Talibans not winning the hearts of people - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

52

Views

3.7k

Users

13

Likes

10

Frequent Posters

344471 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#41

Originally posted by: finicky2010

ok, Mr. adolescent😆😆, how old are you? I thought you were 13-14😕



Originally posted by: finicky2010

Oh, looks like your mom is here, I'll leave two of you alone, bye😛



Why does your posts sound so vaguely familiar?
Enycedoll thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#42

Originally posted by: Summer3

You are welcome and if anyone is living close to them it would be a living hell I think.
There is a lot of drug trading going on. \
See how USA used to fund them previously and also Osama was involved.

The Taliban initially enjoyed enormous good will from Afghans weary of the corruption, brutality, and the incessant fighting of Mujahideen warlords. Two contrasting narratives explain the beginnings of the Taliban. One is that the rape and murder of boys and girls from a family traveling to Kandahar or a similar outrage by Mujahideen bandits sparked Mullah Omar and his students to vow to rid Afghanistan of these criminals. The other is that the Pakistan-based truck shipping mafia known as the "Afghanistan Transit Trade" and their allies in the Pakistan government, trained, armed, and financed the Taliban to clear the southern road across Afghanistan to the Central Asian Republics of extortionate bandit gangs.

Although there is no evidence that the CIA directly supported the Taliban or Al-Qaeda, some basis for military support of the Taliban was provided when, in the early 1980s, the CIA and the ISI (Pakistan's Inter-Services Intelligence agency) provided arms to Afghans resisting the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan, and the ISI assisted the process of gathering radical Muslims from around the world to fight against the Soviets. Osama Bin Laden was one of the key players in organizing training camps for the foreign Muslim volunteers. The U.S. poured funds and arms into Afghanistan, and "by 1987, 65,000 tons of U.S.-made weapons and ammunition a year were entering the war." FBI translator Sibel Edmonds, who has been fired from the agency for disclosing sensitive information, has claimed the United States was on intimate terms with Taliban and Al-Qaeda, using them to further certain goals in Central Asia.[citation needed] The Taliban were based in the Helmand, Kandahar, and Uruzgan region which is overwhelmingly Pashtun territory and predominantly Durranis. The New York Times reported that the Reagan administration delivered several hundred Stingers to Afghan resistance groups, including the Taliban.

i would like to believe that it is common knowledge for everyone to know that the taliban are a product of the US. for years they were supplied with amunition to fight the soviets by the US. so i mean, nothings really a suprise at this point. and i wouldnt believe a fart that comes out of the US
Edited by Enycedoll - 15 years ago
chal_phek_mat thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#43
Since this is turning out to be a chiming session, let me be the devils advocate😉
Why would Taliban win anyone's heart.
1. If one were to be an ardent supporter of the harshest form of Sharia. then what the Taliban implements is a welcome change from the wasteful life of the West. If you look the world over the number of countries turning towards this is more than the countries moving away from the right wing. Like Somalia, Yemen, Pakistan, Iraq are moving in favor of this form of law
2. Opium production prior to taliban from Afghanistan was 70+%, under Taliban fell to under 10%, after Taliban is out of power it is back up to 76% of the world production. If you are a big time drug smuggling and drug consumption supplier you would hate the Taliban.
3.Everyone across the world complains they have leaders who do not practice what they preach, You can never say that about Taliban. So if you are not a hypocrite Taliban should be winning your hearts😉
Edited by chal_phek_mat - 15 years ago
Summer3 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: Enycedoll

i would like to believe that it is common knowledge for everyone to know that the taliban are a product of the US. for years they were supplied with amunition to fight the soviets by the US. so i mean, nothings really a suprise at this point. and i wouldnt believe a fart that comes out of the US

Yes the US are partly to blame for creating this monster.
They are also the ones to cause much suffering in Iraq after bombing it under the excuse of searching for weapons of mass destruction.\
US sending troops to Afghanistan will not help much as it is a local problem. I never believe in outside interventions to solve domestic problems.
Sherraz thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#45

Originally posted by: PhoeniXof_Hades





Why does your posts sound so vaguely familiar?

Coz its human nature to hold on to people they like and not let them go😉
Enycedoll thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#46

Originally posted by: Summer3

Yes the US are partly to blame for creating this monster.
They are also the ones to cause much suffering in Iraq after bombing it under the excuse of searching for weapons of mass destruction.\
US sending troops to Afghanistan will not help much as it is a local problem. I never believe in outside interventions to solve domestic problems.

yes and the US is facing much opposition because of the intervention. Afghanistan has a history of it, and anyone who does invade their space is met fiercly, so its nothing new. and plus, they've been in war for so many years, so many countries have tried their luck in afghan, no ones ever accomplished. its funny because these countries coming in have the best of everything, and the afghans? they barely have anything. you cant defeat someone who doesnt fear life.
Summer3 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#47
Looks like a lot of world attention is on Afghanistan now to resolve the Taliban problem.

Brown delivers warning to al-Qaeda

British Prime Minister Gordon Brown has said mid-2011 should be the deadline for "turning the tide" in the fight against insurgents in Afghanistan.

Speaking at a 70-nation London summit on the future of Afghanistan, he said the nations faced "a decisive time".

Before the talks began, President Hamid Karzai said Afghanistan could need foreign support for its security forces for up to 15 years.

He later announced plans to reintegrate some Taliban fighters into society.

The Taliban have ruled out talks until foreign forces leave Afghanistan.

Foreign ministers from around the world are expected to give renewed momentum to nation-building in Afghanistan during the one-day summit.

ANALYSIS
Martin Patience
Martin Patience, BBC Kabul correspondent
Talking with the Taliban is emerging as the big issue at the London conference. At first glance, it appears a simple idea - weaken the insurgency by luring away low and mid-level Taliban fighters.

This - it is argued - could be done by offering jobs and a general amnesty for the insurgents. But it will be difficult - if not impossible - to pull off.

Part of the problem is that international forces (and the Afghan government) are struggling to understand who they are fighting and what is actually fuelling the insurgency here.

And that raises the question: if you do not fully understand who you are fighting, can you hope to win them over?

"We must reach out to all our countrymen, especially our disenchanted brothers who are not part of al-Qaeda or other terrorist networks," Mr Karzai told the meeting.

Opening the conference, Mr Brown said it marked the "beginning of the transition process".

"By the middle of next year, we have to turn the tide in the fight against the insurgency," he said.

Pledging support for the expansion of the Afghan security forces, Mr Brown said: "We will agree today that the Afghan National Army will number 134,000 by October 2010, and 171,600 by October 2011.

"And similarly today we will commit to supporting a police reform plan, with Afghan national police numbers reaching 109,000 by October this year, and 134,000 by October 2011."

This would bring Afghan national security forces to 300,000, a presence far bigger than the coalition forces, Mr Brown said.

'Financially able'

The talks are being hosted by the UK, UN and the Afghan government.

In his address, Mr Karzai reiterated a long-standing call for King Abdullah of Saudi Arabia to "kindly play a role to guide peace and assist the process".

Karzai pledges to tackle corruption

Senior Taliban figures have good contacts with Saudi Arabia and have been engaged in a series of secret peace talks there over the years since they lost power in Afghanistan in 2001.

BBC international development correspondent David Lyon says that in calling for Saudi involvement in an Afghan loya jirga (tribal council) in the spring, the first major tribal meeting for eight years, Mr Karzai is signalling that there may be a wider peace deal involving more key Taliban figures.

Speaking to the BBC before the talks got under way, Mr Karzai said that five to 10 years would be enough time to train and equip the Afghan security forces.

But he added: "With regard to sustaining them until Afghanistan is financially able to provide for our forces, the time may be extended to 10 to 15 years."

Donor countries are expected to set up a fund to help lure Taliban members back into Afghan society.

An Afghan man

What will happen at the conference?
Pakistan urges Taliban role

But Mr Brown told the BBC any effort to reintegrate insurgents could work only if Afghanistan's own army and police were strong enough to take charge of security from international forces.

"The first thing is to strengthen the Afghan forces, and then to weaken the Taliban by dividing them," he said.

"You cannot have a situation where you are making advances to those people who are prepared to renounce violence and join the democratic process and say they will have nothing more to do with the activities they have been involved with in the past unless you have a strong Afghan army and police."

Mr Karzai has won general support for his reintegration plan, but Western nations are expected to ask for more details on the strategy at the summit.

The proposed fund would help reintegrate defecting foot soldiers with the promises of jobs, cash and protection.

Anti-corruption drive

Mr Karzai outlined a six-point plan to take his country forward, saying in his address he was deeply grateful for the international support his country had been given and Afghan people would not forget the sacrifices that had been made.

Karzai quizzed over warlords

He said good governance and fighting corruption would be the key focus of his action plan.

Corruption is seen by ordinary Afghans as one of the biggest problems in the country, surveys have found. It has also been a long-standing concern among Afghanistan's Western backers.

One of Mr Karzai's most significant proposals is the creation of an external watchdog composed of anti-corruption experts from around the world.

Hard fighting ahead

BBC diplomatic correspondent Jonathan Marcus says the timing of the London conference is critical.

According to most military analysts the Taliban is riding high, but the US surge in forces is under way and weeks and months of hard fighting lie ahead, our correspondent says.

More work will be done on bolstering Afghanistan's own security forces, as well as setting goals on development and governance and a renewed emphasis on setting Afghanistan's problems in a wider regional framework.

A follow-up conference will be held in Kabul in a few months.

Meanwhile, United Nations Secretary General Ban Ki-moon has named a long-serving UN diplomat, Staffan de Mistura, as his new representative in Afghanistan.

Mr De Mistura, who holds Swedish and Italian nationalities, will replace the outgoing head of the UN mission in Kabul, Kai Eide, when he steps down in March.

Mr Eide was accused by a colleague of being too close to President Karzai and his government, and of downplaying fraud during presidential elections last year. Mr Eide always denied the allegations

Edited by Summer3 - 15 years ago
Summer3 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#48
UN claims that some sections of the Talibans are tired of fighting and are willing to talk. Here are some comments:
By Lyse Doucet, BBC News

Whether or not the report of UN talks is true, it's clear that anyone who mediates in this process would want to keep it secret. Taliban leaders who reach out face great danger. They would need to know they would be protected. The reports speak of talks about talks, underlining how this process is still at a very early, very delicate stage.

A number of military and diplomatic sources in Afghanistan say they are hearing reports that some senior Taliban are tired of fighting, and would be interested in a political solution.

But in a situation where intelligence has often proved to be dangerously faulty, it's very hard to get the measure of what the Taliban is thinking and whether indeed this movement is divided and capable of being split from al-Qaeda and more hardline elements as Hamid Karzai and his allies want to believe.

Read More:
Edited by Summer3 - 15 years ago
-Believe- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#49

^Talks with poppy breed brains!!?Why?🤔

Summer3 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#50
Page last updated at 09:56 GMT, Saturday, 30 January 2010
E-mail this to a friend Printable version

Afghan Taliban deny peace talks with UN's Kai Eide

Taliban fighters display their weapons
The Taliban frequently says it has no interest in talking to the government
The Afghan Taliban have flatly denied reports that their representatives recently had talks with UN special envoy Kai Eide to discuss peace.

A statement by the Islamist group's ruling council described the reports as "futile and baseless rumours".

Mr Eide himself denied a report that talks were held in Dubai on 8 January and refused to comment on other dates.

In another development, an overnight Nato air strike reportedly killed four Afghan government soldiers near Kabul.

An Afghan spokesman in Wardak province said it was unclear what had happened while a US spokesman said only that international forces were investigating an "incident" in the province.

The Afghan spokesman said six soldiers had also been injured during the attack on a newly established army outpost which had, he added, been launched after foreign and Afghan forces exchanged fire on the ground.

'Machination against jihad'

On Thursday the Afghan president invited the Taliban to a peace council.

At a key Afghanistan summit in London, Hamid Karzai vowed to reach out to "disenchanted brothers".

The loya jirga assembly would bring together Afghan leaders, as well as members of civil society and clerical groups.

The one-day conference in London saw world leaders pledge $140m (87m) to win over low-level Taliban fighters.

Delegates also said that Afghan forces could take control of security in some provinces by the end of 2010 and that the process could be completed in five years.

Taliban spokesmen have repeatedly said they have no interest in talking to Mr Karzai's government. And there was a strong denial of any talks with the UN.

"The Leadership Council considers this mere futile and baseless rumours, being a machination against jihad and Mujahideen who are waging jihad against the invaders," a Taliban statement said.

Military and diplomatic sources in Afghanistan have said they are hearing reports that some senior Taliban are tired of fighting and want a political solution.

But the BBC's Lyse Doucet says that in a situation where intelligence has often proved to be dangerously faulty, it is very hard to get the measure of what the Taliban is thinking and whether indeed this movement is divided

Related Topics

Debate Mansion Thumbnail

Posted by: Nishnesh

22 days ago

Russian Plaine Crashes : 50 People On Board

Just 18 minutes ago, A Russian plane crashes near Amur District, 50 passenger Including 5 children's were on board -- reporting by Vishal Vivek...

Expand â–¼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".