Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 42 - Page 107

Trp was expected. This leap wasn't even needed at first place. Chalo laya bhi toh it should've made sense na? They are selling rebirth in the name of memory loss. First of all the promo itself was extremely repulsive, like here on one hand female lead is being sati savitri waiting for her husband with 3 kids and on the other hand the same husband found love again. How horrible is this? They should have focused more on Abhimanyu individually rather than making him a sleazy lover boy of a pyscho girl.

Mannat is still not in her form. The Mannat we all knew was multitasker, she never made her entire existence around one person, let alone a man. They could have shown her taking care of everything while searching for Vikrant but nope, they had to reduce herself to her husband only. She is literally surrounded with villians and unlike old Mannat who used to clock people's vibes well, this one is just nonchalant stay at home mom.

All in all, the show has lost its mojo, its difficult to bring that back unless they hyperfocus on it. This leap actually makes Indore leap look so so much better. It had balance from both side, it had freshness due to kids, they established Indore and Mumbai environments so so well. This leap just seems like a lazy work to increase the episode count. You can tell nobody was in favour of this because even Ayesha Adnan look like they have given up and just going with the script. Adnan toh looks under alot of pressure. Khair, this leap has potential to work if they actually cut down the negativity little bit, tone down the cringe from Punjab side and actually bring back the leads in their smartened up form.

Why couldn’t they have shown Mannat handling Mezbaani? And keeping it successful in Vikrant’s absence.

I agree. Mannat has not yet got her mojo back.

Abhi is beginning to think but they need to cut the physical proximity. It’s looking crass esp when he is not feeling a connect.
Today Sameagi tells him Manyata will go along and they have booked a room and he is fine with it.

They need to focus on the leads. our leads will rise up to the occasion and I’m sure TRP will be back
I skimmed though the episodes and DK has the most screen space. He has long conversations wit everyone.
even this week Dua’s school incident he has spoken with Mannat, Ronny, Mannat&Ronny, Dua! Every episode he has spoken with someone on the same thing !! Each scene is long. What do the writers expect? What does Mukta expect ? TRP with this kind of writing of scenes ?

Originally posted by: scarlett22

Why couldn’t they have shown Mannat handling Mezbaani? And keeping it successful in Vikrant’s absence.

I agree. Mannat has not yet got her mojo back.

Abhi is beginning to think but they need to cut the physical proximity. It’s looking crass esp when he is not feeling a connect.
Today Sameagi tells him Manyata will go along and they have booked a room and he is fine with it.

They need to focus on the leads. our leads will rise up to the occasion and I’m sure TRP will be back
I skimmed though the episodes and DK has the most screen space. He has long conversations wit everyone.
even this week Dua’s school incident he has spoken with Mannat, Ronny, Mannat&Ronny, Dua! Every episode he has spoken with someone on the same thing !! Each scene is long. What do the writers expect? What does Mukta expect ? TRP with this kind of writing of scenes ?

I thought they MIGHT have some plans regarding this mezbaani angle if they are showing its in losses and Mannat isn't aware of it, like they might show UV's bio dad joining them all through this as business investor or something but yeah, I was so expecting that they will show Mannat being head of Mezbaani managing it well in Vikrant's absence. They don't even show as a Chef anymore. How hard it is to show her as a working woman as well as a doting mom all while searching for her husband? This saint meera bai thing is so 90s.

I don't know how much ss DK needs now. Like we get it! He is the main villian, he is planning and plotting, we even get what exactly he wants then why should we have to sit through his every session? Also why Yashika is there? This is where Mannat's side falls flat on the face. She knew Yashika is rich, she had parents, she was Vikrant's friend only, then why is she there acting as a family member? Why does she wanna work in Mezbaani? Their doom started from Yashvik only. For mahasangam they stretched yashvik marriage because they needed some occassion to bring two shows under one roof, thats why they went till mandap and after that they didnt give closure to that angle, straightup jumped to Dua's truth. Then eventually got half baked reunion like hello? Didnt we all witness this crappy angle for MONTHS? Why are everyone is acting like nothing happened? How easy it was to just expose Yashika as a gold digger and send her to jail? Why is she being DK's assistant which even Malla can be?

Don't even get me started on the other side, I'm deligently skipping that side looking at how sleazy it is. I can't even watch Adnan's performance as Abhimanyu is always stuck with some sleazy character. I know this show isn't some masterpiece but atleast it had some class but this Rajvansh side looks so cheap and sleazy, can't even tolerate them and if they have plans to make Mannat enter into their house as some worker and get insulted everyday by these cheap people, then only god can help them all.

Same thoughts and it’s equal 3 villains on each side and that’s how Mukta balances the story where leads are only doing guest appearances… money spent on vamps not on leads… Mannat being modern day meera bai and Vik/Abhimanyu, a yes man to both the sisters. I thought they will add some rowdy side like typical punjabi unfiltered gabru and Mannat handling Mezbaani along side managing kids but after leap promo back to square one marriage troop that we already saw 2 times in last 3 months.. Writing team selective amnesia, he knows how to cook but doesn’t question himself on his choices… He’s ok with what is being told and they made memory loss to a personality change🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️along side added so many cringe scenes where he’s comfortable but next dialogue I don’t feel connected then why can’t you stop involving yourself either she initiate or he does but we never got such back to back Manvik scenes… I saw bits on gram and youtube and it looks really cringe as a show follower since beginning…On the other hand, Mannat is not even thinking how does Vish runaway from a jail and series of incidents, how come Y still in house, why she wants to get into their family business, none questioned malla who’s yuvi’s father, dk left his job??? But he was on some mission as per mannat ronnie and now heading mezbaani which is in losses.. most importantly dua, listening to Y not Mannat… itna bewakoofi kaun likhta hai, it’s not creative liberty.. they should have closed few chapters rather adding more to it…I don’t feel like talking about this unnecessary addition in the story, it looks way too cheap and that whole side is not adding any charm in the story…even director and writers visions are not in sync and that’s the worst as it goes overboard..

Abhi/Vik ke saath bahot bada issue mujhe ye laga (based on clips I saw) is he has settled very nicely in Punjab.

Memory loss doesnt make a person loose his core traits, he shouldnt blend in easily. Rather he should look like he is struggling to fit in.... his London upbringing should come up like it did in that Napolean scene today. But the rustic Abhi is not working at all....

It should look like Vik is hidden somewhere in Abhi... and that should happen irrespective of whether he is around psycho or any Punjab side character.

His complete transformation would make sense only if he is pretending the memory loss and hence has adopted a personality completely different from himself, how spies do.... but from what I know vo bhi nahi hai....

If he is pretending even the chipka chipki can be justified to some extent.

Mannat is no more the Mannat she is around Aish. Iska asli roop sirf Aish ke saamne hi aata hai... baki she becomes an abla naari.

Originally posted by: Daman17

Same thoughts and it’s equal 3 villains on each side and that’s how Mukta balances the story where leads are only doing guest appearances… money spent on vamps not on leads… Mannat being modern day meera bai and Vik/Abhimanyu, a yes man to both the sisters. I thought they will add some rowdy side like typical punjabi unfiltered gabru and Mannat handling Mezbaani along side managing kids but after leap promo back to square one marriage troop that we already saw 2 times in last 3 months.. Writing team selective amnesia, he knows how to cook but doesn’t question himself on his choices… He’s ok with what is being told and they made memory loss to a personality change🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️along side added so many cringe scenes where he’s comfortable but next dialogue I don’t feel connected then why can’t you stop involving yourself either she initiate or he does but we never got such back to back Manvik scenes… I saw bits on gram and youtube and it looks really cringe as a show follower since beginning…On the other hand, Mannat is not even thinking how does Vish runaway from a jail and series of incidents, how come Y still in house, why she wants to get into their family business, none questioned malla who’s yuvi’s father, dk left his job??? But he was on some mission as per mannat ronnie and now heading mezbaani which is in looses.. most importantly dua, listening to Y not Mannat… itna bewakoofi kaun likhta hai, it’s not creative liberty.. they should have closed few chapters rather adding more to it…I don’t feel like talking about this unnecessary addition in the story, it looks way too cheap and that whole side is not adding any charm in the story…even director and writers visions are not in sync and that’s the worst as it goes overboard..

Why these makers have made only motto in Vikrant's life is adding girls after girls in his life and not having closure with any of them? They could've made Abhimanyu some kind of brooding henchman and right hand man for that Samragyi whom she wants to be hitched to her obsessive sister but they made him willing participant in the cringe teenage romance. I know the show wasn't some highclass product but it had some standards but this Rajvansh side has to be the cheapest addition till date and we know this won't end here. Sooner or later this circus will shift to Saluja mansion to live under one roof and Vikrant Saluja's 4 wives will live with eachother. What a feminism! How hard it is to end Yashika's chapter who has added nothing in the story? Atleast Mannat will get some edge with her expose. Her getting exposed infront of Vikrant is of no use now that the guy has no memories.

I don't even have much hopes from Abhimanyu's side as he seems even more gullible and yes man than Vikrant ever was. Even if he gets his memories back, he will be manipulated unless Mannat herself does some solid work, so its better if they start to prop up Mannat atleast. Make her clock everyone around her, make her incharge rather than just doing "mera pati mera devta" "hamara amar prem" "soulmates" like she is some abla naari.

There is so much of feedback on Mukta’s posts. There are some bad comments but most are literally begging her to be more mindful for Mannat. How stubborn she has to be to just plough ahead

I saw she’s liking AT related comments. I feel according to Mukta Mannat has lived her powerful journey, now it’s Aarambhi's time. I find her quite egoistic who doesn’t want to take any feedbacks... like which producer kick off same concept with 3 different girls in a span of 2-3 months and with such low ratings what upcoming bts and updates are floating it’s same Mannat crying for Vik, he’s a yes man to both the sisters and dk overpowering continues…this shows Mannat is not her focus anymore.. We thought memory loss could be a game changer as it’s a nice concept but satyanash as always, for her Mannat show only vamps matters nothing else.

Originally posted by: Daman17

I saw she’s liking AT related comments. I feel according to Mukta Mannat has lived her powerful journey, now it’s Aarambhi's time. I find her quite egoistic who doesn’t want to take any feedbacks... like which producer kick off same concept with 3 different girls in a span of 2-3 months and with such low ratings what upcoming bts and updates are floating it’s same Mannat crying for Vik, he’s a yes man to both the sisters and dk overpowering continues…this shows Mannat is not her focus anymore.. We thought memory loss could be a game changer as it’s a nice concept but satyanash as always, for her Mannat show only vamps matters nothing else.

She doesn't care anymore. Somehow she will stretch till 500 & then call it a day.

Episode 499 u would finally see all villains exposed..

And episode 500 Manvik reunion that too a rushed one.

THE END...