Bhagyashree and Toby Right or wrong?

Page

Next Last

Poll

Do u think Bhagyashree n Toby were right?

Tangled

@iTangled_25

Trailblazer

+ 4

Posted: 16 years ago

What do u guys think?....Vote and comment please.

I to one point agree they were right..
but i dont htink that nautanki thing which was said by Toby was right...
the Judges vaibhavi n saroj ji who have always been fair in all reality shows i found are a bit unfair here in JDJ>...i had great respect for both ...but now it is kind off deteriorating...

plz post ur views......

Thank You...

Love
Steffi

Quote

Frequent Posters

Tangled

@iTangled_25

Trailblazer

+ 4

Posted: 16 years ago

NO comments...? Only votes..not fair

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Chandni

@xChandnix

Inactive

+ 3

Posted: 16 years ago

I haven't seen this episode yet but to comment on Saroj + Vaibhavi's marks--well i have to agree with them in saying that the performances and their marks do not coincide! I don't get how exactly their marking this season..it doesn't make sense at times.

--will edit when seen 2night's epi =)

Quote

Tangled

@iTangled_25

Trailblazer

+ 4

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: xChandnix
I haven't seen this episode yet but to comment on Saroj + Vaibhavi's marks--well i have to agree with them in saying that the performances and their marks do not coincide! I don't get how exactly their marking this season..it doesn't make sense at times.

--will edit when seen 2night's epi =)

i agree with u ...their marks n comments dont blend at all...For karan....they could clearly re-monitor the performance....it was clearly possible...they cud zoom it n c if she could see thru the blindfold...n we karan n Ram dont the lipsing....oH my god....what hungama.....n wen baichung dusn do it....hum sab usse nazar andaaz....who realize how much he fumbled in that blindfold performance...😡 n he got 30....i wud agree on 25 now.....his pehli nazar performance deserved a 30 but...

n wen Monica gets 30..she totally deserves it...i agree...👏
judges dunno wt they want.....i tel u😡

Quote

Sonali

@-Sonali-

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

steff i think bhagyashree and toby r right b'coz i personally think tht judjes r not getting partically with all of them there r not fair at all

if karan will not sing itz bad n if baichung will not sing so ok same for ram also but can understand his feeling

even till now karan did not got prefect 30 at the most he got 29 even in his dance of u r my love they could have given him prefect 30 but no vaibhav did not gave him

i think their r not fair at all

NICE POST STEFF

Quote

Tangled

@iTangled_25

Trailblazer

+ 4

Posted: 16 years ago

Thanx Sona...i agree with u

Quote

nandini

@Riddikulus

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 16 years ago

Nice post Steff...!! 👍🏼

I agree with the inconsistency in the marking part...it's something I've been saying since the season began...it's like the judges have a different marking standard for each contestant...which isn't fair if you take a closer look...

they seem to judge Baichung, for instance, in accordance with what they expect him to do as a footballer, and the moment he surpasses that, 30 is what they hurl at him...why? the same old You're-A-Footballer-For-Heaven's-Sake-And-Football-Is-The-Opposite-Pole-Of-The-Spectrum-From-Dance argument, which i've always had issues with...no offense to Baichung fans...he's working really hard and the improvement is quite apparent...but the scores then end up affecting the ranking points of all the other contestants who may have got lower scores because they didn't lip-sync (KSG, Ram) or fumbled (Hard Kaur)...if they marked on one uniform level, i'd be fine with whatever scores they gave, really...

having said all that, i think the Nautanki bit did go a little too far...he could have put forward his point of view in a slightly less brash manner...

cheers! 😃

Edited by nandinidev - 16 years ago

Quote

Wrackspurt

@Wrackspurt

Trailblazer

+ 3

Posted: 16 years ago

Yes cause i am confused too as to how the judges are giving scores....bad performances get 30 and good performances get not more than 26 or 27 🤢

Quote

Tangled

@iTangled_25

Trailblazer

+ 4

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: nandinidev
I agree with the inconsistency in the marking part...it's something I've been saying since the season began...it's like the judges have a different marking standard for each contestant...which isn't fair if you take a closer look...they seem to judge Baichung in accordance with what they expect him to do as a footballer, and the moment he surpasses that, 30 is what they hurl at him...why? the same old You're-A-Footballer-For-Heaven's-Sake-And-Football-Is-The-Opposite-Pole-Of-The-Spectrum-From-Dance argument, which i've always had issues with...no offense to Baichung fans...he's working really hard and the improvement is quite apparent...but the scores then end up affecting the ranking points of all the other contestants who may have got lower scores because they didn't lip-sync (KSG, Ram) or fumbled (Hard Kaur)...if they marked on one uniform level, i'd be fine with whatever scores they gave, really...

having said all that, i think the Nautanki bit did go a little too far...he could have put forward his point of view in a slightly less brash manner...

cheers!

agree with u ...their marks n comments dont blend at all...For karan....they could clearly re-monitor the performance....it was clearly possible...they cud zoom it n c if she could see thru the blindfold...n we karan n Ram dont the lipsing....oH my god....what hungama.....n wen baichung dusn do it....hum sab usse nazar andaaz....who realize how much he fumbled in that blindfold performance...😡 n he got 30....i wud agree on 25 now.....his pehli nazar performance deserved a 30 but...

n wen Monica gets 30..she totally deserves it...i agree...👏
judges dunno wt they want.....i tel u😡