Bhagyashree and Toby Right or wrong? - Page 3

Originally posted by: HariOm

B& T danced so well and all they got was 24. Less than Ram, ARA?????
And what did Gauhar do to deserve a 30??
The judges are quite partial.

Originally posted by: ready2rock

Very very right!!! infact it's those silly judges who are sooo wrong they are so inconsistent with their scores right from day 1...they follow different set of rules for each one of them they themselves don't know what they are marking on??? 9 and 10 toh aise de rahe hain jaise kisi daawat mein aaye hein...bhagya and toby just showed them the mirror and they got scared after seeing themselves in it aur kuch nahi...😡😡😡 they are extremely biased and confused i toh have started hating all three of them especially that guldasta waali...😡 this season has very good concepts, good dancers, good celebrities, good performances but pathetic judges!!!😡😡😡

and last but not the least Steff_DMG u r doing a good job i like the way u r replying to every reply that has been posted...good job!!!👏👏👏

Originally posted by: sumanforums

Toby was right? How on earth did Ram get 9-9-9 and they got 8-8-8.....Rams dance was really bad yesterday and deserved only a 7-7-7 or even 8 would do. Why did bagyashree get only 888.

That is why they said they did not understand what the judges wanted . when they said about breathlessness.....saroj said we did mention that to ram so why on earth did she give him 9.

He did not do the dance well.......he did not lipsync....he was breathless ...... just because he was laughing all through and managed to entertain (nautanki) .....he got 9. I agree with all the others marks ......they were fair to everyone...except Bhagyashree and Ram (they clearly exchanged their marks)

And of course Saroj Kan clearly showed her standard when she said "mein chipak ke bataooon kya"....she stooped quite low so that toby shuts his mouth. even vaibahvi was shocked at that statement.

Personally, I felt that Bhagyashree's dance, while the steps were finely executed, the dance itself lacked fire and passion. Especially since its a Salsa. I don't know if anyone noticed this, but Bhagyashree was looking downcast from before the beginning of the show itself. She was looking unhappy. But I do agree, she could have got more marks.

Originally posted by: suganthirani

Personally, I felt that Bhagyashree's dance, while the steps were finely executed, the dance itself lacked fire and passion. Especially since its a Salsa. I don't know if anyone noticed this, but Bhagyashree was looking downcast from before the beginning of the show itself. She was looking unhappy. But I do agree, she could have got more marks.

I liked Ram's dance, yes he was breathless, but he did dance with rhythmn and beat and that elastic band! I don't agree that he barely moved! It was only at the very end before the cartwheel that his steps looked not fully completed.

I think that the judges this seasonare judging contestants in relation to their previous performances and not in comparison to other contestants. That is why there is confusion regarding the marks, I think!

While I think that Toby and Bhagyashree had a right to question the judges, they should have done it in a more polite manner. I think that in Indian Reality Shows, the tone one uses with the judges matters as compared to Western Reality Shows.

One more thing is, even if Bhagyashree had got 27, I don't think the final outcome would be different. Surely, only Gauhar would have come in through the wildcard!

Somehow, this is my personal view, Bhagyashree does not have that X-Factor needed for a Reality Show of this kind.

Originally posted by: Kaj!

i dont usually comment in this forum but i would like to give my 2-cents here 😊

I agree with whatever Toby said yesterday. He has been a loyal jhalak dikhlaja choreographer since the first season and he is more familiar to what the original format of the show should be, more than the judges!

Jhalak dikhlaja is meant to be an Indian version of "dancing with the stars", a show where you do international dance forms such as salsa and ballroom dancing. However, in season three they have decided to concentrate on bollywood dancing. Ok, I thought it was fine for the first episode so that the contestants can open up and feel at ease doing something that is probably their fortay or close to home. But after several weeks nothing has seemed to changed. Only a selected few, such as Nicole and Savio incorporate fantastic lifts and movements (I will also mention Javed who tries novel ideas too). i won't doubt the other choreographers though as they are only doing what they have been told to do (this so called new format or whatever). But my point is that the international dance forms was what made the show different. What's the difference between this show and any other dance show now?

And even I agree with Toby and Hard Kaur for that matter, the comments and marks do not correlate what so ever. Going back to Saroj Khan's comment on Hard Kaur during the jugalbandi round (if I'm not mistaken) was that she was the best! Hence wouldn't you expect Hard Kaur to get the best, 10 points? Well I would expect that!

Cutting pointson minor issues such as lip sync, according to me is quite petty because your body language and facial expressions can do wonders to a performance that you do not need to lip sync all the time. But nevertheless, if they decide to cut points for that, it would be nice if the rule of lip syncing was meant for everyone and not one or two individuals.

Now going onto Bhagyashree's performance... firstly I would like to say that they both worked hard. It was apparent because when she left the show, she did a decent performance, but what she did on friday was above decent in my opinion. I would have liked Toby to have received at least one 10 for that leg tangle movement. It was novel and well executed. However the judges thought otherwise.

Also, it makes me sick to hear "you danced so well... even with all that weight". I adore Ram Kapoor, i really do, but these comments make me cringe. Why were the judges so surprised to see a "big" person dance? Haven't they ever seen the choreographer Ganesh Acharya dance? He is much bigger in size to Ram and he is a fantastic dancer. Are the judges indicating that only skinny people can dance? 👎🏼 If so, i definately disagree with their opinions.

I felt really bad that Toby was targetted in this manner. I know the three judges are established and experienced in their own field but Toby is no newcomer either. Just because he doesn't ave the exposer that they have gain doesn't make him amateur.

Also, why have they made the jhalak house into a big brother/big boss house? Why do they have cameras everywhere? Don't you think this is causing irrelevant controversies?? And judges should have expected such comments from the participants. Agar itna hi bura lag raha hai to cameras nikaaldo bhai! lol

Ahhh...i think i've said enough. 😆 I hope i have not offended anyone with my opinions. Nevertheless, I watch the show because I'm a hard core dance freak. Karan and Hard Kaur are my favourites, as well as Gauhar for the passion that she shows in her dance. Some may call it her interference but I call it enthusiasm .😆 Monica is someone who always surprises me, as well as Shilpa. As For Baichung, I think Sonia is a good choreographer and doing her best to get him to dance. He does perform well but there becomes a stage in the performancr where he stops for a few seconds then starts. That is quite distracting. As for Parul, no doubt that she can dance but sometimes i feel her expressions can enhance her performance and sometimes she looks quite fearful when she dances. Maybe she's not fully comfortable yet, but i hope she continues the good work.

Ok seriously, enough from me now. lol

Kaju