Saiyaara is a copy? Film journalist alleges YRF of bullying - Page 2

Originally posted by: JackSparrowcraz

https://x.com/Nixachar/status/1947314512794730601

Excellent at copying but I don’t know if they an original thought ever

I thought it’s copy of notebook

No, absolutely not a "copy" of The Notebook.

Honestly, I'm tired of all the statements about that this is a remake of whatever film. Suri may have used an idea and probably also some scenes here and there, but that is n o t a remake.

Aamir's SZP was a remake, his LSC was a remake but only because there may be s o m e similarities doesn't make a movie a remake.

suddenly bollywood questions copy cats, knowing that 99% of product coming from bollywood is copy. they don't even spare their own, bollywood copies tollywood, tollywood copies kollywood, yada

i am glad they copied , at least it generated some much needed business for dead bollywood. i would rather see them copy and deliver rather than do cooperate BB

i mean this is the not the first time it is happening in BW. why are people acting so surpirsed?

Originally posted by: snatch

wasn't ajay devgan kajol starrer u me aur hum too an unofficial remake of a moment to remember ?

Originally posted by: Maroonporsche

Excellent at copying but I don’t know if they an original thought ever

Originally posted by: SriRani

I thought it’s copy of notebook

Originally posted by: Clochette

No, absolutely not a "copy" of The Notebook.

Honestly, I'm tired of all the statements about that this is a remake of whatever film. Suri may have used an idea and probably also some scenes here and there, but that is n o t a remake.

Aamir's SZP was a remake, his LSC was a remake but only because there may be s o m e similarities doesn't make a movie a remake.

Aamir has done remakes. A remake is a remake.

What are you yapping?

I guess, you don't have an idea what copying means...that would be - contentwise - the same movie (almost frame-for-frame) only with other costumes and settings and language...

I may agree with 'copying' an idea (although I prefer the word using) or copying a scene, but in no way does Saiyaara "copy" the content of one of the movies named here. Therefore it is n o t "a copy" of any of the mentioned movies.