Why Karan does/doesnt deserve to win?

Page

Next Last

Rose

@Painted_Lady

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

Guys

I think this question is relevant as lots of people are dying to see karan win and lots of other people are dying not to see karan win..😆

So the question is Why Karan does/doesnt deserve to win a dancing show! Iam stressing the point that Iam not a Karan hater. Guys,please read the bold part. Please cite the reasons what make him does/doesnt deserve it. The winner of a dancing show should be called the best dancer. So the reasons should convince that fact!

According to me..Karan doesnt deserve to win. And the reasons are strictly mine. You can agree/disagree.

My reasons are:1)Considering the show till the last elimination Karan has been the lowest scorer.

2)Regarding the choreographer,Nicole's performances most of the times fall into the 'weak' category again comparing her with the choreographers who already left like Savio,Javed and Toby.

3)Karan's performances were always inconsistent and it doesnt offer any novelty or creativity

Edited by Mickee - 16 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

423259

Suspended

Posted: 16 years ago

Karan dont deserve to win, reasons :

1. Lowest scorer of Jhalak season 3

2. No as such amazing performances given by him

3. Lowest scorer for the maximum times

3. Judges dont see him in the list of top 3 finalists forget becoming the winner

isnt this enough😆

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Fatima

@Rhimjhimsawan

Sparkler

+ 5

Posted: 16 years ago

Ditto. I have absolutely nothing against the guy. No intentions of bashing him for no reason. I adore the guy. He is cute and funny, simply awesome.

With all honesty I can't think of a single reason why he should win the competition.

He has worked hard and he has improved::: Well I think Baichung has also worked really really hard, and his improvement is shocking. Karan got a 29 on the 2nd day and he got a 29 toward the end again. Very inconsistent. It wasn't as if mistakes happe sometimes. But throughout the whole competition they have been like Shilpa Shukla. Except shilpa did better.

He dances better than Baichung: Though it is strictly a matter of personal opinion, but even in that case Gauhar definitely dances better, no place for Karan.

Quote

MissSunshine

@MissSunshine

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: Mickee
Guys
I think this question is relevant as lots of people are dying to see karan win and lots of other people are dying not to see karan win..😆

So the question is Why Karan does/doesnt deserve to win a dancing show! Iam stressing the point that Iam not a Karan hater. Guys,please read the bold part. Please cite the reasons what make him does/doesnt deserve it. The winner of a dancing show should be called the best dancer. So the reasons should convince that fact!

According to me..Karan doesnt deserve to win. And the reasons are strictly mine. You can agree/disagree.

My reasons are:1)Considering the show till the last elimination Karan has been the lowest scorer.

2)Regarding the choreographer,Nicole's performances most of the times fall into the 'weak' category again comparing her with the choreographers who already left like Savio,Javed and Toby.

3)Karan's performances were always inconsistent and it doesnt offer any novelty or creativity

Hello! Where did the two 29s go?

Edited by MissSunshine - 16 years ago

Quote

423259

Suspended

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: MissSunshine

Hello! Where did the two 29s go?

the person is talking about the overall scores which is still the lowest and NOW will always remain the lowest. Didnt get a single 30 in whole of season 3

Quote

MissSunshine

@MissSunshine

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

LOL What's the point of allowing public votes if the judges' scores are what makes you decide who "deserves" to win?

Quote

Rose

@Painted_Lady

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: MissSunshine

Hello! Where did the two 29s go?

I appreciate your feeling..I told lowest scorer after calculating the total scores in the show till the last elimination..I didnt tell that he is the lowest scorer in all the episodes..Hope you got it..😊

Well,not neglecting the two 29's he got..He did get good scores for the wonderful performances..But that wonder was not consistent..I also mentioned that..

Its not a generalised view as I told earlier..Just a personal opinion..And thanks for disagreeing..thats the spirit...

Quote

MissSunshine

@MissSunshine

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: Mickee

I appreciate your feeling..I told lowest scorer after calculating the total scores in the show till the last elimination..I didnt tell that he is the lowest scorer in all the episodes..Hope you got it..😊

Well,not neglecting the two 29's he got..He did get good scores for the wonderful performances..But that wonder was not consistent..I also mentioned that..

Its not a generalised view as I told earlier..Just a personal opinion..And thanks for disagreeing..thats the spirit...

That's exactly my point! If "consistency" and the "fair" judges' scores *rolls eyes* are what matter the most, then why allow public voting?

Quote

Rose

@Painted_Lady

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: MissSunshine
LOL What's the point of allowing public votes if the judges' scores are what makes you decide who "deserves" to win?

Let me put it this way!

What is the point in having judges if the voting decides who 'deserves' to win?

Quote

423259

Suspended

Posted: 16 years ago

#10

Originally posted by: MissSunshine
LOL What's the point of allowing public votes if the judges' scores are what makes you decide who "deserves" to win?

Public voting is done just to know the scope of their money making buisness by calculating that how much sensible public is, if public is not sensible then there are chances of them continuing their buisness in future as well😆

Edited by preksha_forever - 16 years ago

Quote

1 2 3

Why Karan does/doesnt deserve to win?

Related Topics

Explore Topics