The Best and Worst Celebrity Judge

I consider celebrity judge those who actually sat and gave comments for a maximum part of the show, not the ones who just dropped by to entertain

Which thread should I choose to reply?

Originally posted by: slumdog

Which thread should I choose to reply?

Originally posted by: _Anonymous_

this one since your here already 😛

that was a funny question 😆

Best - Ranbir Kapoor

Best - Bipasha because she promoted mera shivam

If you talk about those judges who actually judged the performances closely, then I would definitely name out Sanjay Dutt, Shahid Kapoor and Lara Dutta.

Sanjay Dutt was the best in this regard, he closely listened to the songs and told what he felt. I really enjoyed all his comments on the performances.

Shahid gave critical comments on the voice textures of the few of the contestants. He appreciated in really good and correct words, instead of just saying the same old thing that it was a good performance, he actually made effort to analyze the voice, which was good to watch and listen.

Lara Dutta was good as well, she gave comments which were to the point and appreciative. Her comments showed that she actually listened to the song carefully.

As far as an entertainer celebrity goes, I would vote for Ranbir Kapoor, he danced, singed and appreciated the contestants in a really friendly way. He remained a true charmer on the show.

Nice topics Bahar, Loved all of them, they are breeze of fresh air.

Shahid Kapoor was a guest judge?? when?? 😲

Ranbir, Sanjay Dutt were cool..

The best are Lara Dutta and Shahid - Lara Dutta was quite honest of the lot ..she's critical and her feedback doesn't look like she trying to be nice and humble by praising the singers off like some other guest judges do. Plus her AMAZING voice, makes me wanna listen to her more!