Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 30 - Page 146

Originally posted by: Jyotsna09

Except Vik ,all are entitled to know the truth 🥲

On the pretext of saving him, they're hiding from him, which he should know rightfully...They're buying time for big dhamaka to explode 😜

M excited !!

I have been saying this since many days....

DK is Gagan 2.0. Good guy but temporarily fooled. DK is behaving and will behave the same way Gagan did in Anirudh track. Is on Mannats side morally but thinks she has misunderstood and getting influenced wrongly. He is doubtful but not asking right questions. It will take Dadi's arrival to him to start seeing the other side.

Did they edit some dialogues ... why did DK say to Mannat that she was rude to Vish? after jaago rasam? I dont recall Mannat being rude to Vish in previous episode or he heard anything.

Mannat is absolutely right in kitchen... this is what we had presumed for Vish in her intro scene (non glam avatar and before her truth was out for audience) when we all wondered why she showed no excitement to meeting Aman or even eager to meet him..... Mannat is also operating from her gut right now (like audience) rather than anything else. She doesnt have any proof against Vish... but she knows something is amiss... neither are the responsible parties helping matters by not revealing the entire truth to her.

I found it interesting that Vish repeatedly said Vikrant not Aman when she asks for property deal. Where is her attachment to Aman? or is it a sly hint to audience because Vikrant Saluja is the one with money.

Mannat DK eye contact in bedroom after Vish puts her deal was so communicative. Such talented actors they are

DK Vish discussion in bedroom is very interesting. DK even asks why didnt Vish talk about Aman and asked for money... Vish gives a faltu ka reason about using money power.... this is very odd (for us) and very stupid of DK... they are treating Vikrant like a toy here.... he is not 6 year old Aman anymore that Neetu can snatch him and take him away. Vikrant is a 30 year old man with his own mind and emotions... why is everyone treating him like a child???? Tell him the truth and let him decide.

No one is thinking of this except Mannat ... Especially DK and RoTu.

DK is not wrong in questioning Mannat about the share transfer but he wrong in equating Mannat and Vish because he does that AFTER questioning and listening to Vish about Aman. He himself has wondered why Vish is obsessed over money and not Aman yet falls for her hyperbolic logic. Mannat on the other hand clearly tells him why she made the surreptitious deal. (I know one account on X who is going to be very happy with this scene ).

There seem to be another cut when DK says RoTu putting false case on Vish and then immediate cut to Mannat asking about what? Dubbing is clearly different. What case? How does Mannat doesnt wonder about it and ask him details??? Definitely some editing here.

this is another point DK is missing in asking Vish... how will RoTu use money power to buy out Vik from them??? is he an object that they can purchase??? What happened to all those proofs DK was collecting? Does he think Vik is dumb to not consider them????

In the end, why is DK asking Mannat to tell the truth to Vik??? Why is it her responsibility?

This track is about Aman but Aman is missing... for once they could have shown Vikrant/Aman finding the truth rather than Mannat doing it for him. For a lack of better word... they should stop this princess treatment to Vikrant where he gets everything served on platter and Mannat does the legwork.

(In OG, Mannat was actively trying to get his memory back and he had started to recall stuff because of that)

He could have investigated after listening to Aish... but he is shown happily dancing and too non chalant about a truth that's supposedly going to destroy Salujas

Another day of asking the writers to please write better for Vikrant... Adnan can nail it ofcourse... but only if they give him that sort of content to deliver.

Originally posted by: Daman17

Mannat trp from 11-17 October is 1.3 episode, it includes Vik finding about vish, hall drama and manvik fight episode.

That’s great 😁

Originally posted by: Jyotsna09

Bold DK and VK came looking for their son/ brother though for different reasons , they have every right to tell the truth to Vik...Dk doesn't know the deal made years back by taking money, so he is searching for his brother for right reasons..He is undergoing mental trauma and agony to find his bro as he told to Mannat..If VK is good and right in her perspective, there is no other reason to evade the truth to Vik..DK 's response is 100 % correct that Salujas are the same like ARS who are murderers and bought justice and their son by money in an illegal way ...

What do they want though? DK and VK. Do they want justice so that the Salujas can be punished for earlier crimes? It's hard to understand what they want once you factor in the property demands.

Are the Salujas murderers though? There was no intent to kill on Neetu's part. RoTu were at the Kumar's mercy and if one of their family members decided to request for money in order to squash the crime at that time why do they seem to be repeating the trend again and requesting for property now in order to delay telling Vikrant the truth.

Originally posted by: Bettyscar

What do they want though? DK and VK. Do they want justice so that the Salujas can be punished for earlier crimes? It's hard to understand what they want once you factor in the property demands.

Are the Salujas murderers though? There was no intent to kill on Neetu's part. . RoTu were at the Kumar's mercy and if one of their family members decided to request for money in order to squash the crime at that time why do they seem to be repeating the trend again and requesting for property now in order to delay telling Vikrant the truth..

DK wants his brother back, not any legal battle against Salujas..He is clear in that, he told his mother also very clearly and he doesn't have any idea of the previous deal..

Mannat requested him some time, to prepare Vik mentally..His goodness made him agree to her request..She is not trying to tell Vik in any way till now, taking her own time to protect bacha chor couple ...

Pink If there was no intent also, an accident was an accident, Neetu was responsible for it,She ran away from the accident spot with Aman without taking accountability of the accident...

DK's actions were based on a combination of two things: his direct, personal observations at the accident spot and information received from his mother...Now also he is influenced by his mother's theory of property...

Purple: that request for property was made by his mother ,who was after property ..DK 's weakness is succumbing to his mother's manipulations ,believing her..

All these confusions are due to Mannat's interference in the matter..She should have left to RoTu to deal with the matter directly with DK and VK instead of stepping into the matter and requesting DK for time to reveal..

She should have allowed DK to reveal the truth. She has done to protect him & his feelings with good intention to prepare him for the impending calamity..

At anytime the truth has to be revealed and it will come out eventually..What is the point of delaying it and preparing him.These unshared secrets create confusion and doubt..

Unnecessary misunderstandings crop up between them due to her holding back the truth

At anytime Vik has the same heartbreak 💔,It doesn't do anything good for him in any possible way..

Originally posted by: Moor278

I have been saying this since many days....

DK is Gagan 2.0. Good guy but temporarily fooled. DK is behaving and will behave the same way Gagan did in Anirudh track. Is on Mannats side morally but thinks she has misunderstood and getting influenced wrongly. He is doubtful but not asking right questions. It will take Dadi's arrival to him to start seeing the other side.

Did they edit some dialogues ... why did DK say to Mannat that she was rude to Vish? after jaago rasam? I dont recall Mannat being rude to Vish in previous episode or he heard anything.

Mannat is absolutely right in kitchen... this is what we had presumed for Vish in her intro scene (non glam avatar and before her truth was out for audience) when we all wondered why she showed no excitement to meeting Aman or even eager to meet him..... Mannat is also operating from her gut right now (like audience) rather than anything else. She doesnt have any proof against Vish... but she knows something is amiss... neither are the responsible parties helping matters by not revealing the entire truth to her.

I found it interesting that Vish repeatedly said Vikrant not Aman when she asks for property deal. Where is her attachment to Aman? or is it a sly hint to audience because Vikrant Saluja is the one with money.

Mannat DK eye contact in bedroom after Vish puts her deal was so communicative. Such talented actors they are

DK Vish discussion in bedroom is very interesting. DK even asks why didnt Vish talk about Aman and asked for money... Vish gives a faltu ka reason about using money power.... this is very odd (for us) and very stupid of DK... they are treating Vikrant like a toy here.... he is not 6 year old Aman anymore that Neetu can snatch him and take him away. Vikrant is a 30 year old man with his own mind and emotions... why is everyone treating him like a child???? Tell him the truth and let him decide.

No one is thinking of this except Mannat ... Especially DK and RoTu.

DK is not wrong in questioning Mannat about the share transfer but he wrong in equating Mannat and Vish because he does that AFTER questioning and listening to Vish about Aman. He himself has wondered why Vish is obsessed over money and not Aman yet falls for her hyperbolic logic. Mannat on the other hand clearly tells him why she made the surreptitious deal. (I know one account on X who is going to be very happy with this scene ).

There seem to be another cut when DK says RoTu putting false case on Vish and then immediate cut to Mannat asking about what? Dubbing is clearly different. What case? How does Mannat doesnt wonder about it and ask him details??? Definitely some editing here.

this is another point DK is missing in asking Vish... how will RoTu use money power to buy out Vik from them??? is he an object that they can purchase??? What happened to all those proofs DK was collecting? Does he think Vik is dumb to not consider them????

In the end, why is DK asking Mannat to tell the truth to Vik??? Why is it her responsibility?

This track is about Aman but Aman is missing... for once they could have shown Vikrant/Aman finding the truth rather than Mannat doing it for him. For a lack of better word... they should stop this princess treatment to Vikrant where he gets everything served on platter and Mannat does the legwork.

(In OG, Mannat was actively trying to get his memory back and he had started to recall stuff because of that)

He could have investigated after listening to Aish... but he is shown happily dancing and too non chalant about a truth that's supposedly going to destroy Salujas

Another day of asking the writers to please write better for Vikrant... Adnan can nail it ofcourse... but only if they give him that sort of content to deliver.

Bold nailed it honestly nothing more to add.

Vish character IV on this police colony event. I guess actor playing got backlash so she is twisting the narrative and showing salujas in bad light and justifying her character. As per what is telecasted so far vish is cunning from beginning, sold her child for money and her husband passed away due to not getting treatment but in IV she says she planned all this with malla to make sure salujas suffered, few years back they made my life hell, my husband died coz of neetu and they showed me money power now I want that money power to make their life hell. I want my child back from them but whatever we have seen so far, never felt vish attachment towards Vik/aman. I mean you treated your child like a commodity and now holding others accountable. Actor playing negative or grey shades should know the character well before giving IV’s. Mona was fabulous both off and on screen.

Originally posted by: Bettyscar

What do they want though? DK and VK. Do they want justice so that the Salujas can be punished for earlier crimes? It's hard to understand what they want once you factor in the property demands.

Are the Salujas murderers though? There was no intent to kill on Neetu's part. RoTu were at the Kumar's mercy and if one of their family members decided to request for money in order to squash the crime at that time why do they seem to be repeating the trend again and requesting for property now in order to delay telling Vikrant the truth.

If justice is what they want they could have taken the proof and gone to the police for accident and child trafficking. Being a cop DK should know this better but again he seems to be emotionally harassed by Vish from childhood to question her on anything. DK is made into a replica of Vikrant when it comes to his mom🙂‍↔️

What would have made for a brilliant plot (atleast in my overconfident brain ) and Addy would have aced would be Vikrant doing his own investigation in parallel after the ARS phone call to not bother Mannat and finding out all the truth while the villains play ringa ringa with Mannat. If the makers wanted Vikrant to be the dark why did they have show that scene of him finding out ARS & Malla are conspiring 🤔

Based on the new BTS, Mannat needs to have a plan which shouldn't include RoTu and their sob story, nor hope to get help from DK. She needs to approach a doctor to see how the truth can be revealed , there is no point after this incident since Vish/🤢 will repeat this drama throughout the ceremonies. What is the point in hiding and trying to cushion the blow.