I am going to vent!!!

jpatel thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#1

Hey guys...well lately i have been seeing a lot of things within the twilight communitty and hearing podcast both HP and Twilight ones....reading reviews and both books and reading articles e.t.c

I just felt like letting myself go on what i have to say on everything i feel right now toward Twilight.....I am a big fan of the Twlight Series and also love Harry Potter (most people might not thav e known this)....Brace yourselves cuz im gunna be rnating about what i feel..... First i wanna talk about the whole Breaking Dawn contraversy......and Yes unfourtunately BD had not at all lived up to my expectations.....when i was reading New Moon i was thinking about how this story of Bella and Edward was gunna end...I was quite upset by the feeling i got.... but when i got to the last page of BD which said the end...i felt NOTHING! no excitment...no sadness...nothing...just " oh i finshed the book"... the boo was not that bad and plot was satisfactory but unforutunately Meyer really lacked some real major detail....i wish she had explained the new characters introduced a bit more.....and acttually shown a lil bit more or Bella and Edward "lovey" time after the transformation.. I understand that at that point Bella haad indeed became a mother but still for me this was not perfectted. I do like Renesme and the whole Jacob sceario as it make everythign nicer and more plesent... i really want to find more about Jacob and Nessie now and hope that Meyer develops this...however i did not like that whole 100 page bulid up for a fight that never happened...that was truly unnessary! The poor spelling, grammer and punctuation in the book was a total let down and distarcted me totally....how could so many mistakes could have been made... i only realised this when i re-read BD!!!
Now i'm gunna rant about the movie...i am damn excited about it and can't wait but i have my doubts....looking at trailers...i just feel that Kristen acting wasn't my idea of how Bella really is...i do like Kristen though... i feel Rob's gunna be a Fantastic edward and all the others are gunna be amazing....My only bad point i wanna make it the HUGMONGOUS high expectations for this movie...look at it....it's somewhat OTT in a way...really...what if it turns out not to be that good??? well we will see wont we
Thirdly....and this is pissing me off alot..people compareing between Meyer and JK Rowling....they are both different for pete's sakes can't you see that...they have different writing styles and different plots...different everythings!! and i like theri storys both...can't we just all live with the fact they are completely different and we should appraise them both for their own unique work????
Lastly i wanna say i have much much more to say abou all of thes ethings but i think y'all might get bored so im gunna stop there....these are just my opions....you guys may not feel like this so plz do not bash me...i just wanna get things off my chest and tell people my opioins!
Love
Radz😃😃
xxx
Edited by converse_chick - 17 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

2

Views

573

Users

3

Frequent Posters

Ambrosia thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 17 years ago
#2

When I read about the disappointments that people faced after reading Breaking dawn, i was actually tempted to read this book even more. I actually loved Breaking dawn as much as I loved the remaining 3 books of Stephenie. To tell you the truth i was happy about all the romantic moments that EB shared right from Twilight to New Moon to Eclipse. Every single moment between EB was so beautiful, even the touch of Edward that sent shivers down bella's spine was no less than one passionate love making scene.

After they had a baby, I felt Stephenie did the right thing by not showing more EB moments rather she showed how bella embraced her little vampire family, how she acted as the shield when she was a feeble character in the initial days. She was shown as one responsible daughter-in-law, one protective mother and supportive partner. This looked more realistic to me.I wasn't craving for more, rather i was happy that finally the Cullen family is complete, and they lived happily ever after.
But yes the disappointments will always be there that instead of that entire fight fiasco they could have shown more interactions between Edward and his daughter, or the trio together in their very own dream land. Or even scenes between renesme and the remaining members of the family would have been a treat. I always wanted bella to spend atleast one day in her little cozy bedroom at Chef swan's with edward, recalling their early days when edward used to peep into her room and watch her sleep and talk.
neverthless the book is beautiful in its own ways. i loved it thoroughly. Like you said the comparisons between Rowling and meyer is baseless, I hope people just stop comparing the two writers and enjoy the movie twilight... we are just weeks away from THE DAY.
Leenasmg thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#3
OMG! Ananyaa..u kindaa jus like stole all the words from my mouth! LOOOOL!
I wasn't disappointed with BD either..i totally loved it!
And i also think that she was right to have no more EB scenes after Renesmee and she concentrated on Bella being part of the Cullen family! However i thought after the fight there could have been more EB scenes! lol!
And wowie Ananyaa! That would have actually been really kool if she did include stuff like that! Hehe!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".