Government announces CAA in India - Page 2

Immigration systems and policies vary from country to country, and the pathways to citizenship in India differ from those in the United States or Canada. Each country has its own set of eligibility criteria, procedures, and requirements for individuals seeking citizenship or residency. There is no gold standard here; neither does India have an obligation to follow in the footsteps of western nations. Asylum seekers may not have a precedence over other immigrants when it comes to naturalization eligibility but they do have priority access to certain humanitarian-based immigration programs, such as refugee resettlement or asylum protection in US. Discrimination? Not exactly! Just a policy based on “values“.

That said, I don’t see a reason why * anyone’s * path to citizenship should be expedited. Sure, without citizenship, they can’t vote, or hold public office, or have certain privileges that citizens do, but so what? Asylees are now in the country of their choice, not being persecuted and waiting in line to become citizens just like everyone else in the queue, right? What’s wrong with first come first served then?

Originally posted by: NotYourType

Good decision by the govt. it’s the last push before elections to get important things beyond the line and glad this time they did not balk to pressure or propoganda. 👏🏼 👏🏼

how is it good news? the law excludes muslims.

Originally posted by: akrishna111

how is it good news? the law excludes muslims.

https://twitter.com/ZZoariah/status/1767232631283081424?s=19

Originally posted by: NathuPaapi

Finally! 🙏

Bas ab pressure me wapas na lein.🙏

Hopefully, waise is government ka koi bharosa nhi hai

Originally posted by: K.Universe.

Immigration systems and policies vary from country to country, and the pathways to citizenship in India differ from those in the United States or Canada. Each country has its own set of eligibility criteria, procedures, and requirements for individuals seeking citizenship or residency. There is no gold standard here; neither does India have an obligation to follow in the footsteps of western nations. Asylum seekers may not have a precedence over other immigrants when it comes to naturalization eligibility but they do have priority access to certain humanitarian-based immigration programs, such as refugee resettlement or asylum protection in US. Discrimination? Not exactly! Just a policy based on “values“.

That said, I don’t see a reason why * anyone’s * path to citizenship should be expedited. Sure, without citizenship, they can’t vote, or hold public office, or have certain privileges that citizens do, but so what? Asylees are now in the country of their choice, not being persecuted and waiting in line to become citizens just like everyone else in the queue, right? What’s wrong with first come first served then?

@bold, as asylees, they are not eligible for purchasing property in here. They have difficulty in getting into educational institutes. They actually were able to get Covid vaccine after few deaths in camp (a person who died went twice for the vaccine but was returned both the times since he didn't have an Adhaar card)

citizenship is a must for them else they might die.

A person willing to get a citizenship can not be equated with someone who is living in sub human condition here only to evade persecution they face in their daily lives

Originally posted by: akrishna111

how is it good news? the law excludes muslims.

Persecuted religious minority in Pakistan, Afghanistan and Bangladesh. Where do Muslim the majority come into discussion here?

Pour in your views

Govt just gave the guidelines which they didn't did in 2019.

Good decision hope they stick to it.

Honestly CAA isn't even that big deal as it isn't about Indians.

Implementation of NRC will actually make a difference

Also

It is about those who are getting prosecuted in Muslims majority countries due to not being Muslims so Muslims can't be included.