Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 25
BALH Naya Season EDT Week #10: Aug 18 - Aug 22
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai - 18 Aug 2025 EDT
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai - 19 Aug 2025 EDT
GAADI CHOOTH GAYI 18.8
DAHII HANDI 19.8
Shradhanjali to Mr Anshuman Raizada
Disaster Monday: War 2 falls 75% to Rs. 6 cr, shows cancelled
Back to the pavilion when??
KJO To Return In 2026 With Classic Hindi Cinema
Faissal Khan's Shocking Revelations
Param Sundari ..Yay or Nay ?
I find it unprofessional
Rashmika Mandanna & Vijay Devarakonda India Day New York parade
Originally posted by: meens1981
aarthi brilliant post sweetheartš......first of all big hug š¤to u for the way u protrayed the sense of loss in all three of them.......it was indeed very touching
i told u just yest am not coming to IF forum but ur topic just forced me to šš
Well I have a slightly diff perspective .........for all three of them- samrat, mayank and gunjan but the most powerful one is that of nupur........she told mayank exactly what everyone else needs to do -is to forget and move on.....its very easy to say but so tough to even imagine.....death is such a painful thing.....d person who dies always finds peace in sum form through death.....at least we assume that....but the person worst affected is the one who is left behind......is int it so very unfair to be left behind???? but when has life ever been fair or is it always fair but we just fail to realize the realities while we are busy taking everything that comes our way for granted........a question one can never easily find an answer to
Mayank........he is going through such a tough phase........samrat and gunjan survived and may be some day they will get together.....but for mayank a meaning of togetherness died the day nupur left him.........i have been the one to believe that when a loved one leaves us, the only way that we can continue to live is to live with the gift of beautiful memories the person has bestowed on u.....its second best to having the person with u .......memories cannot be ever removed as long as u believe in d power they bring.....they r urs to create, cherish and live n u can remember them d way u want to....thankfully god has made one thing that no one can snatch or taint or touch, much as they may try to and he never put a restriction on the same.....yes thats d magic n d power of memories.....the way u percieve them shall decide whether u can continue to live every moment or u shall continue to die every second,....(diff between sec n moment....second is just meaningless time that shall look unbearable when u carry d baggage but moment is personalized time of urs with that sumone special which even d passage of time cant change or tamper with )........thats y i loved nupur's take....she wants to move on coz the only way in such tragic accidents, one can ever heal themselves is by making an attempt to move on.....by moving on do we mean forget the person, forget that they were ever part of our lives, forget that we believed a life which just was so full of mutual love n understanding......no never...... moving on means respect the aspect of love over hatred.........when fate is unfair to us, we are left with two choices--- we can either let fate win by living in denial and hatredness for d injustice belied to us or we can believe in the power of love, a beautiful gift with which the angel in question touched ur life with, we can honor the person's memory by continuing to remember them in happy n sad memories but with a perspective to draw strength from their memories to live on.....death can only be ever physical coz a person who has had the fortune to experience love shall become immortal forever to those whose life he or she has touched , death may spearate us physically from our loved one but no one can separate us from the love we feel for them, when we relive them in our memories........mayank may be on the road to that....but does that mean he can get over nupur.......loss of a loved one is a like a unseen void which much as u may try u can ignore but u can never forget....it stays with u just like ur vital organs, like d breathe u take......of-course d diff lies in how we keep our loved one alive even after death.........that shall decide the victory or defeat fate managed to throw upon u by its act....fair or unfair ....u can still decide.....all u need to do is heal
coming to samrat......am not sure how to judge his penance.....he is paying for a fault or sin which he never committed, yet he so committed it by d sheer ignorance of his confidence n unfortunate presence in d wrong place at wrong time......okie dont come to hit me.......am not blaming samrat.....all i am saying is life when cornered by darkness of death, all that revolves in ur mind is what if, if only's........sure it was a break failure no doubt .......but the only question the one indirectly is being held responsible for a sin he didnt commit is, cud he averted the accident had he gone slow, may be d breaks still wud have failed but d impact cud have been less had the speed of the car been in control........welll yes those r d thots of a heart in delusion wanting to lay d blame on sumone, for d loss they r suffering from....
yep am talking about gunjan......as a sister i can so understand her pain.....frankly i dont know in wat perspective CVs have made her indifferent and cold towards samrat but the prime reason i see for her behavior is samrat reminds her of the what if's n if onlys' , that cud have, may be a just a little bit helped in avoiding her sister's death........if she had forgiven samrat then n there believing in d power of her love n treating it as a freak accident , it deffo wud not have been natural coz everyday she wud have lived to hate samrat......gunjan is in d phase of denial but not without justification....every time she comes across samrat she will think if only samrat had listened to her n slowed down may b d repercussions wud not be so bad...........imagine when u lose the person who is an integral part of ur life n by some twisted game of fate it happens to be dat d reason u lost the person was becoz of d love of ur life.......how shattering it will be for d mind n heart to come to peace.......its like ur soul was d reason ur spirit got destroyed........yes samrat was not responsible directly but who is to tell d heart which is busy living the pain n loneliness n vacuum of a lifetime???, who can make it understand d abject realities of life?????, d person who left or d person who is left behind????? pain is so weird that it makes us visualize d most impossible of d possibilities that a sane mind wud fear from thinking aloud ...yes when in denial "if only" sounds like heaven coz it allows u to stay in d state of denial n lash out n bombard sum 1 with d blame of ur loss.......but does this mean she doesnt love samrat or she has killed their love n d old gunjan d way she claims......no not at all...n d day she realizes this, her pain is only going to double; not only was she suffering from d loss of her sister, she is also suffering from d loss of her love n d hurt she managed to bring to samrat in d due course......
she is using the cloak of denial to avoid facing two realities -----1. she has to wake up to d fact her sister is no more n much as she may hate it, samrat unfortunately was at d wheels that day, does this mean if sum1 else was there d accident cud have been avoided......no....thats d only realization she needs to wake up to.....death was her sister's destiny, blaming someone for her loss cannot bring back her sister, its only going to add onto her turmoils d day she ends her self imposed exile to the path of love.....she cud have healed more easily leveraging the strength of samrat's love had samrat not been d one driving d car but fate seems to be winning now since she seems to be succumbing to her internal pressure to withdraw from her biggest strength ie. her love which she is currently busy castigating as d reason for her pain........-----2. they say right when u lose the basic sanity u find some twisted pleasure in torturing yourself......unknowingly may be she thinks she is serving a penance by continuing to live in denial n denying herself the happiness she deserves or d forgiveness samrat is due to.......but she is so mistaken ......she is continuing to hurt the memories of her beautiful loving sister by her acts......she needs to wake up n see wud nupur have been happy to see her like this, positions reversed will she be happy seeing nupur in her place like this.....no right???
in her love for her sister she is unknowingly judging samrat very harshly, but as the beautiful saying goes We can never judge the lives of others, because each person knows only their own pain and renunciation. It's one thing to feel that you are on the right path, but it's another to think that yours is the only path. If you judge people, you have no time to love them..The more one judges, the less one love......that shows that while hugging the path of denial n holding samrat responsible for a freak twisted game of fate, all she is doing is running away from d path of love......
only one question remains to be answered by all three of them.....for how long??????
sorry thoda zyada ho gayašš
@mallu cant agree more dear .... its such an insight into the reasons of her behavior... and so beautifully explained .... i too wish all those who are still blaming gunjan read or for that matter even who don't get a different perspective which further justifies her actions...
meens let that be the strangest one š¤£š¤£š¤£Originally posted by: meens1981
@aarthi.....thanks a ton sweetheart.š¤.....soul sistersš i totally agree wat with our stranger than strangest connectionsšššš¤£
@1gunjan7 , thanks a lot dearš¤
@yashi.....awww thanks sweety........š¤