Upset at the judges - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

34

Views

2.2k

Users

27

Frequent Posters

frosty thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#31
Its not that I think that the judges should not criticize, thats what they are
there for. However, there is a time and place to do so. We all have
favourites, but as judges it is their duty to look past that. Did they not
know when they agreed to be judges that the best singers may be voted
out. Agreed that II may not produce the best singer, but that is the
FORMAT of the show. Sonu keeps saying that I will walk out, lie down etc.
Well OK if you have such a problem with the show, leave. Do not come
back for the next season. Will he do that - NO. He and the other judges
like the money and recognition that this show gets.
As far as Anuj is concerned, if they had such a huge problem with his
voice, there were several points at which they could have thrown him out.
At the initial elims, when Jolly could not return. Did they bring him back
thinking that he would be voted out soon and would not pose a threat to
their favourites?
Sonu, Anu and Farah need to respect the audience decision, by walking
out etc they are not only dissing Anuj, they are also disrespecting the
audience of India
Edited by frosty - 19 years ago
coolsonu thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 19 years ago
#32

Originally posted by: lucky_lakshmi

well...u know...we cannot blame the judges..they are helpless...they simply sit watching the participants perform...they juss give their views but the voters arent taking their views into account and r not voting on the basis of talent.
It will be shame for the judges if a undeserving person wins...they can do nothibg...wont they feel bad?
They simply sit as watchers...In FG at least..the judges had some power to take decisions.

Also...i thought ...when they gave a standing ovation to Anuj...they were supporting him and giving him courage to face life.



I stronglyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy AGREE!! 😳
Qazi_Fan thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#33

Originally posted by: frosty

Its not that I think that the judges should not criticize, thats what they are
there for. However, there is a time and place to do so. We all have
favourites, but as judges it is their duty to look past that. Did they not
know when they agreed to be judges that the best singers may be voted
out. Agreed that II may not produce the best singer, but that is the
FORMAT of the show. Sonu keeps saying that I will walk out, lie down etc.
Well OK if you have such a problem with the show, leave. Do not come
back for the next season. Will he do that - NO. He and the other judges
like the money and recognition that this show gets.
As far as Anuj is concerned, if they had such a huge problem with his
voice, there were several points at which they could have thrown him out.
At the initial elims, when Jolly could not return. Did they bring him back
thinking that he would be voted out soon and would not pose a threat to
their favourites?
Sonu, Anu and Farah need to respect the audience decision, by walking
out etc they are not only dissing Anuj, they are also disrespecting the
audience of India



i totally agree.. sonu's comments like lie down n all were soo humiliating.. if they want the result just a particualr one.. then just stop public voting and dont waste our money... it was really digusting..

i cried for anuj .. and i miss him 😭
breathing_irony thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#34
yes the jduges have been very insensitive when it comes to anuj. OK, i knw karu is the best among the top3, but tht doesnt mean u humiliate some1 to this extent.

They didnt even think abt anuj during the walk-out drama. Amey was the only one who's anger towards anuj would be justified to an extent, but ironically, he was the one who actually stood up for anuj. I dont get it. When Amey didnt mind Anuj being there, why do the judges have a problem....why do they keep rubbing it in. Imagine being stuck somewhere and performing in front of ppl who u knw arent going to appreciate you no matter what. HOW much more demotivating can it get!!!

And not only tht, even the way mini made karu believe he got the highest votes only to break tht belief later on was so disgusting. I dont see how playing with people's emotions lik this is entertainment. What sadistic pleasure do ppl get out of this.
pramm thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#35
judges' behaviour towards Anuj has been really disgusting....if we feel so sorry for him, imagine what his family and friends must have gone through!!!!....really hats off to Anuj for showing so much courage against all the odds....

the way Sony humiliated Karunya and his family during the recent result episode 🤢 .....these kids put in so much effort and hardwork, and imagine them going through all this rubbish.....is humiliation a part of the format?????

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".