Why Karan does/doesnt deserve to win? - Page 2

Originally posted by: Mickee

Let me put it this way!

What is the point in having judges if the voting decides who 'deserves' to win?

Right! What I'm saying is that let them do their job and us ours! They have no right to question the janta's voting

Originally posted by: Mickee

Guys

I think this question is relevant as lots of people are dying to see karan win and lots of other people are dying not to see karan win..😆

So the question is Why Karan does/doesnt deserve to win a dancing show! Iam stressing the point that Iam not a Karan hater. Guys,please read the bold part. Please cite the reasons what make him does/doesnt deserve it. The winner of a dancing show should be called the best dancer. So the reasons should convince that fact!

According to me..Karan doesnt deserve to win. And the reasons are strictly mine. You can agree/disagree.

My reasons are:1)Considering the show till the last elimination Karan has been the lowest scorer.

2)Regarding the choreographer,Nicole's performances most of the times fall into the 'weak' category again comparing her with the choreographers who already left like Savio,Javed and Toby.

3)Karan's performances were always inconsistent and it doesnt offer any novelty or creativity

Great topic! ANd my reasons for why he DOESN'T deserve to win are the same as the ones you listed out😉

Originally posted by: MissSunshine

Right! What I'm saying is that let them do their job and us ours! They have no right to question the janta's voting

Originally posted by: Mickee

If you are in a fighting spree I cant help it..Did I question the public right to vote at any point in the topic?

Just asked all of you whats your opinion about Karan winning or not winning the show and also the reasons!!!!!!! I only commented on his performance and I have the rights to..I never insulted him as a person..

I just wanted to mention how I disapprove the judges' attitude towards the junta. I'm not in a fighting mood. Trust me.😊

He doesn't deserve to win... but I think he is better dancer than Baichung

he doesnt deserve to win..
if hard kaur was there
if gauhar has any chance of winning
seeing that both are impossibilities, he should win, since he is a better dancer than baichung.
STRICTLY speaking on their individual dancing capabilities minus their respective choreographers.

Karan according to me does not deserve to win if and only if he is beaten by any of the existing contestant. We know that both judges marks and votes are important, still my logic goes against his winning is

Originally posted by: kaushikbasu

Karan according to me does not deserve to win if and only if he is beaten by any of the existing contestant. We know that both judges marks and votes are important, still my logic goes against his winning is

1. He has the lowest average among the remaining.

2. I have to see his full potential as a dancer, though Bhaichung says that he himself is the worst dancer, that does not appear to be the case, maybe that is the fault of choreographer. Well those who says Karan is a better dancer they only see lip sync and expression difference, not the steps and body postures and movements, which i think Bhaichung did better.

3. He has arguably slipped to 2nd position last week in number of votes as well.

ohh I forgot to mention this reason, include this as well.

Originally posted by: kaushikbasu

Karan according to me does not deserve to win if and only if he is beaten by any of the existing contestant. We know that both judges marks and votes are important, still my logic goes against his winning is

1. He has the lowest average among the remaining.

2. I have to see his full potential as a dancer,though Bhaichung says that he himself is the worst dancer, that does not appear to be the case, maybe that is the fault of choreographer. Well those who says Karan is a better dancer they only see lip sync and expression difference, not the steps and body postures and movements, which i think Bhaichung did better.

3. He has arguably slipped to 2nd position last week in number of votes as well.

@the bold text - i feel he only says that because as a person he is humble, the k-fans just use it as an excuse to have another "logical" reason in their kitty as to why karan should win, 'cause omg even baichung says he's a worse dancer' *roll my eyes*

EDIT - oh and i didnt even answer the topic's question lol 😆

my opinion - alongside all the other reasons listed by everyone else, another reason he doesnt deserve to win is that he doesnt dance, nicole does all the dancing, while karan acts,lifts,supports and moves from one corner of the stage to the other, the idea of the show is to test the celebrity's dancing skills not the choreographer's...