Why Karan does/doesnt deserve to win?

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Rikz

@BlueSoul

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

#21

Originally posted by: Mickee
Guys
I think this question is relevant as lots of people are dying to see karan win and lots of other people are dying not to see karan win..😆

So the question is Why Karan does/doesnt deserve to win a dancing show! Iam stressing the point that Iam not a Karan hater. Guys,please read the bold part. Please cite the reasons what make him does/doesnt deserve it. The winner of a dancing show should be called the best dancer. So the reasons should convince that fact!

According to me..Karan doesnt deserve to win. And the reasons are strictly mine. You can agree/disagree.

My reasons are:1)Considering the show till the last elimination Karan has been the lowest scorer.

2)Regarding the choreographer,Nicole's performances most of the times fall into the 'weak' category again comparing her with the choreographers who already left like Savio,Javed and Toby.

3)Karan's performances were always inconsistent and it doesnt offer any novelty or creativity

Well the reasons you stated are actually correct.

Quote

Aleena

@Aleena12

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

#22

actually i think it is because of nicole cuz she is not that good geogrpher so whatcan karan do???

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

fizzles

@fizzles

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

#23

@Mickee: You have made some valid points and I agree with you.

For me, the main point is that when a competition gets to the final stages, contestants need to raise the level of their performance. Karan failed to do so in the semis, yet he did not even face the dance off. And judging by the spoilers, scores are nothing to write home about, this time either.

Therefore if a contestant falters at the crucial stage in a competiton, he/she should not be there. And this has happened with Karan. And another important factor is that he has not been consistent either. I would label him as a weak performer, for sure. So yeah, I don't think he should be in the final.

Quote

Rose

@Painted_Lady

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

#24

Originally posted by: fizzles
@Mickee: You have made some valid points and I agree with you.

For me, the main point is that when a competition gets to the final stages, contestants need to raise the level of their performance. Karan failed to do so in the semis, yet he did not even face the dance off. And judging by the spoilers, scores are nothing to write home about, this time either.

Therefore if a contestant falters at the crucial stage in a competiton, he/she should not be there. And this has happened with Karan. And another important factor is that he has not been consistent either. I would label him as a weak performer, for sure. So yeah, I don't think he should be in the final.

exactly fizzles..you and me share the same viewpoints here..hope people take it in the right spirit..they should understand that we dont have any personal enemity against karan...we are watching the show spending both money and energy..for that reason we have the rights to analyse the performances of the contestants..then why should it be called a reality show?a 'reality show' is not about simply voting with madness... we do try to connect with the contestants..sometimes we stand as the judges,sometimes as the choreographers and even sometimes as the contestants themselves..we watch the show from all angles..its easy to sit and watch the show dreaming ''oh he is so sexy..look at his smile..look at his chest''..its very easy..but if somebody tries to talk about the particular person's dance its a big problem!🤢