Postivity lost? (To KP & SA Fans)

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Aphrodite

@Aphrodite

Navigator

Posted: 17 years ago

#11

agree with u mimi....we dont hate KA or RN.....we jus dont like the charecter kiran....sum ppl might hv said wrong things abt RN but most of us dont dislike her....we jus cant c any 1 else with ro accept ka

Quote

mimi0295

@mimi0295

Inactive

+ 4

Posted: 17 years ago

#12

Ahw Yams! I know what you mean by hurting. See I'm a DIE HARD KP fan as I am of SA! That's why I tend to ignore any post that degrades the people I care about.

KP is the only reason I'm watching the show. But this new track is way too oblivious for me. Both Karan and Shubhangi are AMAZING! Therefore when I read a post that is offendable to a fan, I report it. To be honest, it's the best thing we can do right now.

In no way am I saying ANYTHING negative to KP, because if there was a list of his craziest fans, I'd be there. Trust me. lol

-- Mimi

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Yams

@HobbitButt

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 17 years ago

#13

Originally posted by: robbii
@yummy...i think u r little bit confused about riddhi nayak and kiran..for u r kind information no body hates riddhi nayak..we all know that she is doing what she was told to do...we hate kiran's character...that too they way the creatives are portraing kiran's charecter is disgusting...on the top of that they are trying to compare with kasturi character...which was absolutely opposite to kiran's character.

same with raunak and anitha...no body hate jatin sha and anitha ( i dont know anitha's real name) .even with maasi...sudha chandran is an fantastic actor👏 no body ever can hate her...but people hate her character maasi.

yummy for your kind information people watch ekta's serial only for the sake of the lead actors.if they makes a mess with lead actors.....that too we are all waiting for RoKs union after the end of very lonnnng track of raunak-anitha...instead they suddenly brought kiran in between robbie and kasturi and trying to say kiran is kasturi.....then it is really difficult for the fans to adjust with them.what happen to kyun ki...people do not want to accepct other than smiriti even though the other lady was doing very well.after 10 months she brought back smirti..now since smiriti could not continue cuz of her excess work load ekta is going end the show.

i totally agree with @mimi..instead of showing this track...that is trying to put two opposite characters kasturi and kiran in one shoe..let them better show happy ending.😭

Robbii, I understand what you're trying to stay. But you should also understand that the reason why I created this topic is because a member earlier have made bad comments on Riddhi. I asked her to apologize later on, and she did. And this has been seen happen a couple of times, not directly but in directly!

Kyun ki, is completely different. That's been running for more than 5 years. If you're trying to say that KiRo is not going to work in this show, then you might have to check that again. Because the TRPs are at Top 5 since Kiran has entered. And I have seen people say "that's only because Shubhangi is in the show" sure, it might be but that doesn't mean that Kiran has no importance.

How exactly is Kiran's character shown disgusting? Has she done anything bad? Has she ever mentioned she loved Robbie and wanted him to leave Kasturi? She hasn't done anything wrong.

If you're talking about wrong, then wasn't Kasturi wrong also when she married Robbie to get revenge? Who was she to give justice to Raunak's murder? Then if she decided she wanted to do that then why was she falling for a strange man? (As she said Robbie was to her)

Since Kiran has also been dragged here, then now I'm not talking about just KP fans, I'm also talking about KiRo fans this time. What about them? With the comments made around the forum, doesn't look like a KiRo fan can ever comment on anything. If I was a KiRo fan, who am I suppose to go and talk to?

The best comment I'll ever get is "forget KiRo, RoKa is the best!", and something like that has been commented here before!

Check these topics:
https://india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=1006679
https://india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=1004783
https://india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=1005291

Every member is allowed to participate in everything, how is a KiRo fan suppose to react to that?

Check this one also:
https://india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=1005118

Here are some comments on Karan:
https://india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=999024

I was one of them but it started to hurt after a while when I actually thought I sorta like KiRo.

Sorry if I was harsh, but truth hurts.😳

Edited by yummys - 17 years ago

Quote

Yams

@HobbitButt

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 17 years ago

#14

Originally posted by: Roka Lover
Robbii well said! 👏 No one hates the real characters we hate the reel characters...and if they are portrayed that way and we are hating them...then that means they are doing a good job!

Anyway everyone has faults so if Karen or Shubanghi or Riddhi do something in real life...and they are celebrites they are bound to be talked abotu whether goood or bad....its part of their job!

Everyone here is entitled to what their opinion is reagrdless who's fan they are!

What happened to freedom of expression???

Everyone is entitled to their opinion dear. And the same goes for KP & KiRo fans. That's why I created this topic requesting those who chose that the only thing right is what they are saying.

If you don't know what I'm talking about then here's an example:
https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/kasturi/1009210/very-sad-movement

^This was PMed to me by someone that's not happy with the negative comments just like me.😳

Quote

kaswetta

@kaswetta

Explorer

Posted: 17 years ago

#15

well said robbii, we do not hate the actress playing kiran. we fell in love with
the show kasturi because of kp and sa's acting and their chemistry on screen.
if the track is what it is today ,its their behaviour ,they can't give a good perform
ance,they can't stand each other and i think, it's not just karan &shubs who don't
get along even some cast and you can just watch their body language. except
jatin shan. i want them to end the show for the sake of our brains.

Quote

shumshad parveen

@shumi.

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 17 years ago

#16

Originally posted by: yummys

Robbii, I understand what you're trying to stay. lol i dont think that u understand what i said.But you should also understand that the reason why I created this topic is because a member because of a member u made a big post on the forum which is open to all..?earlier have made bad comments on Riddhi. I asked her to apologize later on, and she did. And this has been seen happen a couple of times, not directly but in directly!

Kyun ki, is completely different. no it is not different...i was trying to say even after watching 10 months they canot accept other girl in place of smirti..That's been running for more than 5 years. If you're trying to say that KiRo is not going to work in this show, i never said that..please dont assume things on your own..then you might have to check that again. Because the TRPs are at Top 5 since Kiran has entered. And I have seen people say "that's only because Shubhangi is in the show" sure, it might be but that doesn't mean that Kiran has no importance. i never said kiran has no important.

How exactly is Kiran's character shown disgusting? yes up to RoKa fans it is disgusting..Has she done anything bad?not necessary to do directly.. Has she ever mentioned she loved Robbie and wanted him to leave Kasturi? dont u remember she was standing behind the door and singing kabhi alvida na kahana to robbie She hasn't done anything wrong.no need...she showed more interest and trying to spend more time with robbie than kasturi even though she was appointed to take care of kasturi.it is not necessary that she should do physically wrong...a single look is enough.i hope u know that there are lots of scenes where robbie convey the message just through his eyes without a single dialogue.

If you're talking about wrong, then wasn't Kasturi wrong also when she married Robbie to get revenge? Who was she to give justice to Raunak's murder? Then if she decided she wanted to do that then why was she falling for a strange man? (As she said Robbie was to her)yes kasturi was wrongi never said she was right at that time.

Since Kiran has also been dragged here, then now I'm not talking about just KP fans, I'm also talking about KiRo fans this time.lol if there are KiRo fans i wish they should make a KiRo fan club..so that i can also join in that.What about them? With the comments made around the forum, doesn't look like a KiRo fan can ever comment on anything. If I was a KiRo fan, who am I suppose to go and talk to?

The best comment I'll ever get is "forget KiRo, RoKa is the best!", and something like that has been commented here before!

Check these topics:
https://india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=1006679
https://india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=1004783...https://india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=1005291

Every member is allowed to participate in everything, how is a KiRo fan suppose to react to that?

Check this one also:
https://india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=1005118
about all these threads for u r kind information they say about kiran not riddhinayak..i dont find any thing wrong in those threads.neither the mods found mistakes in that.

Here are some comments on Karan:
https://india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=999024 this says about karan and SA not at all about riddhi

I was one of them but it started to hurt after a while when I actually thought I sorta like KiRo.

Sorry if I was harsh, u r not at all harsh lol.... truth hurts....i am happy u spoke the truth...

Quote

mimi0295

@mimi0295

Inactive

+ 4

Posted: 17 years ago

#17

Guys, could we please not argue?

Every single member on I-F has complete right to discuss their opinions. What Yams is trying to say is: A lot of members may like KiRo/Kiran/Ridhhi. Just like we find it offensive if someone comments on SA/Kasturi, Karan/Robbie, or even Jatin.

She's not badnaming anyone else, she's just defending all those people who have left- Yes LEFT our Kasturi family because they don't feel that homliness here anymore.

The best thing to do is if you do not agree with someone, better not say anything right? Because that leads to fights. And we don't want that. Let's leave it as it is.

--Mimi

Quote

JWMRK

@JWMRK

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 17 years ago

#18

@Yummys, 😊

Apologies in advance to anyone.😊 Pease understand..This is not against any reel/ real character/ actor member/ fan. This is just my perception based on what I see being telecasted everyday.

I am confused and therefore have the following input. Based on the serial I have watched so far.............up until now and as on date as I write..........Just how and when has Kiran turned disgusting/evil?

It is painful to see our favorite pair Robbie-Kasturi apart...I hav enever been any jodi's fan but I like seeing Robbie and Kasturi together......therefore I too am not happy with whats happening....but how can Kiran be disgusting ....??

Here are some examples

1. The person who got Kiran to Sabharwal house was Robbie, not Kiran.

2. The person who went up to Kiran on that rainy night and told her to come along was Robbiekins, not Kiran.

3. The person who; if he did (I dont think he did, but still😳), if she looked at him looked back at her when he sang the song in Kasturi's room was Robbie. So is Robbie disgusting?

4. The person who shouted at Kasturi, because as per Hindu religion (and am sure all Hindus will agree) Kasturi was wrong when she threw an aarti thali ......was Robbiekins, not Kiran.

5. The person who entered Kiran's room, without knocking (entering a girl's room without knocking is bad manners) was Robbie. Kiran did not call him. As for Kiran giving him looks, well at least to me she did not give him any inviting looks. In fact he looked confused at what he saw....So is Robbie disgusting?

6. The person who repeatedly kept on checking on Kiran when she was with Kasturi (popcorn scene) was Robbie, not Kiran. ....so is Robbie disgusting?

7. Kiran fell of the stairs, because of Kasturi. How is Kiran responsible?

8. Robbiekins tried to give first aid to Kiran. Kiran did not call him. Today the contempt Robbie is showing for employees. He could have done it that day itself.

9. Robbiekins himself went to Kiran's room to check on her again as to whether she was ok. He took his handkerchief and touched her. Kiran did not call him.....so if Robbie gave her first aid....he is not disgusting....but because she got first aid ...how does she become disgusting?

10. Devika got Kiran to Robbie's office, Kiran has not come there by herself....so shouldnt Devika be disgusting?

11. If a person saves you from being raped and then employs you, will you not have respect for that person. That is what Kiran is doing.....maybe she is disgusting....maybe every girl who gets saved and is grateful is disgusting.

12. My sweetiepie Robbiekins😳😳😳 is a good looking, charismatic, attractive, public figure. Aka a Rockstar😳😳😳. If we girls stare at him day in and day out, we expect a girl like Kiran to be not in awe of him.....if at all she is..........which I dont think so (coz the way the Creatives are going...she is either the vamp or the real Kasturi). ........That said I love Karan Patel😳😳😳.....and stare at my Karnoo when he is on the screen.....that makes me disgusting too!

13. On last Wednesday, Kiran ran after Robbie's car. Maybe she was aware of the transport strike. Maybe she only wanted to reach home. How does it make her disgusting. Wouldnt some of us would have done that. I would have. ..........maybe I too am disgusting.

14. Kiran was there outside Robbie's room when the Kabhi Alvida song was played. She did not sing it. It was in background score. Perhaps we should check the video. So by that logic isnt Robbie too disgusting. As he was clearly in Kiran's thoughts or Kasturi's thoughts or boths thoughts' when that song was played.

15. Kiran and Robbie fell off near the clothesline.......courtesy Kasturi. Kiran did not cut the ropes. She just laughed. It was Robbie who gave her the looks.....maybe he was confused.

16. Kiran fell near the clothes line......so she is disgusting.....By that logic anyone who trips and falls......is disgusting. I am super disgusting because I keep falling all the time. 😆😆😆...I fell of yesterday when I was fixing a tubelight in my house.....and my poor maid bore the brunt of my weight😆😆😆.😆😆..... And then so is Kasturi.....she fell in Robbie's arms left right and centre, even when she was not married to Robbie and was married to Raunak.

17. Kiran was in Robbie''s office writing on a piece of paper. I work and if I am in my boss's (male or female) cabin I will from time to time look at my boss; to check what they are doing. Am I cheap and disgusting. Maybe I am cheap. All employees are cheap then.

18. When they won the contract Robbie went to hug her. Kiran was patiently standing near a group of people. And even if Robbiekins did hug her ....whats the big deal.....An athelete wins a contract...they hug their co-workers. An actor who receives an award hugs his colleagues....I hug my staff if they have achieved some academic milestone..or on thier birthdays etc.....Am I cheap and disgusting?.......Maybe I am disgusting.

19. Kiran was in the car. Kasturi threw a tantrum and therefore Kiran had to sit on the front seat. There are many times I am sitting next to a male colleague, friend, cousin, uncle, brother. Am I disgusting...maybe I am, coz if I am sitting on the front seat, I either look ahead or through the left window (In right hand drive cars) or at the driver from time to time.........unless its a cabbie😆😆😆.

20. Near the temple, Robbie told Kiran I am getting the car, please come out. How is Kiran disgusting if she just follows his orders?......Can she control the rain? Robbie too got drenched in the rain. So by that logic he is also disgusting. I have forgotten my windcheaters or umbrellas at some point in time and have got drenched in the rain....maybe I am disgusting.

21. In the cottage scene, It was courtesy Robbie that Kiran was forced to change. What was she supposed to do? Freeze away to numbing death? Maybe she should have.

22. Robbie equally looked at Kiran when she was behind that curtain ....if thats what we are gonna call it.......so then why is Robbie not disgusting?

Edited

Some more....

23. The person who made Kiran call Robbie when he was in office was Kasturi because Kasturi could not sleep without hearing a lullaby. Kiran just called Robbie and gave the phone to Kasturi....In fact Kiran was clearly hesitant to call Robbie.

24. Kiran asked Robbie for tea and food......Is basic human manners wrong?......When a person rescuses us from personal harm and poverty we will have gratutude to that person. If a person employes me then on any on occasion I too will be very respectful to that person....So am I disgusting?

Maybe I can think of more examples.......but I guess the above is sufficient.

Anyways ......thats not the point....The point is simply this......A lot of people like watching Robbie-Kasturi. I do too and it is painful to see them separate. But...........But...........But..............Kiran, at least up until now has got nothing to do with it. Because if she is attracted ....if she is in the first place........to Robbie.......afterall he is my handsome, wow, charismatic Robbiekins😍...........then from the looks of it....he too is attracted to her.

JW😊

Edited by JWMRK - 17 years ago

Quote

Shruti

@shruti

Alumni

+ 9

Posted: 17 years ago

#19

Moderator's Note:
Everyone is free to express his/her views but there is a way of putting up everything. One should see that the lines aren't crossed. Please remember the serial is a fictional story & actors are merely professionals who are enacting their respective roles. If you do not like a character, criticize the character but NOT the actor. While criticizing remember to not post anything unsavoury that you wouldn't like hearing about yourself spoken by others. Any derogatory references/name callings against actors /characters/members is a strict NO.

When you are watching a show you get attached to it's characters/actors portraying the lead & can't see someone else stepping in their shoes but that doesn't gives right to make comments that would hurt others or offend anyone. There are members who might like Robbie-Kiran jodi but don't say anything on forum because of fear. Is it fair to them? The answer is NO.

Before this topic gets out of hand.

Topic Closed

Kasturi Dev Team

Edited by *Shruti* - 17 years ago

Quote

1 2

Postivity lost? (To KP & SA Fans) - Page 2

Related Topics

Explore Topics