Sonu Nigam vs Udit Narayan - Page 12

Originally posted by: raveena_d

How is this proof that Udit is better??
1) Usually, the main version of the song is often chosen for awards, not the sad version or seductive version (where akshay and shilpa are waltzing away)..the happy love song is obviously gonna be more well recognized.. athough if you try to find the song on limewire or bearshare or iMesh or any other music sharing program, you'll find Sonu's version & it's difficult to find the ones by Kumar Sanu and Udit
2) Sonu complimented Udit's voice.. anyone would do that. Udit compliments Sonu a lot too so it's mutual respect they have for each other..
3) The song he's singing live - anyone with minimal singing talent could sing that, no offense. And of course he's legend - no one's denying that.. only Sonu is more of a legend 😆
4) Like I said, they have mutual respect for each other.. I commented on this very article you mentioned and it's common knowledge that Subhash Jha (the author) has a grudge against Sonu so he writes BS about him... I doubt there's an ounce of truth in it.... even if there was, lots of singers auditioned to sing panchi nadiya from refugee (including Uditji) but Sonu was chosen so there are plenty of songs out there that ony Sonu is fit for. I bet if Udit and Sonu both wanted to sing dil deewana, tera jadoo chal gaya or bawri piya ki, Sonu would be chosen because of his range, vocal flexibility and emotion. There's a certain style to each of those songs that Udit wouldnt be able to imitate (especially not dil deewana from pardes) but Sonu can replicate Udit's singing style easily

Originally posted by: raveena_d

How is this proof that Udit is better??
exactly! lolz
1) Usually, the main version of the song is often chosen for awards, not the sad version or seductive version (where akshay and shilpa are waltzing away)..the happy love song is obviously gonna be more well recognized.. athough if you try to find the song on limewire or bearshare or iMesh or any other music sharing program, you'll find Sonu's version & it's difficult to find the ones by Kumar Sanu and Udit
yup!👏
2) Sonu complimented Udit's voice.. anyone would do that. Udit compliments Sonu a lot too so it's mutual respect they have for each other..
this was the funniest one lolz...Sonu says Udit is good so that "proves" he's better?😆 well, following that logic, Ashaji and Lataji have complimented Sonu's singing.😉
3) The song he's singing live - anyone with minimal singing talent could sing that, no offense. And of course he's legend - no one's denying that.. only Sonu is more of a legend 😆
haha nice one...totally agree!
4) Like I said, they have mutual respect for each other.. I commented on this very article you mentioned and it's common knowledge that Subhash Jha (the author) has a grudge against Sonu so he writes BS about him... I doubt there's an ounce of truth in it.... even if there was, lots of singers auditioned to sing panchi nadiya from refugee (including Uditji) but Sonu was chosen so there are plenty of songs out there that ony Sonu is fit for. I bet if Udit and Sonu both wanted to sing dil deewana, tera jadoo chal gaya or bawri piya ki, Sonu would be chosen because of his range, vocal flexibility and emotion. There's a certain style to each of those songs that Udit wouldnt be able to imitate (especially not dil deewana from pardes) but Sonu can replicate Udit's singing style easily
@ bold: 👏
@ underlined: exactly! and he has done that sooooo many times. And Udit himself has accepted that Sonu is able to mimic him well. Sonu can do what Udit can if he tries, (but then he doesn't need to because he has his own voice and style) but Udit can never do a lot of the songs that Sonu sings. He just does not have the same range and versatility.

Originally posted by: shehzaadi91