Do you think Mahesh Bhatt is the right guy to judg

Ok half the time I don't understand what this guy says, he just talks in riddles. Like when he was talking to Gauri he said something about her smile hiding her sadness, but then he contradicted himself by saying that she doesn't ever smile.

But what I thought was the worst was when he compared Dimple to a horse and said that if a horse doesn't perform well it would get shot. I mean isn't that a bit too over the top.

Why is he judging the show anyway? He's a flop film maker not a choreographer

What do you guys think?

lol I agree totally! The guy isnt the right judge! I mean they are dancing: Judge their dancing not what they do with their faces! He's always giving harsh marks, I mean cut them some slack!

Totally agree mahesh bhatt makes vague comments...he is never to the point...always sorta beating around the bush😕

Sorry 4 sayin this.....
He had hurt Dimple alot.....
Dimple is 1 of ma fav....
So... i think Mahesh Bhaat is not a good judge.....................
He only knows 2 insult people.......
4 Gauri & Dimple same...
I hate the way he compared her & insulted her.....
The best judge in this show is surely Sameera Reddy..
A new judge should be introduced soon......
😆abt d way Gauri talked against his unfair decisions....

Originally posted by: KaranSB

Sorry 4 sayin this.....
He had hurt Dimple alot.....
Dimple is 1 of ma fav....
So... i think Mahesh Bhaat is not a good judge.....................
He only knows 2 insult people.......
4 Gauri & Dimple same...
Gauri is a arrogant person.... so it is bit ok 4 her...
But poor Dimple is so innocent....
I hate the way he compared her & insulted her.....
The best judge in this show is surely Sameera Reddy.. Next Ganesh & last of all Mahesh Bhaat......
A new judge should be introduced soon......

I'm really..... really... ....sorry......
I was upset with both d eliminations....................
Really sorry.....
I know Gauri is a very nice person......
I appolagize.....

nooo...cause some times he is so mean ....

Originally posted by: mimi0295

lol I agree totally! The guy isnt the right judge! I mean they are dancing: Judge their dancing not what they do with their faces! He's always giving harsh marks, I mean cut them some slack!

Not to be mean, but these telly stars are more known then he is.

Thankfully I don't watch the show anymore, I always felt his comments were rude towards Gauri, but now what you've mentioned in your post about Dimple- a horse getting shot if it doesn't perform well😲, that's just so insulting and OTT. Never heard such crude comments from a judge before.

i think he is not right person.....