Tum Bin or Lagaan: The better music album of 2001?

I have seen folks divided over this for the longest time.

Which one deserved the best music album of 2001: Lagaan or Tum Bin?

Lagaan swept away all music awards, but I feel Tum Bin was the best music album of 2001.

Each and every song in Tum Bin is a gem. TBH, even Kasoor, RHTDM, and Dil Chahta Hain were better than Lagaan.

Opinions, folks?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8MN2bxMiB9A

This one song makes Tum Bin worth winning...it's a song that haunts me to this day

Dharamsankat 🥴

But both albums are two entirely different genres. One is inspirational while the other one is absolutely romantic.

Originally posted by: 1t1svat1t1s

Dharamsankat 🥴

But both albums are two entirely different genres. One is inspirational while the other one is absolutely romantic.

I agree both albums are different genres but one has to objectively judge which one is better because ultimately it boils down to which one deserves the best music award. Melody over the genre.

Originally posted by: mintyblue

I agree both albums are different genres but one has to objectively judge which one is better because ultimately it boils down to which one deserves the best music award. Melody over the genre.

It’s too hard to pick only one winner from the movies you mentioned. I guess they just went with the popular choice. But even Gadar’s album was there in the contest and it became more popular than even Lagaan’s album. So really not sure why Lagaan swept all the awards when there were several able contestants.

more than that Suraj Huwa Madham deserved to win the award over mitwa,....Suraj Huwa Madham became one of the most iconic songs for srk

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L0zKs8i7Nc8

But the Tum Bin album is the best of 2001. Don't you agree?

Originally posted by: mintyblue

But the Tum Bin album is the best of 2001. Don't you agree?

anything over Lagan ....i hardly heard lagan songs ....infact 2001 chori chori chupke chupke , mujhe kuch kehna ha , pyar isqh aur mohabbat , yaadien, pyar tune kya kiya too had better songs than lagan ...

but yeah Tum Bin became cult music over period of time best of Nikhil Vinay

COMPLETELY AGREE!!!!

Only superb song in Lagaan is Radha Kaise Na Jale. That song is a masterpiece

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qNnvL0ztJhA!

I liked the Kasoor Songs

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GNAkcfeZIII