Was Saroj Khan Wrong?? - Page 2

Originally posted by: hawa_hawai

Wow you all missed the point. regardless of what you personally feel for the person, you can't ask the audience to vote for one.

Yes saroj khan shud not say about voting to a particular candidate...her job is to judge ..

what i felt was among the 3 finalists GK was better , may be this was reason SK went on GK side..

agree with your objection, i know she was not supposed to do so, i just don't like saroj khan, i did not expect her to do with karan i just hate her now😡

To me a judge should just judge and give advice on improving dance moves, not tell the audience to vote for this certain person because they like their dances, let the audience decide who they will vote for, its their money...😊

Originally posted by: Ms.S.K.

Re. 22.5.09 episode I think Saroj Kahn was wrong by saying "vote for Gauhar" while making comments on Gauhar's first dance. In my opinion the judges are there for judging and giving advise to the dancers BUT NOT to persuade the voters to who they should be voting for. Does this mean that the producers/channel have told the judges who is going to be the "fixed" winner as lets face it the judges chose Gauhar over Hard Kaur in the dance off despite HK's high scores on previous occassions but the judges just voted only on the basis of that dance off night only. After last night's episode, I now want Karan or Bhaichung to win despite Gauhar danced well to the "copied" choerography. I just got the feeling that all the dances were not Himanshu's originallity. What do you think?

You are right.. they are there to judges, not to do drama's..

but she didn't ask the audiences not to vote for the other two, so I don't think its such a big deal.

It might have been wrong if the judges didnt have reason to say so. The fact that there is only one strong dancer in the finals is pathetic, and the fact that people arent voting for her despite her abilities is even more pathetic. So I think it was fine that she said that.

Originally posted by: moonlit.gold

It might have been wrong if the judges didnt have reason to say so. The fact that there is only one strong dancer in the finals is pathetic, and the fact that people arent voting for her despite her abilities is even more pathetic. So I think it was fine that she said that.

And I completely disagree with the copied choreography unless you have proof of it. His dances are very original, and i doubt copied.

i sooo agree with you.
himanshu and gauhar never copied the choreography. people are just saying that because of the concept, in nach baliye also there was the same kisna concept, but that is a pretty common concept. many people has danced with the same concept to that very song. but the dance moves were not copied.
Just one strong dancer being on the finals is very pathetic. i wanted hard kaur, gauhar and shilpa or monica or parul to go to the finals. none of the guys were that good this time( no offence anyone!! this is just my point of view).

Mona Singh was right, if she was not Jessie at that time, she would not have won, or if PrACHI was not Bani, she would not have won either. who is hauhar, i never heard of her before this show. this show is about how popular you are not how good. this is not a specialist dance show. Gauhars attitude towards other participants as well as her trainer was pathetic. it will not help her in the future...who wants somebody with attitude as part of their team. the judges were ALWAYS biased towards her.