looks like the loony clan will just postpone the engagement till Anant recovers from his illness..
Anant's happiness, what he wants is not important to creepy baba..🤢
laddoo598 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: aimin


& it was really nice, exchanging thoughts with you.😊



Glad we reached a consensus..😆
About the engagement- from what I could gather from the articles posted in the forum, the engagement will be postponed as Anant is ill..
Something major has to happen for this engagement to break..I actually wanted to see Shagun backing out once she realized that Anant loves someone else..That would have been realistic..Which girl would go after a guy who is in love with someone else? But I doubt CVs will show that..they would rather transform her into a full fledged villain instead..🤢
Edited by laddoo598 - 14 years ago
barbie2011 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#18
par agar Engagement ho gayi, to phir to Anya... kabhi saath nahin honge...😭
Phir to kuch bhi acha nahi rahega dekhne ko... I cannot watch anant with Shagun at all...
They are the lead characters to phir aisa kaise kar sakte hain...
Please dont get him engaged, CV's koi acha twist socho, Engagement todne ke liye,...
Agar engagement ho gayi to sara craze chala jayega.. story aur bhi boring aur depressing ho jayegi...
Shidev.Soniak thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#19
Loved the post yaar. Amazing post.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".