Lumos maxima=EXPELLED!

sherry

@charmedsherry

Inactive

8

Posted: 17 years ago

#1

another blooper i noticed in prisoner of azkaban.Witches and Wizards under 17 aren't allowed to do magic outside of school. It says so in the books and in the movies. Harry particularly reminded the minister of magic of that in the leaky couldron. Well, if so, why was he practicing Lumos Maxima in his bedroom? Why didn't he get expelled for doing so?

Anyway, obviously they did that so they'd have a cool intro. But, still....

Reply

Quote

Maryam

@-Precious

Dazzler

20

+ 2

Posted: 17 years ago

#2

i guess the spell lumos doesnt count for

bcoz even when the minister caught him he did not mention the lumos spell only swelling up his aunt

in the fifth book too when harry got the warning only the patronus charm was mentioned not the lunos spell and he did use that spelll

Reply

Quote

sherry

@charmedsherry

Inactive

8

Posted: 17 years ago

#3

Originally posted by: MyLuvRajat
i guess the spell lumos doesnt count for

bcoz even when the minister caught him he did not mention the lumos spell only swelling up his aunt

in the fifth book too when harry got the warning only the patronus charm was mentioned not the lunos spell and he did use that spelll

i dont think so...magic is magic! whether it is lumos or whatever

dobby cast a simple hover charm but still harry got caught

Reply

Quote

Just call me Chhilt :)

@chhilt

Rocker

25

Posted: 17 years ago

#4

this wasn't mentioned in the book... the movie makers threw that in and it's wrong... even in chamber of secrets movie... when the weasleys harry and hermione are shopping in diagon alley hermione repairs harry's glasses using "Reparo" they weren't at school yet so hermione should also have been expelled...

Edited by chhilt - 17 years ago

Reply

Quote

bitasta

@tukz_REmix

Rocker

25

Posted: 17 years ago

#5

Originally posted by: charmedsherry

i dont think so...magic is magic! whether it is lumos or whatever

dobby cast a simple hover charm but still harry got caught

yup u r rite...he shud hav been expleed...but dis was jsty nother cuttin-shuttin of d directrs....n dat wasnt in d actual stry

so plzzz dont oc**t n judge harry potter by movies

Reply

Quote

sherry

@charmedsherry

Inactive

8

Posted: 17 years ago

#6

dont be angry with me tukz ok?
no hard feelings 😳

Reply

Quote

bitasta

@tukz_REmix

Rocker

25

Posted: 17 years ago

#7

Originally posted by: charmedsherry
dont be angry with me tukz ok?
no hard feelings 😳

arrey y wil i b angry yaarcumon

Reply

Quote

vritika

@vrits

Inactive

8

Posted: 17 years ago

#8

well yes....the movies r ok but hv faults 😕

Reply

Quote

Maryam

@-Precious

Dazzler

20

+ 2

Posted: 17 years ago

#9

along with faults movies often dont show many imp. parts

Reply

Quote

344471

Suspended

Posted: 17 years ago

#10

Hmmmmmm....i think lumos isnt counted. It is written that "doing magic in the presence of a muggle is NOT allowed..". But when Harry did it, he was in his bad, wasnt he? No one was seeing him... 😕 😕 😕

And like everyone had said...the book is the real vertion not the movie 😳

Reply

Quote

Lumos maxima=EXPELLED!

Related Topics

Explore Topics