Why wasn't Amrish Bansi Selected?

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Ritesh

@hardyrules

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

#11

Originally posted by: bhaskar21

Another thing which surprised me was that only 11 people were selected from Delhi...
Did all the judges have a bad mood or what?
Not only Delhi, only 1 person was chosen from Punjab.
I cannot believe that a city like Delhi in which atleast 40 people are usually selected, only 11 were selected... Even in London had more people were selected (in II3) than Delhi and all the people abroad sound like sh*t.

I think the judges just didn't have the mood to give the yellow cards...

You know why I hate Indian Idol ...is this one reason...all judges couldn't see the talent in tha guy...man...that was so surprising...i felt all judges kept their ears closed....
I just felt for that guy...that he has done supremely for that day by any other singer......
These judges don't want real talent...they just want good faces...glamour in the show...they are not selecting singers...they want hero heroines for the movie....they just want TRPs...and nothing else...i just hate it ..i just hate it...

Quote

kuhu.kuhu

@kuhu.kuhu

Sparkler

Posted: 17 years ago

#12

keeping all regional biases aside .....sp when I don't know how many of them really sing well/bad ...they just showed few performances ..and the bad ones from both the cities were plain bad and good ones were good enough to make the 1st cut .....

Having said that I agree that Amrish Bansi's rejection caught me by surprise ..I was feeling it was unjust not to select him at least for the 1st round .....

I have a question ...The girl Parleen brought in with him is very besuri ...Did Parleen select her ???😕..Because I saw Parleen travelling to Punjab and he had all those tickets to Delhi auditions with him...at the end of his journey he said that he selected 11 contestants from Punjab and later we saw that only one got selected....

My question is .....Were these contestants went to several places and selected the 20, 30 , 40 ...whatever singers and then brought them to the auditions in front of the judges?????...If that's the case ....then that's scary ....no offence to Parleen fans who find his singing flawless !!!!( although I think he is very cute and hot😛 usme koi shaq nahi)...

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

kashish

@IamKashish

Voyager

Posted: 17 years ago

#13

I also liked his singing so much and wanted him to come back atleast for next round. What if he is not good looking or if he has not a good personality but it can be done right ? I don't understand what actually they are looking for this season ...😔

Quote

Aphrodite

@Showbizz

Dazzler

Posted: 17 years ago

#14

I dont know if the topic is abt the guy who teaches music to small kids and sang sufi. sorry I dont know his name . But yeah he sang extremely well👏 and the judges are really biased 🤢🤢.They selected so many young girls who were just average and think hundred times when they select someone from lower middle class ! The judges of American Idol have far better maturity -They always focus on giving the benifit of doubt so that they dont miss out on Talent. The judges of Indian Idol very biased and immature--Want the best in the first round of auditions and not only that they also want them to look the best the first day itself . 👎🏼

Quote

samhita29

@samhita29

Beginner

Posted: 17 years ago

#15

I agree to hardy rules. they should give him one more chance. Last year also there was a girl and had a makeover.They should look for the singing abilty of a personsince it is a singing competition.