After effects of Indian Force's actions on Pakistan# 7 - Page 95

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.4k

Views

42.7k

Users

33

Likes

1.7k

Frequent Posters

Reeva_Mohan thumbnail
3rd Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 5 months ago

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

Let's be practical.

The address or contact details of candidates aren't mentioned after the announcement of results, no one can practically find out the such details of all the qualified candidates to do this survey.

Aside what do you mean by "most of selected candidates had over general cut off"

Assuming there are 101 seats for the exam, then there would be 50 reseved seats and 51 open seats. Now if you say that most of the selected candidates from reserved category had over general cut off (meaning they got selected as general candidate)

So we already have 50 students here who are selected as reserved students, so if most of the students selected from that background had got a score above general cut off, then that needs to mean that at least 51 candidates who applied through reserved category got in as general (having scored more than general cut off)

Does that mean all the candidates selected are from from the background of reserved category? No one from supposedly upper caste got selected? If that's the case the anger of supposedly upper caste is justified.

as I said you really need to revisit that survey, this statement is completely impossible

Bold: They can, by interviewing the candidates.

Red: This is as per your calculation. However, the actual percentages of reservation are much lower compared to the UR seats, or were lower at the time the data was taken. I don't remember all the exact percentage calculations, naturally.

Reeva_Mohan thumbnail
3rd Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 5 months ago

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

The key word here is especial from poor areas, do you really think the children of a doctor or an IAS officer will not have access to good school/tutors? And what makes you think that a person from a supposedly upper class with little money will have an access to good school/ tutors? Any school or tutor will check for their fees/remuneration, not for the caste.


Yes they have been discriminated for years so this social upliftment is good. But don't you think that now it's the same family which continues to get reservations for generations? Whom do you think will get an SC seat? An SC candidate from a village with no access to good schools/tutors or an SC candidate whose parents are doctors and goes to best School and tutor?

This means that SC candidate from the poor areas you mentioned, still doesn't get an upliftment.

Shouldn't there be a rule that a family won't get reservation after having availed it for 3 generations? Or at least something like a creamy layer thing present for OBC(maybe make the threshold higher for SC/ST), so that even the unprivileged gets something.

Bold: Yes, that happens. But again, the percentage of the creamy layer is a small minority in the larger scheme of things.

Blue: Yes, this is something I agree with. The main thing is that, reservation was originally meant for the underprivileged and socially downtrodden, who are still the overwhelming majority of people that avail the benefits of reservations. Now, some elite families do enjoy these benefits despite having generational wealth, but they're in a small minority.

Yes, you can check family background of reserved candidates and stop reservation benefits if the people have generational wealth. But I don't think that'll impact the overall scenario much.

The vast majority of beneficiaries are still from the poor and rural areas.

Edited by Reeva_Mohan - 5 months ago
Reeva_Mohan thumbnail
3rd Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 5 months ago

Originally posted by: NathuPaapi

SC aa jayega rokne, as usual 😒

Somevody should make a rap song on safai abhiyaan.

NathuPaapi thumbnail
Republic Rhythms Aazadi Quest Volunteer Thumbnail Voice of India 2024 Participant Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 5 months ago
suhaaana thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 5 months ago

The root cause of all our problems in one sentence..started with its formation, killed many Hindus, patriots. Don't wanna say more.. ab filter nahi lgta muh par

suhaaana thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 5 months ago

Koi IMF ko bhejo yeh video.. batao pakistan ne chuna laga diya hai unhe

https://x.com/RohitInExile/status/1926139229341454432?t=Idc8D7ZCy0xg1xxi-eoQUg&s=19

SlatePencil thumbnail
IPL 2025 Participants Thumbnail IPL 2024 Match Winner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 5 months ago

Humaare desh mein paida hone par bacchon ko polio ki drops dete hain. Par lagta hai inke desh mein paida hone par bacchon ko drugs khilaate hain. Tab jaakar aise durlabh praanis tayyar hote hain

suhaaana thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 5 months ago

Originally posted by: SlatePencil

Humaare desh mein paida hone par bacchon ko polio ki drops dete hain. Par lagta hai inke desh mein paida hone par bacchon ko drugs khilaate hain. Tab jaakar aise durlabh praanis tayyar hote hain

Yeh ek pakistani actress hai ise koi kitna serious lega bhala.

InsaneDivine thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 5 months ago


Kitna gardan matka matka ke news suna rahi hai... Is she trying to turn on the audience ?? 25 crore ki abaadi aur ek bada fertile land leke bhi 40th no. ki economy hain duniya mein aur itna ithlate sharmate bata rahe hain jaise outer space fatah kar liya ho... smiley15

Related Topics

Current Affairs thumbnail

Posted by: mnx12 · 5 months ago

Discussions of whatever happened in past few days between India Pakistan. Past thread: An analysis of Indian Force's actions against Pakistan#5/...

Expand â–¼
Current Affairs thumbnail

Posted by: mnx12 · 5 months ago

An analysis of whatever happened in past few days between India Pakistan. Past thread: India Pakistan After Ceasefire Discussion- Thread 4 DT...

Expand â–¼
Current Affairs thumbnail

Posted by: Sutapasima · 6 months ago

The resolution moved in the J K assembly during a special session on the Pahalgam attack described the incident as barbaric, inhumane and...

Expand â–¼
Current Affairs thumbnail

Posted by: Nishnesh · 5 months ago

Ceasefire collapse in 4 hrs as Napak paki strike on Rajasthan cities indian army Respond More on this on Republic tv live 2.3 Abaj dollar Loan...

Expand â–¼
Current Affairs thumbnail

Posted by: Leprechaun · 5 months ago

Pakistan violated the ceasefire within a few hours of announcing it Past thread: India-Pakistan Conflict (Thread 3) DT Note: This thread is...

Expand â–¼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".