Upset at the judges

Hello all

I am a HUGE fan of Karunya and Amey and was very very upset when
Amey was voted out. However, today was the first time during the
eliminations that I actually cried. I was never a fan of Anuj's voice, but I
do believe that the show has a format that we the audience and the
judges must accept. I can understand the anger that the judges and we
the audience feel at the elimination of a good singer.. That said, the
judges really humilated Anuj befor he left. Even before the entire process
started when they were asking the judges who they felt should be
eliminated, it was obvious that Anuj had tears in hs eyes..
While Anuj may not be the best singer in II, there is no doubt that he is
talented. The judges honestly have been unneccessarily brutal in their
criticism of Anuj. For Sonu to say that well this is the reality deal with it -
well I have something to say to him too. When Sonu got panned by critics
for his AWFUL acting in movies - he lashed out at everyone, the media
and the audiences for not accepting him. Well Sonu, you were an AWFUL
AWFUL actor and yet you could not take the criticisms of your peers. Anuj
is a pretty good singer, imagine what he went through when he heard the
kind of remarks that you guys made. Sonu and the others need to realize
that it is difficult for someone like Anuj to listen to comments like that
since Anuj knows that the judges are the people who can make his career.
Sonu also needs to understand that Anuj is 29 and II was probably his last
chance at making it big
I want Karunya to win but at the same time I want to give my best wishes
to Anuj and I will definately pray that someone gives him a break.

well...u know...we cannot blame the judges..they are helpless...they simply sit watching the participants perform...they juss give their views but the voters arent taking their views into account and r not voting on the basis of talent.
It will be shame for the judges if a undeserving person wins...they can do nothibg...wont they feel bad?
They simply sit as watchers...In FG at least..the judges had some power to take decisions.

Also...i thought ...when they gave a standing ovation to Anuj...they were supporting him and giving him courage to face life.

i hated yesterdays episode.I could bear to watch about 10 mins of it.I thing everything is handled with such poor taste.It is humiliating for everyone on the show and for us it is excruciating.has any one watched american idol results episodes.....in half an hour it is over...judges(contestants ,their families) are not repeatedly bombarded with the same idiotic Qs again and again. .why do mini and aman take such sadistic pleasure in torturing the poor terrified contestants.grrrr 😡

I cried for Anuj as well. I voted for Karunya and actually wanted Anuj out to, but the way they handled this whole thing and humiliated Anuj is disgusting.

By walking out they insulted Anuj. That's the foremat of the show and they should accept it. By Sonu not coming out at the beginning was very stupid too. Also the style in which they spoke to Anuj, its almost as if they are blaming him for people voting for him.

Fine, Praise karunya because he is a good singer, but don't insult the other singer. IT's sick.

I think Anuj can sing punjabi songs very well. Also he is very good looking with a very geniune personality .....I also wish him all the best in his future.

i felt really bad 4 him when he said that he also wanted judges to clap 4 him 😕
i really felt sad at that time

two times i hated judges most was when they humiliated anuj and his relatives at amey's ouster and again last night. if janta is voting for anuj then why is anuj getting blamed?

if judges want only karunya & amey then better stop public voting and throw all contestants out. i think they are mature adults so they should show a bit more respect for fellow human. they blamed a teenage niece of anuj. but i think these adults are immature.

judges shd. realise that by insulting the contestants they are the ones who are losing respect!!!

ya very true all of u guys

As a perosn, I liked Sonu a lot but as a judge in II2, he's worst. Anu Malik is always annoying and farah Khan I guess has nothing to say except Performance, which also she is not able to judge quite nicely as a person of her stature should do..so the only remaining responsible person to make immediate comments on any contestent's performance/singing/sur and taal is Sonu who himself actually is very very talented singer. I dont know why his scale is a bit tilted? With amey, he was not pleasant as he sud have been...amey was no doubt the best among the 12 finalists but he gave him 'not so bad' or okie comments while on the same shows, he praised Karu like he's already Idol!!
no offence to anyone but until its done, its not done! What others would feel if judges behave like this....his cursing to Sandeep is now gone past thing but he sud have been more realistic and knowning sandeep's strength, he sud have been able to understand why he was sticking to his strengths only - this is a life time opportunity and no one wanna miss anything to do their best.

Having said that, all of the judges were so brutal to Anuj after Amey's exit....why wud Anuj be balmed or humiliated? Amey was more sensible than these so called 'Judges'....

And my fear is even more worse, looking at the voting trends, popularity and increasing fanfare of Sandeep, what will happen on grand finale if he is declared Indian idol by Junta....? they will definitely ruin the show by their drama...they tried it twice n if u r really hurt, ur voice say it all...but I cant see any deviation in the way they are speaking after their drama....come on, we know u have ur own preferences but..ppl like Anuj and Ravi are aspirants and you judges sud better encourage them than to humiliate on such mega show!!
peace