Sandeep Vs Panna

I thought there was no doubt that sandeep deserved a place in top 12. he has a very soothing voice which sounds like udit narayan....which is not a bad thing...a lot of pretty good singer started their career copying other singer's styles...to name a few abhijeet, Kumar sanu copied Kishore kumar and our own dear Sonu Nigam tried to sound like Mohd Rafi.
It seemed that judges blamed "sandeep AND panna"...was it just becuase he was given the results first with panna....?
There was no comparison betn panna , nakash and sandeep 's performance...panna being bad in singing and performance relied too much on his saif ali khan smile....while Nakash was off sur and arrogant.
I am afraid judges comments on sandeep will jeopardise that poor boys chances in further rounds.. 😭

i know....sandeep is so sweet and his voice is just as sweet..i hope he goes far!! 😃

Originally posted by: ms04

I thought there was no doubt that sandeep deserved a place in top 12. he has a very soothing voice which sounds like udit narayan....which is not a bad thing...a lot of pretty good singer started their career copying other singer's styles...to name a few abhijeet, Kumar sanu copied Kishore kumar and our own dear Sonu Nigam tried to sound like Mohd Rafi.
It seemed that judges blamed "sandeep AND panna"...was it just becuase he was given the results first with panna....?
There was no comparison betn panna , nakash and sandeep 's performance...panna being bad in singing and performance relied too much on his saif ali khan smile....while Nakash was off sur and arrogant.
I am afraid judges comments on sandeep will jeopardise that poor boys chances in further rounds.. 😭

so u think those who have already unique voice shouldnt win!!! even if they r more talented?? n Sandeep is not that technically sound like Amey or Karunya.... n both r orginal...... Amey too have smooth voice!! his voice is not that unique but do have his own style to stand out from other singers!!!!!! where Sandeep was clearly copying udit voice n style!!! neither he has a unique voice nor his own style! on top of it he is not that technically sound!

he doesnt deserve to b in top 3..... Anuj & Javed derserved the place of Panna and Sandeep bcoz both r orginal n technically sound!! Judges reaction is justified! but they 4got they r the ppl gave useless comments in the piano round n then they blemed janata for that! 🤢🤢

i m sorry if i hurt ur feelings.... but this the truth..

I thought sandeep sang quite well too! Pana is ok but sorry he just didn't appeal to me.Nothing against him.But felt real bad for Anju.He had talent and it was sad to see him go.

Originally posted by: thhikana

so u think those who have already unique voice shouldnt win!!! even if they r more talented?? n Sandeep is not that technically sound like Amey or Karunya.... n both r orginal...... Amey too have smooth voice!! his voice is not that unique but do have his own style to stand out from other singers!!!!!! where Sandeep was clearly copying udit voice n style!!! neither he has a unique voice nor his own style! on top of it he is not that technically sound!

he doesnt deserve to b in top 3..... Anuj & Javed derserved the place of Panna and Sandeep bcoz both r orginal n technically sound!! Judges reaction is justified! but they 4got they r the ppl gave useless comments in the piano round n then they blemed janata for that! 🤢🤢

i m sorry if i hurt ur feelings.... but this the truth..

Did you actually read the post????
I never said anything against amey and karunya....karunya is really good too....amey is ok, deserved a place in top 12, after that other performances wd decide...my arguement was that sandeep was a deserving candidate...and no doubt he came through.
I would disagree on javed's song....his voice is amazing, personally I love that kind of voices...nusrat fateh ali khan/kailash kher kinda....but singing umm not that great...if somebody has heard that song original by nusrat fateh ali khan...will agree with me.
Why people are angry with sandeep....while everybody is praising panna...and blaming sandeep. that was the point..

I heard all versions of Upar khuda!!! Javed was better than Sandeep.... thats for sure... but i never sed he sang better than orginal!!!!!!! after Nusrat i like Amit's n RS's version.....

I didnt agree with what u sed abt copying their Idols! if we have better options then y would we go for a copy cat??? nd i m not angry on Sandeep! its janata who shouldnt vote for him!

Karunya has a gr8 voice... but so far i dint see him putting his own style..... N Amey has better than average voice but he has his own style..... so i think overall amey is better... but its still early to say it......

hmmm me bhi yaihi kahoon ga
sandeep better tha

Originally posted by: thhikana

I didnt agree with what u sed abt copying their Idols! if we have better options then y would we go for a copy cat??? nd i m not angry on Sandeep! its janata who shouldnt vote for him!
.

Its not being a copy cat...do you really think sonu nigam is a copy cat or others I mentioned are copy cats...no but they started like that...they took inspiration from them....modeled them after their idol's style.....
If sonu nigam would have been a participant in some show...By your argument you would have gone for somebody original not sonu nigam....and boy what a mistake that would be...

this all is leaving sandeep and II etc aside...

Originally posted by: ms04

Its not being a copy cat...do you really think sonu nigam is a copy cat or others I mentioned are copy cats...no but they started like that...they took inspiration from them....modeled them after their idol's style.....
If sonu nigam would have been a participant in some show...By your argument you would have gone for somebody original not sonu nigam....and boy what a mistake that would be...

this all is leaving sandeep and II etc aside...

its not a bad thing to take inspiration from ur Idol... i m saying when there is contestants who has his own style then i will prefer the original singer... bcoz he is more talented n thats y he can think beyond copying his idol!

i m not a sonu fan.... i like some of his songs... but really not his fan.... i like ppl with unique voice.... like Fateh ali, Rahat Ali, Sukhvinder, Kailash, Adnan Sami, Shaan, of course Amit Sana etc....

one more thing.... when sonu, udit entered the industry it was a diff story.... now ppl expects so many things from a singer.... n also competition is 5 times more now! if public couldnt vote then Sandeep couldnt make this far.... bcoz he is an average singer

according to me Sandeep sang well... but there were ppl sang much better than him..... n u have every rite to oppose me.... its ur way of thinking 😊

sandeep was better than panna....i dun think panna deserved to be in top 12(this is only my view point)
karunya is the best in the present finlists...
secong cums amey and saagar..
third:monali
fourth....i dunno...
i liked sandeep for his all time SMILE! 😉