Do judges give honest opinion?

Do judges give honest opinion?

I will start from Farha Khan.

In my opinion, Farha is honest. She always looks for performance and that is why she is here. Meenal is a best singer and deserves in top 3. She knows about sur, music and a versatile singer. As far as singing is concerned, she always gives 100%. But according to Farha, Meenal looks like, she is not enjoying singing. So in gala2, she was not happy with Meenal's performance and she gave her views and then Anu malik and Sonu Nigam got angree and started arguing. Actually if we see, Farha was not wrong. She is not biased because next time she was happy with Meenal. Her favorite was Sagar but when she didn't like his performance, she gave negative comment about his performance and he was out. So in my opinion, she is neutral.

Sonu nigam is neutral too and he always give honest opinion. He always says "In my opinion, Karynaya/Meenal/Amey should be next indion idle". His opinions are unbiased and his different opinion for every contestant helps in voting.

But Anu, He is annoying because most of the time he always has a share for each and every contestant specially for girls. He should give his opinion honestly and whatever i noticed he always try to please each contestant. And when he saw his favorite Amey/Meenal in bottom three then he was angry with Janta. He should try to give his opinion like how much he liked a contestant rather than pleasing every contestant with same kind of shares(poems). He should differentiate clearly each and every contestant's performance to help people in voting like Sonu Nigam do.

Tell me, what are your views?

thanks

I Think judges do have BIAS against certain contestants.

For instance, Amey doesnt really get the recognition he deserves!!! They always say something stupid.

Don't think they lie!!!Anu gives his honest opinion!(in my opinion!!!)Because of anu's comments half of the votes come for our contestants!!! 👏

Amey is the only contestant who's got good comments right from piano round till date. He's got standing ovation and some excellent reviews so far along with KARU.

All other contestants were at the receiving end. Anu Malik, I feel, is basically a very passionate person and that reflects in his shero shayari. I misunderstood him first but I guess he is very honest in his opinions. Most of the times he sees to it that the contestants are not demotivated and thus ends up giving good and not so good comments..especially when the contestants rec bad reviews from the other two judges.

Farha, I strongly feel is kinda based...though not all the time but yes she is.

Sonu is the most honest guy and sometimes feel he is rude but I guess being honest is more important. Look how it benefitted Karu. He was praised by one and all in the following gala only b'coz of those criticisms.

Criticism should always be constructive. It should be motivating rather than discouraging.

i liek sonuu!! hes always niice and honest n so cute! lol