if you would have been at gahna's place?

aaayan thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#1
ok, cant ask this question from guys.. because we are not that sensitive as you girls are, specially when it's about gahana's emotions. Forget social responsibilities for a while.Keep yourself at gahana"s place and tell me honestly " how many of you would have fallen in love or would have had at least emotional attachment with a guy like niranjan ? Who is first of all is cute looking and of your age. soft spoken, knows what all women are facing in our society, you and niranjan are share the same passion that's music. Specially when u are married with a guy who is double of your age ?

I think its easy to talk about society and its rules which are always for men, given by men. In these circumstances, if you start liking a guy(i am referring niranjan again and again because of his character and gesture as of now) like niranjan, what's so bad about it? Its not important that it should end up on physical intimacy. Can't there be an emotional attachment? you want to believe what niranjan says because may be you think that" you and niranjan, both think exactly the same way. You want to blindly trust him.

( may be even niranjan ll start liking her,but because of his up bringing and responsibilities towards society and its values, he ll stop himself)Then it ll be Niranjan's responsibility to handle the situation in a very mature way and without taking advantage of her emotional weakness, help her to understand her family and husband better and save her married life and social values. Then niranjan and gahana ll become an example and would be able to give some message to the socity.[/B][FONT[SIZE=6][/SIZE][B]. I want ur comments girls?

Created

Last reply

Replies

8

Views

1.8k

Users

6

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

radheradhe thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#2
Hmm, I certainly hope the Gehna Niranjan track can show that friendship can exist between a man and woman, and women dont need to be locked up in their houses with no contact with men other than their husbands..
Niranjan may become a person who becomes Gehnas friend and mentor..
I only hope they dont get into a relationship, as that will give wrong message to people, even though I know this does happen in real life...
TheRager thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 16 years ago
#3
though i understand gehna's problem even i hope niranjan and gehna dont get into a romantic relationship. its not neccessary that a girl would get attracted to any boy her age. getting into a romantic involvement with niranjan would be too kkektaish.
london741 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#4
I would also agree...that gehna shouldnt fall in love with some body else... friendship is okay...but romentic relation??? i think its not necessary...
now she is already married and pregnant...she shouldnt fall for somebody else...also now bansanth takes good care of her...
saif is also almost bouble age than kareena...everbody still likes them...
then whats wrong in gehna and basanth....especially when they both started understanding each other..
aaayan thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#5
i am not surprised by wat u girls said, but unfortunatelly either people dont want to participate in this important topic or ok with whatever is happening in our villages. 👏 👏 👏
one thing is proven here, what ever is happening in our society by chance or forcefully is happily accepted specially by indian girls. what an example i was given as far as age difference is concerned 👏 👏 👏( saif & kareena) two mature people who are in a relation by CHOICE and they both have enough link ups and relation ships in between.
😆 😆 😆
How can you expect change in socity if indian females only wants such humiliations in life & ok with whatever happened with gahana, child marriage and all? Because Time is a healer. If a girl is socially raped this way. its o.k. Because everything will be fine after some time 👏 👏 👏 . Bravo.

👏 . I am speech less by such response. 😭 😭 😭
sonal75 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#6
My thought is gehna and niranjan will fall in love gradually. They have more connection. Basanth is only nice to her right now because she is pregnant. Where was the love and concern when doctor's told her to abort the baby. I see nothing wrong in the relationship between G and N. It shows that forced relationships can not last if mutual understanding is not there.
TheRager thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 16 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: aaayan

i am not surprised by wat u girls said, but unfortunatelly either people dont want to participate in this important topic or ok with whatever is happening in our villages. 👏 👏 👏
one thing is proven here, what ever is happening in our society by chance or forcefully is happily accepted specially by indian girls. what an example i was given as far as age difference is concerned 👏 👏 👏( saif & kareena) two mature people who are in a relation by CHOICE and they both have enough link ups and relation ships in between.
😆 😆 😆
How can you expect change in socity if indian females only wants such humiliations in life & ok with whatever happened with gahana, child marriage and all? Because Time is a healer. If a girl is socially raped this way. its o.k. Because everything will be fine after some time 👏 👏 👏 . Bravo.

👏 . I am speech less by such response. 😭 😭 😭

lol! and guys seem to swing b/w extremes. either they expect every woman to be a sati-savitri or a revolutionary. pray tell me what purpose will gehna eloping with naranjan serve except ensuring all women in the area (even sumitra) are locked up in their houses. i prefer a more subtle revolution where ppl's mindsets change. so what gehna was attempting unsuccessfully was more commendable. despite being an poor and uneducated girl from a remote village who is abused by her husband she ensured that he doesnt touch her against her will.
also i dont think gehna wud be happy to lead a life with basant IF she feels basant cherishes and respects her as person and his motives are not driven by the fact that she will give him an heir.
NiharikaMishra thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 16 years ago
#8
Even I agree to the fact that Basant and Gehna's relationship does have some scope
It would be totally wrong on her part if she falls for Niranjan

But yes they can definitely be friends
as Niranjan will understand her being of her age

but falling for Niranjan means complete sense of irresponsibility

She has a responsibility towards her child as well
though she might say that she is giving birth to the child only because she wants to repay her family's loan
but it is obvious that she feels for the child
and will never be able to stay without it

And coming to Basant,
he had reacted to the abortion situation only because he wanted his mother to be happy and yes he may be taking care of Gehna only because of the child

But now he is feeling for her too which was obvious from the fact that he did numerous things for her like
taking care of her meals,
taking her to a Doctor inspite of Dadisa's denial,
sleeping on the floor just for her comfort,
even arranging for her music lessons,
and above all supporting her in the quarrel between Dadisa and Gehna

And even Gehna is respecting Basant by taking care of his needs and convincing him to take the lunch box (which even Dadisa, Jamuna or Sumitra couldn't do)
This proves a strong relationship being bulit between then

Yes I know it is difficult to adjust with a husband double your age
but then, nobody leads one's life perfectly,
every one makes adjustments
and Gehna is no exception

If not here
she would have been married to some guy of her age whose family would have pestered her parents for dowry which would have been worse

Adjusting is the way of life and one cannot always take easier routes
I strongly think Gehna and Basant should resume their attempts to make their relationship a success....
london741 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#9
very well said nikkie....👏...i totally agree with you

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".