UTTARAN a very realistic unusual story - Page 2

Originally posted by: ankit111

very rightly said. i always prefer a person sacrificing her own happiness tht a person snatching other happiness. although i dont support Ichha sacrificing Veer to Tapu, as Veer is not a commodity, but i can read it her dampness, gd intention with bad implementation. Ichha hs took a lot of bad decisions, but the main things going in her favor is her intention, she never wished bad for anybody. on contrary Tapu did everything intentionally. so i think Ichha deserve all happiness of life, just she sd be taught a lesson, which Veer r doing now.

agreed.we do our Karmas & watever its result r not in our hands but the only thing in our hands is our actions wid intentions whether gud or bad!! though sumtimes action wid gud intentions may result in bad result !! but still the only thing which differentiates gud from evil is intention !!

Originally posted by: tiny15

agreed.we do our Karmas & watever its result r not in our hands but the only thing in our hands is our actions wid intentions whether gud or bad!! though sumtimes action wid gud intentions may result in bad result !! but still the only thing which differentiates gud from evil is intention !!

(I am talking about Ichha only.......and I am not comparing her with Tapasya right now)

I agree with people that intention means a lot.....but my perspective about Ichha's intention is different...... her actions speak of a different kind of gratification by battering oneself rather than sacrificing for a higher cause.

e.g. Ichha's intentions seem to be "If there are 2 people ......I will sacrifice my happiness for the other"...........but her actions show a different intention "If there are 2 people........I will gratify myself......by finding a reason to sacrifice and hurt myself for the other-whatever is the consequence"..... She seems to be so carried away by the idea of hurting herself and calling it "sacrifice", that she cannot even see the consequence of her actions.

E.g. who is benefiting by her idea of destroying her lungs by inhaling tons of carbon monoxide.......by choosing unhealthy cooking methods, in the name of "widow sacrifices"...?.....who is benefiting by her idea of living an imprisoned life..?....... Isn't it a path to voluntary self destruction?...... People who are misguided enough to destroy themselves while they imagine they are doing some "sacrifice" for someone?

I feel its more of a misguided sense of idealism. Even those who renounce worldly pleasures do so with a higher objective of attaining actualization-and they don't harm themselves uselessly......and though Ichha has no bad objectives.....but then she doesn't seem to have any objectives, any purpose...any reasoning.....like nothing at all.....she seems to be motivated only by the idea of getting any opportunity that makes her hurt herself....I have seen her kind of doing nothing but harming herself for whatever excuse she can find (she opened one school earlier....whatever happened to it.....doesn't she need to work to finance that school at least?)

Originally posted by: hima_123

(I am talking about Ichha only.......and I am not comparing her with Tapasya right now)

I agree with people that intention means a lot.....but my perspective about Ichha's intention is different...... her actions speak of a different kind of gratification by battering oneself rather than sacrificing for a higher cause.

e.g. Ichha's intentions seem to be "If there are 2 people ......I will sacrifice my happiness for the other"...........but her actions show a different intention "If there are 2 people........I will gratify myself......by finding a reason to sacrifice and hurt myself for the other-whatever is the consequence"..... She seems to be so carried away by the idea of hurting herself and calling it "sacrifice", that she cannot even see the consequence of her actions.

E.g. who is benefiting by her idea of destroying her lungs by inhaling tons of carbon monoxide.......by choosing unhealthy cooking methods, in the name of "widow sacrifices"...?.....who is benefiting by her idea of living an imprisoned life..?....... Isn't it a path to voluntary self destruction?...... People who are misguided enough to destroy themselves while they imagine they are doing some "sacrifice" for someone?

I feel its more of a misguided sense of idealism. Even those who renounce worldly pleasures do so with a higher objective of attaining actualization-and they don't harm themselves uselessly......and though Ichha has no bad objectives.....but then she doesn't seem to have any objectives, any purpose...any reasoning.....like nothing at all.....she seems to be motivated only by the idea of getting any opportunity that makes her hurt herself....I have seen her kind of doing nothing but harming herself for whatever excuse she can find (she opened one school earlier....whatever happened to it.....doesn't she need to work to finance that school at least?)

Originally posted by: guddididi

@piasengupta no replacements,,but also the story track is quiet stable and the pure essence of the show is not lost still....unlike many other shows which start with a theme and then end up with something else in the time course