Just a little too much...!

Hi I just saw the rerun for the gala rite noww. Both of them rocked today! 👏But the gala wastn that great, the songs were wierd. but I m still with wat I said earlierr. Yes Iagreee Karunya sang soooo grrrreattt todayy!! FANTASTIC MIND BLOWING. And he desreves everii single praise he got. But isnt the note thingg too much?? Couldnt Sonu hav shown that to him bakstage or sumthing?? Isnt Minii being overlyy enthuastic weneverr Karunya cumz bak frm perofrmance lil too muchh? Isnt getting 2 TV starzz taht r sayy Karu is II2 too muchh? Anu Malik I thought wuz TOTALLY UNFAIR TODAY! First evn befor gala started he said Karu is II2. Then after.. why is he telling Sandeep that Sandy thinks he is gonna get votes watever the judges say..How does he know wat Sandeep is thinking?? And Anu Malikk interuptss Farah Khann that is soo ruude he shud let her say watevrr she wants! And he wuz talkin bout his smiile..wat kinda critism is taht?? how does it like help him improve? Before this morning I was fightingg wit ppl that it was unfair to Sandeep. Noww I feel it is REALLYYY unfair to SAnddeeep. I AGREEE KARunya sangg better than him todayy. But Is all that EXTRAAA PRAISE AND PROMOTION really needed??? The praise he got frm the judges, the crying, the applaud is enough. But I thinkk they went a little over the top! Indian Idol is reallyy losinggg my respect now! Sorry... this is nothingg at all against any Kaurnya fans or Sandeep fans. I m just saying wat I feel.

I dont wanna fight with anyone in this threadd cuz I hav dun enough fighting this morning..lol and Im sick n tiredd n i just wanted to post all wat i feel in this thread.

I agree but i still like Karu more...bgut u shud b happy dat sandy is leadin in votes!

RexLover I am with you. just watched on sony. totally biased !! unfair all of them was just blind folded

karu is great but if everybody is correct 100% then I would say Sonu is number 2 and karunya is number 1 as of date - what u say folks

Originally posted by: famegurukul_fan

I agree but i still like Karu more...bgut u shud b happy dat sandy is leadin in votes!

ok thats great u like Karu more...I didnt make this topic to lessen ur like for Karu! lol

How do u knoww Sandeep is leading in votes?

I can understand the predicament of the judges. They have seen and know who is the really talented person. They are too mature and knowledgeable to be swayed by just charming smiles. Having seen how the junta votes they are worried that the real deserving candidate will be voted out. They are trying to put some sense in the crowds by giving a clear verdict in one's favor. In this process they seem to go overboard sometimes in praising someone or criticizing the other. People who can see this will understand their position. People who don't see this will be offended and the judges actions might be counterproductive. But I think that the judges were truly moved by his talent and overjoyed by his performances. That is why they could not hide their feelings.

zee you just listed everything i felt after i watched the show...

Originally posted by: ReXLoVeR

Hi I just saw the rerun for the gala rite noww. Both of them rocked today! 👏But the gala wastn that great, the songs were wierd. but I m still with wat I said earlierr. Yes Iagreee Karunya sang soooo grrrreattt todayy!! FANTASTIC MIND BLOWING. And he desreves everii single praise he got. But isnt the note thingg too much?? Couldnt Sonu hav shown that to him bakstage or sumthing?? Isnt Minii being overlyy enthuastic weneverr Karunya cumz bak frm perofrmance lil too muchh? Isnt getting 2 TV starzz taht r sayy Karu is II2 too muchh? Anu Malik I thought wuz TOTALLY UNFAIR TODAY! First evn befor gala started he said Karu is II2. Then after.. why is he telling Sandeep that Sandy thinks he is gonna get votes watever the judges say..How does he know wat Sandeep is thinking?? And Anu Malikk interuptss Farah Khann that is soo ruude he shud let her say watevrr she wants! And he wuz talkin bout his smiile..wat kinda critism is taht?? how does it like help him improve? Before this morning I was fightingg wit ppl that it was unfair to Sandeep. Noww I feel it is REALLYYY unfair to SAnddeeep. I AGREEE KARunya sangg better than him todayy. But Is all that EXTRAAA PRAISE AND PROMOTION really needed??? The praise he got frm the judges, the crying, the applaud is enough. But I thinkk they went a little over the top! Indian Idol is reallyy losinggg my respect now! Sorry... this is nothingg at all against any Kaurnya fans or Sandeep fans. I m just saying wat I feel.

I dont wanna fight with anyone in this threadd cuz I hav dun enough fighting this morning..lol and Im sick n tiredd n i just wanted to post all wat i feel in this thread.

I COMPLETELY AGREE! The Final Gala was a bit too much!
And Anu Malik was completely unfair!

Listen, if someone is good he is good..and why shouldn't they say so. they are judges and their judgement is that Karunya is the better singer. we have seen what happened with Fame Gurukul...where no one listened to the judges..and what did we get a cute likeable non singer who is off the radar now... not that Karunya will ever be off the radar...but you can't match the talent of Karunya with anyone else .. they are way below his league..

Why does it upset everyone to see the judges speak their mind? I can't fathom...??????????

Originally posted by: jakapa

I can understand the predicament of the judges. They have seen and know who is the really talented person. They are too mature and knowledgeable to be swayed by just charming smiles. Having seen how the junta votes they are worried that the real deserving candidate will be voted out. They are trying to put some sense in the crowds by giving a clear verdict in one's favor. In this process they seem to go overboard sometimes in praising someone or criticizing the other. People who can see this will understand their position. People who don't see this will be offended and the judges actions might be counterproductive. But I think that the judges were truly moved by his talent and overjoyed by his performances. That is why they could not hide their feelings.

She is not asking your opinion jakapa...she said what she felt and therz no mean justifyiing what had happened and why that happened...no one denies karu's talent n all his super-great abilities....he deserve more than Indian Idol Title...I was worried the way Sonu was praising him, he wud have called him better than himself...which wud have been the greatest compliment for karu...but...
anyway,
@ Zee, plz not go too senti....plz...you know exactly what I mean...

peace

Originally posted by: avadvani

Listen, if someone is good he is good..and why shouldn't they say so. they are judges and their judgement is that Karunya is the better singer. we have seen what happened with Fame Gurukul...where no one listened to the judges..and what did we get a cute likeable non singer who is off the radar now... not that Karunya will ever be off the radar...but you can't match the talent of Karunya with anyone else .. they are way below his league..
Why does it upset everyone to see the judges speak their mind? I can't fathom...??????????

First thing, we aint complaining that why someone is good or bad....anyway, it seems u even didt know what we were talking abt all the day....u just dropped in n made a comment....and u have right to do so.....no issue....

second, do you think ppl listen to Judges? ask yourself.....and let us know what do u feel....and how wud u vote if someone tells u whats good n whats not.....
third, who said karu is not a talent...he is a real talent but that doesnt give right to judges to discourage others....thats what we are asking ourselves...why wud one do that, and was that necessary?

anyway....stay tuned here n then reply..not in a hurry though

peace